COLCHESTER — The Group 19 merger committee discussed fair representation at its first meeting Wednesday, Sept. 30 at Colchester High School.
Representatives from the school districts in Colchester, Milton, Champlain Islands Unified Union School District, South Hero and Alburgh convened in accordance with Act 170, which requires all school districts to send a school board member to participate in regional merger studies with neighboring districts.
Each district is not required to merge but must actively participate in “good faith” discussions and generate a final report by Sept.1, 2027. Proposed mergers would then go to a vote on Town Meeting Day 2028.
South Hero representative Richard Monterosso read a letter at the beginning of the meeting advocating for more representation on the committee than one school board member per district.
He said his district, wants to have one representative per town to expand participation, distribute workflow and make sure no community is left behind.
“The facilitator has failed to recognize the duly-appointed members of this committee appointed by the Alburgh, South Hero and Champlain Islands Unified Union School Boards,” Monterosso said. “The Act 170 law clearly provides that school boards must appoint at least one member to merger committees, and contains no language limiting that number.”
Regional facilitator John Everitt said he would take the matter up with his supervisor.
“One of the things we want to make sure we do is move forward with as much input and community involvement as possible, because if we don't move forward in ways that make sense to our communities, we're wasting our time,” Everitt said.
Everitt said his role as regional facilitator involves keeping the committee on task, introducing topics and framing questions. Milton’s representative, Nick DeVita, was appointed chair of the committee.
Members also discussed what to do if some committee representatives are unable to attend a meeting. Monterosso argued for cancelling the meeting if there could not be 100% participation.
“Especially since we have an imbalance in terms of student populations…These decisions we make are very important to the communities that we represent,” he said. “The three districts from Grand Isle County have also appointed secondary representatives who can be available to fill in if that is permissible.”
Milton and Colchester had not appointed secondary representatives. Colchester representative Lindsey Cox said the committee should still be able to meet even if some representatives cannot make it, in order to complete the required report in an efficient manner.
“I think balancing that request with the timeline and requirement for the work we need to do and working in good faith may bump up against one another at times,” she said. “That would be my only concern. And we do have virtual participation as well.”
Everitt suggested the committee could meet and conduct business but not make any decisions without all districts present. The committee agreed to these terms.
The committee was instructed by Everitt to think about how their votes should be weighted between different districts for decisions. He said options could include weighing each vote by district population size or splitting it by the number of representatives, among other possibilities.
The population sizes of the districts included in merger Group 19 vary greatly. South Hero School District is the smallest with 222 students, followed by Alburgh with 283, Champlain Islands with 392, Milton with 1,465 and Colchester with 2,331.
Alburgh’s representative Cheryl Dunn said each representative should bring the decision for how to weigh votes back to their school boards for feedback.
Monterosso agreed the decision should be brought back to the school boards.
“My perpetual concern here still is that it shouldn't be falling on one rep, the percentage voting rate should be assigned to the district, and then the district can empower one rep or two reps to share that vote, depending on who's at the table that day,” he said.
Cox agreed and said it would be good to make the decision at the next meeting, considering this meeting’s agenda had no action items.
Everitt also tasked the committee to come up with a list of questions about how the merger could affect the committee's districts’ to consider during its deliberations for the next meeting, which will be warned on the districts’ websites at a later date.
11:30 a.m. Monday, Oct. 12 Editors Note: This article has been updated to correctly state Rich Monterosso's district affilation with South Hero and not with North Hero/Champlain Islands Unified Union School District.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here