COLCHESTER — The Colchester school board met Tuesday to talk about how the district is successfully boosting equitable outcomes for all students.
Director of curriculum and instruction Gwen Carmolli shared a presentation about the Vermont Comprehensive Assessment Program (VTCAP) tests given annually to students in the district and across Vermont to test their English Language Arts, math and science skills each spring. ELA and math are tested annually for grades 3-9, while science is tested during grades 5, 8 and 11.
Carmolli highlighted scores are trending upward in Colchester. In the 2025-2026 school year, 61% of grade 9 students were meeting or exceeding proficiency in math, compared to 47% in the 2023-2024 school year.
Grade 9 students also made strides in ELA with 63% meeting or exceeding proficiency in the 2025-2026 school year compared to 50% in the 2023-2024 school year.
“We also went up for each one of our equity cohort groups: poverty, disability, multilingual learners, and students of color,” Carmolli said. “So we were really excited to see that really nice growth, particularly for our students of color with English Language Arts.”
Students of color’s scores in ELA increased from 49% to 57% proficiency.
The school district will continue to support all students in improving their learning and scores, Carmolli said.
“It's important that we had decreases in our achievement gaps in almost every equity cohort, in every content area,” she said. “It was slightly larger in English Language Arts for our students with disabilities, and for that particular equity cohort, but every other one, every content area, and every equity cohort, so we're really excited to see that amount of progress in decreasing the achievement gaps while we're still increasing [overall] achievement.”
While it is easy to close achievement gaps by lowering standards for all, the district has been keeping the standards high for all, Carmolli added.
The district has been assessing growth constantly with “exit tickets,” low stakes exams at the end of class to assess learning completed that day, and student projects are used to measure student progress outside of the VTCAPs.
School board chair Lindsey Cox asked what the biggest surprise was in the data for Carmolli.
“I would say an increase for our equity cohorts across ELA, math, science, and then the improvement of the achievement gap,” she said. “It was just a combination of so much exciting growth.”
VTCAP is taken on the computer and students are able to utilize accommodations if necessary.
“If you ask our school administrators, it takes about three weeks to do the full administration,” she said. “I think on the student end, it is a disruption from their regular learning, which is a little bit frustrating. So, we work really hard to plan, and each school plans it in a slightly different way to meet the needs of learners and their school schedules to the best of their ability.”
CHI-20 Representative Doug Bishop (D-Vt.) asked as a member of the public how different regions and states assess these academic skills compared to Vermont.
The testing philosophy in Vermont is fairly similar to the National Assessment of Educational Progress which is done for all fourth-graders across the country, Carmolli said.
“For the statewide assessment for each state, they set up their own and they design them, or they're in a consortium that designs it,” she said. “I would say it ranges from light comprehension to deep comprehension. Ours happens to go into the deeper comprehension component, and so that's really based on the state standards the state has selected.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here