The Colchester School Board unanimously approved a $40.57 million budget proposal for fiscal year 2019, a 3.67 percent increase over the previous year that would prompt an estimated 10.18 percent tax increase.
The owner of a $300,000 home who does not qualify for income sensitivity would see a $444 tax increase if the proposal passes. But superintendent Amy Minor said only a small portion of the double-digit spike is in the local district’s hands.
“Your estimated school tax rate is not just paying for taxes in Colchester,” Minor said. “It’s funding every school in the state of Vermont.”
Local budget deliberations at board meetings over the last few months have largely centered on an unusually large cohort of students set to enter the Colchester Middle School next year.
Grades 6, 7 and 8 currently have 158, 159 and 147 students, respectively. That means core classes house somewhere between 24 and 27 students under the current configuration. State education quality standards suggest a maximum of 24 students per core class teacher.
The current grade 4 and 5 cohorts, however, each hold more than 170 pupils. The 20-student bump would push core class sizes to 29 or 30 in grade 6 if staffing numbers were kept constant.
“If we were below the education quality standards, it would have made it much easier to absorb a larger class,” Minor said. “But because we are already above the education quality standards, it makes it that much more challenging.”
The problems that arise from unusually large class sizes are twofold, Minor said. For one, many classrooms simply aren’t big enough to accommodate 30 kids at once.
It also limits opportunities for one-on-one instruction. This is especially problematic at the middle school, where standardized test scores fell below or just slightly above state averages last year, Minor noted.
“What we have seen over the last three years [is] a significant decline in the student performance at the middle school,” Minor said. “Typically, in the other grades Colchester performs in the top quarter of scores.”
Board members were initially drawn to a proposal that added 2.2 full-time positions to grade six.
But the add pushed the per-pupil spending increase (the percentage displayed on the ballot) to 3.23 percent, a figure that prompted trepidation among several board members.
School officials then crafted a modified option, reducing one full-time staffer from a different section of the district. Moving to a 1.2 net addition (about $90,000) brought the estimated per-pupil spending down to 2.99 percent.
The board opted to discuss that hybrid scenario in private at their last meeting and emerged with unanimous agreement. The staff member in question has not yet been informed of the possible cut, Minor said.
“Sixth grade is a huge transition year, and it’s an incredibly important year of education for students,” board member Lindsey Cox said at a previous meeting. “I think it’s really important that we give those students the best opportunity for learning and support.”
Gov. Phil Scott made headlines when he asked districts with declining enrollment to “level-fund” their budgets late last year. To achieve a 0 percent increase in Colchester, Minor said the district would have to cut $1.3 million — about 17 full-time employees.
Yet enrollment is actually flat, not declining, in Colchester. The board therefore supported some significant staffing cuts in this proposal, notably eliminating two paraeducators and two behavior interventionists, but declined to pursue the state’s “not a penny more” recommendation.
Minor said the district was then disappointed to learn the state-determined “dollar yield amount” and the town’s common level of appraisal had fallen significantly for FY19.
The two levers have a significant impact on local tax rates when plugged into the education funding formula along with the school’s budget increase. This year, Minor said even a 0 percent budget increase in Colchester would have brought a 5.5 percent school tax hike for residents.
The state could make the decision to change its dollar yield amount after Town Meeting Day, just as it did last year. Voters approved a budget resulting in an estimated 3.89 percent tax rate increase on Town Meeting Day 2017. After votes were cast, though, the number fell to 2.89 percent.
Communications specialist Meghan Baule said the complex (and potentially fluid) formula makes a solid community outreach program all the more important. They plan to film short budget videos, host public roundtable discussions and mail out their annual report to the community in the coming weeks.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here