SOUTH BURLINGTON — Champlain Water District referred the Village of Westbury in its pursuit of wholesale water rates to the Town of Colchester at a CWD meeting earlier this month.
Being beholden solely to the town’s water rates would leave the Village in a tough spot, given the town’s past resistance to the Village’s goal of leveraging a municipal status to address financial concerns. The move on CWD’s part renders the Village of Westbury the only existing municipality served by CWD to be denied a request for discounted water rates.
Historically, municipalities have been granted wholesale rates by the provider, CWD, and sell water to their individual clients at a retail price in order to fund infrastructure maintenance.
At this point, there has not been a formal vote on the part of the CWD commissioners, and the Village still intends to pursue the direct avenue with CWD further for subsequent conversations.
Discussions about water rates between Westbury and CWD have been ongoing since late 2022, and well before the Dec. 17 meeting, the water district had previously indicated it would not be supportive of Westbury’s request via severalletters from early 2023, though Village residents remained hopeful this position would change as they furthered the discussion this month.
The Village formed last year around a mobile home park in Colchester in an effort to pursue equitable access for its working class residents to basic necessities. Currently, the entirety of Westbury pays a retail rate, which not only covers their own water service, but also goes toward repairing other pipes in town — while Westbury lacks access to that fund for pipe maintenance.
In other words, right now Westbury residents and other Colchester residents pay the same rate on water, but hundreds of Westbury residents’ retail water dollars are being used to supplement the repairs on water pipes elsewhere in town, without receiving that same support in return.
This is because they are viewed as all being residents of one property, formerly Westbury Park — even though there are numerous residents with their own homes there, with over seven miles of associated pipes currently going unserviced.
Despite the obstacles that have come up along the way, Westbury residents believe their relatively-new status as a village rather than a privately-owned mobile home park should make it possible to reframe the situation and make more equitable their pay-in.
It is precisely this discrepancy — and Westbury’s new status as an outlier among other municipalities in being the only one in known history to be denied municipal membership access to discounted water rates by CWD — that’s led village leaders to deem this an equity issue.
The co-op and the residents contribute about $300,000 annually in taxes paid to the town, according to Gayle Pezzo, Westbury’s co-op president and a recently-elected state representative for Colchester. Yet Westbury residents are now worried about how to manage their own aging water infrastructure and future maintenance costs.
An online petition seeking support for the Champlain Water District to reassess their share of the cost has by the time of publication amassed 179 signatures.
If the Village were charged wholesale rates, it could then charge its residents the retail rate and use the difference to maintain and upgrade its physical infrastructure — as all other municipalities supplied by the water district are able to do already.
Residents more fully delved into their concerns in a video included in the materials delivered to the commissioners in advance of the meeting. In that video, longtime affordable housing advocate Erhard Mahnke of Burlington referred to the effort by Westbury to secure a municipal water rate “a matter of environmental and economic justice.”
One caveat is that CWD currently owns and operates Colchester’s water systems, on account of a fragmented municipal management system breaking down in past years within the town.
CWD leaders do not wish to become more involved in Colchester’s water system management dynamics — and although the town has not yet committed to doing so, folks at CWD are hopeful they can wipe their hands of it when the town at some point takes over a merged system.
General Manager for CWD, Joe Duncan, has said time and time again that CWD is not in the business of owning water systems, and does not practice this anywhere else. It only stepped in to take over Colchester’s system because had it not done so temporarily when the fragmented management system broke down, the town’s water supply would have been jeopardized.
With this latest discussion opened by Village Clerk Libby Payne and led by Colchester resident Ralph Perkins on behalf of the Village, the meeting, held Dec. 17, involved about an hour of back-and-forth among Perkins, CWD board commissioners and Duncan.
About a dozen Westbury residents were also in attendance in support of the Village’s cause.
As stated by Duncan himself in a video clip of Duncan’s testimony before the U.S. Senate, played back to him by village leaders at CWD’s meeting earlier this month: Communities must have the ability to modernize their infrastructure — a belief shared by Payne and the Village.
In Westbury’s case, much of said infrastructure is approaching or past the time of its useful life.
“The Village of Westbury was created by residents in the Westbury neighborhood to address municipal services the town of Colchester has indicated they cannot provide,” Perkins said. “And also to find municipal solutions for typically-municipal infrastructure that the co-op [had] accepted ownership of when the residents were fighting to save the park from developers.”
Now, Pezzo, says the co-op is finalizing a legal transfer of Westbury’s water infrastructure from the hands of the co-op over to the purview of the Village, in an effort to utilize its new municipal management structures to the benefit of the Village residents.
“It appears CWD and Westbury Village are exactly on the same page in regards to providing clean water to all customers,” Pezzo told the Sun after the meeting. “However, it seems as though Westbury Village continues to be overlooked as part of the larger conversation.”
“This entire issue has never been about handouts or making an exception,” she added, alluding to the historical practice of providing municipalities with member-rates. “It has always been about equitable water rates for the Municipal Village of Westbury and to be treated fairly.”
Westbury’s water system is similar in size to over 95% of public water systems, Payne said at the start of the meeting, and the Village of Westbury’s population alone is larger than that of roughly 50 full-sized towns in Vermont.
But ultimately, CWD’s intention to decline the provision of wholesale rates on water to the Village stems from CWD’s new policy, stating CWD functions to provide wholesale water exclusively to town- and city-owned distribution systems — in this case, the broader municipality enveloping the incorporated municipal village being Colchester.
CWD expects the village and town to work out relational issues and financial arrangements on their own.
Although the fire district that used to manage Westbury’s water system has disbanded, CWD continues to view the Village as a customer of Colchester’s Fire District #3.
