Correction April 28, 7:28 p.m. - The headline of this article was updated for clarity.
A few weeks ago, business manager for the Fry Daze of Vermont food truck Jessica Dickinson was ready to start a countdown on Facebook, counting down the days until opening.
But now, after a dispute around the truck’s permit, the future of the Fry Daze of Vermont food truck is uncertain.
On Tuesday, the Colchester selectboard refused to approve the truck’s peddlers permit, which gives them permission to operate in Colchester, per a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Department.
However, the town has approved the permit for a vendor in that space every year since at least 2012.
Fry Daze’s permit is now in limbo after the board determined on Tuesday night that the food truck — typically located near Bayside Park — is not in compliance with the town’s Site Plan Approval.
Planning and Zoning Director Cathyann LaRose recommended the selectboard deny the permit, but after a long discussion about the history of the property, the motivation for a denial and perceived inconsistencies in the enforcement of regulations, the selectboard tabled the decision.
Fry Daze’s inaugural season was just last year, when owner Stephen Harrington took on the food truck to fulfill a lifelong dream of owning an establishment, according to a 2021 Sun article.
Harrington said he bought the truck from Bill Sawyer in April of 2021.
However, according to the town, Harrington’s business was unknowingly violating zoning conditions that were approved in 2006.
The conditions listed in the board’s motion to deny the permit include:
In fact, in 2012 after violations of these conditions were observed, the Town of Colchester took the previous owner, Brian Billings, to court and entered into a settlement agreement with him.
That being said, every Peddlers Permit for this property that has come before the selectboard since that 2012 agreement has been approved despite no steps being taken by previous vendors to be in compliance with the zoning. It remains a little unclear why.
When the town receives a request for a peddlers permit, the permit is supposed to go through and obtain approval from various departments. The selectboard then either approves or disapproves the request.
For this permit however, in years past, that process was not done, Town Manager Aaron Frank said at the meeting. The selectboard, therefore, did not have all the information in order to make an informed decision and previous vendors were able to skirt the enforcement of regulations they were in violation of.
On Tuesday, selectboard members said that regardless of past decisions, with the information in front of them now there’s no way they could approve the permit for Fry Daze.
In a memo from LaRose recommending the denial, she writes that there is a legal obligation to comply with these conditions.
“While there is generally increased support for outdoor dining in the last few years, these are the conditions stipulated by the Town’s authoritative body and there is a legal obligation to comply unless they are changed,” the April 5 memo reads. “Should the applicant wish to amend any of these terms, they should apply for appropriate approvals.”
Selectboard Chair Pam Loranger said the situation is unfortunate.
“We’re all in agreement that we are in an unfortunate set of circumstances and yet here we are,” she said. “This selectboard on this day has a new set of facts that it did not have a year ago.”
Harrington said he had no idea about the regulations until he heard that his permit request was going to be denied. He expressed worry about the investment he’s made in his business and the complete surprise and shock about not being able to open yet.
“We’ve got $100,000 in this and we can’t open,” Harrington said in an April 28 interview.
Joe Handy, the landlord on the property who was a party in the 2012 court settlement, said that in the years after the settlement he checked in with the town and asked if they were going to enforce the agreement.
“They said, ‘we’re not going to do anything about it. It can stay there. It’s fine,’” Handy said.
Handy said he then forgot about it. However, before Harrington went and purchased the establishment, Handy advised Harrington to go to the town and ask if there were any issues.
Harrington said he went to the town and they told him there were none.
“We did not know about any sort of violations,” Harrington told the Sun. “If we did, I wouldn't have bought it.”
Fry Daze said they applied for the peddlers permit early in March this year with the hopes of opening earlier than usual.
When mid-April came around and Harrington hadn’t heard anything back from the town, he reached out and was then told about the selectboard meeting and the recommendation.
“There has been no precedent taken since 2012 in regard to this,” Harrington said at the meeting. “The truck hasn’t moved since 2012.”
Harrington said that if there was an issue last year he feels that they should have been told about it then.
In addition, in order to comply with the regulations some hefty changes to the actual structure of the establishment will have to be made.
Although Harrington contends that the truck is disconnected from direct sewer access, the truck is in no shape to be moved off the property nightly. Harrington said the engine hasn’t run since 2010.
Selectboard members Tom Mulcahy and Maureen Dakin agreed that Harrington’s problem is with the people who he bought it from who did not divulge the information that the truck was actively breaking regulations.
“Unfortunately, the statute says what the statute says and that’s the way it is and that’s the way this vote’s gonna go down,” Mulcahy said. “I think that the issue seems to be between yourselves and the people you purchased it from. If they did not divulge what you are going up against this evening, that’s a major problem.”
Harrington said at the meeting that he was looking for a way to resolve the issue.
“I understand you are bound by the statute, I get that,” Harrington said to the board. “But we are here, we didn’t know. We should be able to at least open with some sort of stipulation to get this resolved and we all work together. That’s the way it should be done, not a flat out denial. We should be able to work together on this. We are all supposed to be community members helping each other.”
In the end, the selectboard decided to table the vote in order to start a conversation with the Planning and Zoning Department and Fry Daze to find out if there is a solution to the problem.
This way the food truck’s request doesn’t get denied and a dialogue begins with the goal of resolving the situation.
However, in conversations since Harrington says things are at a stand still.
Harrington and LaRose met Wednesday morning but Harrington says he received a lot of the same answers.
In the meantime, Fry Daze is at a standstill although Dickinson says she gets messages all the time from people wondering when they are going to open.
“We’ve been getting all sorts of messages on Facebook asking ‘when are you opening?’ And I can’t tell them,” she told the Independent April 28.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here