COLCHESTER — What does it mean to be a student musician in Vermont? This year has shown that among other things, it means sending handwritten notes to Secretary of Education Dan French, begging him to allow indoor music practice.
At the start of the 2020-21 school year, guidance from the Vermont Agency of Education disallowed singing and the practice of wind instruments indoors, in an effort to curb the spread of COVID-19.
But Colchester High School students did their own research about Coronavirus transmission, and with support from CHS Choral Director Melissa Towle, started a letter-writing campaign, trying to convince the AOE to update. their guidance.
Katie Hayes, a student at CHS, said she supported and participated in the letter campaign.
“I agreed with [Towle's] reasoning of it being letters: with a solid amount of us doing it, the letters with the same request would pile up and show that there were quite a few of us who wanted change,” she said. “I think it ended up working quite well.”
Music students’ efforts weren’t enough until early January 2021, when talks about allowing indoor practice started occuring.
At the start of this school year, musicians at CHS practiced outdoors under large tents around the school.
Once the weather started to cool off in late November, practices moved inside, then ceased to happen at all, due to guidelines from the Agency of Education.
A parent of a CHS music student voiced her opinion on the treatment of Vermont musicians throughout the pandemic.
“It made me concerned that the school district was treating the music programs as second class and as less important than sports programs,” she said. “While I understand that sports are an integral part of the school experience, students who are involved in music programs deserve to have the same amount of consideration paid to them as the sports programs do.”
Instead of practicing their vocals and instruments, choir and band students alike worked on theory and rhythm practice indoors during in-person class time until mid January, when things started to shift.
Students in select ensembles, like Chamber and Chorale had been humming inside for longer, as there wasn’t much other work they could do. A lot of the actual practice of their pieces was done at home, and a few virtual choir pieces were produced during the winter months.
Students recorded their individual parts of a song at home, and then submitted them using a music software program. All parts were lined up, balanced and tweaked until the more than 20 voices sounded like just one. The end product was like a real concert, just on screens at home instead of right in front of audience members.
Hayes said she felt the performing arts were undersupported for most of the year.
“It was very showing of the priorities of people in positions of power when we asked why and the response we got was ‘Sports being an integral part of our community and to still be able to offer scholarships like every other year,’” she said. “I understand the points they were trying to make, but their logic falls apart when you remember the exact reasons they gave work for music too.”
Towle also said the state’s decision to disallow singing and music-making indoors felt like an insult.
“It felt insulting to our students, and I don't take this too much personally, I feel like the students are the ones being let down,” she said. “There was considerable pushback from communities all over the state that said no, this is not okay. And this is not equity. This is not equity.”
Another CHS student, Leanne Winchester, explained how frustrating this process felt to many students.
“It felt incredibly frustrating, like we were being completely ignored by the state,” she said. “I understand they had a lot on their plate, but I feel we should’ve taken up a little more of it.”
CHS Band Director Evan Peltier was also disheartened by the way COVID restrictions limited musicians’ practices.
“Then the winter came and two weeks in I just got this feeling like, 'Oh man, this is what it's going to be like for who knows how long.' And that was really, really kind of depressing,” he said.
Towle and Peltier soon realized there was a silver lining to not being allowed to practice indoors.
Peltier said the pandemic gave him a chance to dive in depth into what’s behind the music, not just learning and performing it.
“The focus on composition and theory was something we’d always flirted with, but with concerts always looming over us, it felt like we never had enough time to really dive as deep as we would’ve liked,” he said. “It felt like I was teaching a completely different class.”
As with the choirs, band students had to spend in-person class time learning theory, rhythm and other ‘behind the music’ curriculum pieces.
“It really felt like both Mrs. Towle and I had to come up with drastically different curriculums, just to get the students doing something meaningful,” Peltier said. “We weren't able to perform together and not knowing when we'd be allowed to do that. That was the agonizing part, the uncertainty.”
In addition, both directors also did lots of advocacy at the state level to try and speed-up the process to get indoor practice in Vermont schools.
“I myself did lots of advocacy,” Towle said. “That included encouraging my students to write letters to Secretary French, asking parents to write letters and emails to Secretary French. I posted on my social media. I did everything I could.”
Now, as spring slowly starts rolling in, things are looking up for Vermont musicians. Indoor singing and playing of instruments is allowed, with certain mitigation measures still in place to keep everyone safe.
Those measures include: six feet between musicians, disposable masks and only 30 minutes of practice in any space.
With all the trials and tribulations Vermont musicians have faced this year, they finally get to share their beloved arts with others. Towle will host an outdoor concert for her ensembles on June 9 at Colchester High School.
Peltier and his bands will also have an outdoor concert on June 4 at CHS.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here