When the four of Colchester’s fragmented and functionally disbanded systems in Colchester are effectively merged, CWD maintains that Westbury will be a traditional, retail-rate customer of that merged distribution system, which CWD hopes will be owned and operated by the Town.
CWD only provides the wholesale rate to its whole served systems, and not to individual customers of served systems, Duncan told the Sun. This would not change if the Town of Colchester were to take over the merged distribution system in the next three or so years.
The large town- and city-owned distribution systems aspect of this language specifically, referenced by Duncan as reasoning to not move forward, is relatively new — as of a CWD policy change made in June.
The policy change was not made until after CWD had been made aware of Westbury’s intention to obtain wholesale water rates, with its recently-earned status as a municipality. Previously, wholesale water was offered by precedent to municipalities generally.
However, Duncan told the Sun in an email at the time of the change that although rate offerings were historically at the discretion of CWD’s board of commissioners, the policy change had nothing to do with the Village’s pursuits.
In Duncan’s first-ever meeting with Westbury residents, in December of 2022, he had presented the process used to add the Town of Milton and Village of Jericho as member municipalities, indicating there was a path, but that it’d require approval from CWD’s board of commissioners.
“I did not say whether the path was doable because I had not received the Board’s formal position going into my first meeting with [Westbury],” he told the Sun. “Ultimately our experience with small villages and fire districts and hindsight from past precedent led the CWD Board to not support giving Westbury the wholesale water rate.”
Still, Duncan told the Sun the formal policy change made this past June only served to formalize its existing practices, stating the timing of the policy change in relation to their knowledge of Westbury’s pursuits was entirely coincidental.
The existing, though no-longer-functional, fire districts in Colchester used to separately manage Colchester’s water systems and were allowed to relieve wholesale water rates from CWD at the time that CWD was first created in the 1970s, Duncan told the Sun.
“Over time, we have experienced that water systems operated by small villages and fire districts are not sustainable,” Duncan stated in an email to the Sun. “That is why CWD now owns four water systems in the Town of Colchester.”
CWD’s practices and policies have evolved over time, he said, as a result of its historical experience with the Town of Colchester’s broken utility management system.
“We believe town-wide, locally-owned distribution systems are required to provide long term sustainable water service,” Duncan stated. “For this reason, we are planning to merge our four Colchester water systems and transfer that merged system to the Town of Colchester.”
“[The] bottom line is that CWD made decisions in its infancy that allowed for small villages or fire districts to [function as] served systems within the district, and over time we realized that those municipal structures were not sustainable,” he added. “CWD is working to correct that by creating one merged system in Colchester and turning it over to the Town.”
Westbury residents characterize their Home Owners’ Association as an entirely separate and unrelated entity from their incorporated municipal village. However, the folks behind CWD continue to characterize them jointly.
Duncan said he believes “allowing a Home Owners’ Association that has become a municipal village” to become a member municipality of CWD sets a precedent contrary to CWD’s goals — as it would continue to fracture the town structures CWD feels are critical for the long-term operation of a water system.
Duncan and CWD’s board also fear that if this sort of precedent were set via cooperation with Westbury, it would open the door for this sort of thing to occur with other small communities throughout CWD’s existing member municipalities.
However, Perkins said the Village of Westbury is in a unique enough position that its results are not easily replicable, based on state statute granting existing municipalities the right to require existing customers to remain connected to their systems — individual customers of a town’s water system can’t leave a system to form a municipality just to request discounted service.
Colchester is the only town served by CWD without its own existing town-owned water system. Westbury’s residents maintain their position is also uniquely distinct from that of other mobile home parks in Colchester.
There’s an additional layer of security in most of CWD’s partnering town ordinances as well.
Furthermore, there is historical precedent in support of a rare situation like the Village of Westbury’s. In the only other instance in which a small village municipality requested to become a member municipality to receive wholesale rates on CWD water the request was granted.
In 1990, the Village of Jericho water system wanted to connect to the CWD system. There was a desire by CWD to have the Town of Jericho be the member municipality. Due to political issues between the Village and the Town, CWD allowed the Village of Jericho to do so.
Outside of CWD’s original members established in 1973, the Town of Milton and Village of Jericho are the only two systems that ever previously requested to become member municipalities. In turn, they received the wholesale rate.
It had one industrial user request the wholesale rate: Global Foundries, formerly known as IBM — and CWD declined the request, viewing them as a customer of the City of Essex Junction.
The difference in Westbury’s eyes is its municipal status as a village, rather than a corporation.
Although Duncan and the board voiced a general opposition to granting the Village’s request, no formal vote was taken on the matter, and Duncan said he expects further discussion to come.
“What was an interesting comment made by one of the commissions that spoke about the unfairness to others if Westbury were to receive the wholesale rate, suggesting that the savings would need to be distributed to the others and that would be unfair,” Pezzo later told the Sun.
“It was a great point because in my opinion, it emphasized the point we have been trying to make all along,” she added. “It isn't fair that Westbury is paying the retail price for all others who receive services to their water system [while] Westbury receives none of those services to the Westbury water system.”
Perkins told the Sun in an interview following the meeting that he was appreciative of CWD’s time and willingness to engage. He respects CWD’s commitment to the system’s integrity and is optimistic that all parties involved will find a solution that works at some point in the future.
Perkins and the villagers feel that at this point in time, there is still more discussion to be had with CWD.
Although this December meeting did not go the way Westbury residents had hoped, leaders of the charge are looking at this as fuel for a continued climb towards equitable treatment — rather than as a set-back.
“I am not discouraged,” Pezzo said. “I just needed to clear my mind a bit to get it ready for the next steps.”
More information with respect to the Village residents’ rationale can be found here.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here