The Bayside Hazelett land parcel could be a good fit for a potential on-site community septic system, according to an investigation undertaken by the planning commission in their search for wastewater solutions.
After the failed sewer line vote in March earlier this year, the town selectboard charged the planning commission with finding a wastewater solution, kicking off a summer filled with public forums, surveys, research, and workshops all focused on wastewater. The commission has narrowed possible solutions down to three— extending sewer service to the bay, community septic, and land conservation—with a fourth, ‘do nothing’ option, as a sort of control.
At the last planning commission meeting on Aug. 20, the commission heard from hydrogeologist Craig Heindel who investigated whether the town-owned Bayside Hazelett land parcel would be able to sustain on-site septic. The planning commission looked to the town-owned land parcel because it falls within the study area laid out by the selectboard. While some residents at the meeting raised questions about examining alternative sites outside of the study area, the planning commission reiterated that it wasn’t possible within the narrow nature of their scope.
Hydrogeologist Craig Heindel surveyed the land and began the meeting by jumping straight to his conclusion. “The site has plenty of capacity for 100,000 gallons per day,” he said. “120,000 gpd are likely available and permit-able.” This amount would accommodate the 200 houses identified within the area at risk around Inner Malletts Bay. Heindel noted that his conclusion came with caveats and that his was a guesstimate based on professional experience at a similar site and evaluation of data from surrounding properties.
He noted that two forms of on-site wastewater disposal would be appropriate for the site: drip dispersal or a conventional leach field. Both are considered indirect discharge systems, meaning that wastewater joins groundwater, eventually discharging into streams, rivers, or lakes. Under indirect discharge regulations, tertiary treatment is required for processing of over 50,000 gpd. This adds additional nutrient removal, including phosphorus and nitrogen which are naturally occurring nutrients that pose a risk to Lake Champlain.
“It’s expensive,” Heindel said bluntly, in discussing what tertiary treatment would add to the cost of an on-site septic system. The total estimated construction cost would amount to $17,450,000, including a sewer collection system, a wastewater treatment facility, design, and permitting, among other things. The only way to avoid tertiary treatment would be to decrease the amount of wastewater going through the system to below 50,000 gpd.
Director of Planning and Zoning Sarah Hadd also noted the difference in cost compared to other options being considered—next to the sewer option, community septic with tertiary treatment would cost several million more.
In a drip dispersal system which was discussed in detail at a septic workshop in early July, the potential system would be able to snake around existing trees in the Bayside Hazelett land parcel and follow the contours of the land. “It’s like a fancy version of your homestyle drip system for irrigation of your garden,” Heindel said. The land parcel has “lots of big, gorgeous trees,” he continued, noting how in a leach field system, all of those trees would have to be removed. He also noted that in a drip dispersal system, there would be good phosphorus remediation and that the surrounding trees could aid in uptake.
In moving forward, he raised concerns about a steep sloped portion of the Bayside Hazelett parcel that would need to be addressed, even if the potential septic system is scrapped. “It could be a year, it could be 30 years, but that slope is going to migrate south towards East Lakeshore Drive. If you did nothing, in 50 to 100 years, I could almost guarantee you that it could take a portion of E. Lakeshore Dr. It could be made more unstable by introducing wastewater upgradient of that.”
Former selectboard member and current member of Friends of Malletts Bay, Jack Scully, proposed a situation which would allow multiple small scale on-site septic systems to accommodate the area. Scully noted that the permitting process would be reduced and the amount of water treated would hit below the regulatory mark of 50,000, meaning that tertiary treatment would not be required. Hadd reiterated that the planning commission identified 200 properties to be at risk and that more research and consideration of variables was outside of the planning commission scope.
The Bayside Hazelett land parcel is also actively being considered by the selectboard and parks and recreation department as the site of a town park.
Hadd noted that in lieu of a meeting next month, the planning commission will be taking an all-day tour of some on-site septic sites around the state, including a large leach field at Sugarbush which receives tertiary treatment. If interested in joining the tour, email Sarah Hadd at shadd@colchestervt.gov.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here