Vermont Treasurer Mike Pieciak presents medical debt relief program proposal

Posted

MONTPELIER — A state and nonprofit partnership intends to use $1 million of state funds to eliminate up to $100 million of Vermonters’ medical debt. 

Pending its passage, Vermonters will be eligible for relief if they have patient accounts that have reached “terminal bad status” and are in households at or below 400% of the Federal Poverty Level, or that owe medical debt equal to or exceeding 5% of household income. 

Medical debt is a poor indicator of creditworthiness, so in addition to relieving debt, the proposal would remove adverse information resulting from medical debt from a consumer credit report. 

The Federal Government recently took similar action to eliminate the impact of medical debt on Americans’ credit scores, but uncertainties created by the recent change in the federal administration renders it important for states to act independently to protect their residents, said State Treasurer Mike Pieciak at a press conference about the proposal Tuesday morning. 

From a podium at the Vermont Statehouse, Pieciak said Vermont’s medical debt relief program would come at no extra cost to eligible Vermonters and with no new taxes or fees on Vermonters at large, financed instead by reappropriating a small portion of funds previously assigned to the Treasurer’s office for the purpose of buying down outstanding state bonds. 

Lead legislative sponsors of the initiative are Sen. Ginny Lyons (D-Williston), chair of Vermont’s Senate committee on health and welfare, and Rep. Alyssa Black (D-Essex), chair of the Vermont House committee on healthcare. 

“Medical debt is a pervasive problem in the United States, and continues to rank as the number one reason for household bankruptcy here in Vermont,” Pieciak said at the press conference. “It's estimated that over 60,000 individuals hold some form of medical debt, impacting over one in 10 adults in our state.” 

“Medical debt is also unique and unlike other types of consumer debt,” he added. “It’s often the result of an unexpected cost following a medical crisis, putting people into debt through no fault of their own.” 

Unlike other types of consumer debt, people often have no idea what the cost of medical care will be before they receive it, and typically have no say in the cost or ability to negotiate or shop around. Medical debt is an economic issue as well as a public health issue, he said, and can be a drag on a family's finances with potential to create significant barriers to upward mobility — not only for that debt itself, but also as a result of credit score impacts to other interest rates. 

Medical debt is also the leading cause of bankruptcy in the U.S. as a whole, burdening 41% of all Americans. People with medical debt are more likely to forego medical attention and have difficulty paying for other basic needs. 

In a Vermont Department of Health survey, 85,000 Vermonters said the fear of medical debt impacts their decision to get medical care. People who hold medical debt often feel shame around their debt, and they put off the care they need, leading to worse physical health outcomes, worse mental health and greater cost to ultimately treating their underlying condition. 

The partner nonprofit for the proposal, Undue Medical Debt, has a track record of eliminating nearly $15 billion of medical debt nationwide. If the legislation passes in Vermont, they would be specifically aiding moderate and low-income Vermonters who hold older medical debt. 

“This program will have a big impact without carrying a big price tag, wiping out an estimated $100 million in medical debt with a relatively small investment of $1 million,” Pieciak said. “The program is automatic. There's no need for people to apply, no forms, no hassle.” 

“I view this as the government working at its best,” he said. 

The way the dollar amounts shuffle out, a little goes a long way in this instance thanks to the work of Undue Medical Debt negotiating with providers — bargaining down the cost of people’s debt in exchange for paying off debts that were unlikely to otherwise be paid down at all. 

“The benefits of this proposal will be felt in every corner of the state,” Pieciak said. “Our focus on low- and moderate-income Vermonters means that we will have an outsized impact on more rural parts of Vermont, which tend to be the more impoverished parts of our communities.” 

Pieciak characterizes the proposal — which has the potential to help thousands of Vermonters if passed — as a step in the right direction, rather than a silver bullet. 

“The proposal will not eliminate all medical debt, and while this program will help address the high costs and the impact of high costs of health care, it does not address the underlying problem of these high costs to receive health care in Vermont,” he said. 

Pieciak was joined at the podium on Tuesday by Rhode Island Treasurer James Diossa, who has seen similar legislation already be implemented in his state; Vermont Legal Air healthcare advocate Mike Fisher; Heather Bauman, AFT Vermont’s local president for UVM Medical Center Support Staff United; Mike del Trecco, president and CEO for the Vermont Association of Hospitals and Health Systems; and Katie Van Haste of U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders’ office. 

Other states which have medical debt relief programs and proposals in the works beyond Rhode Island include Arizona, Connecticut, New Jersey, Illinois, Pennsylvania and Washington D.C. 

When asked about his confidence in the plausibility of this initiative materializing in Vermont, given the end to the Democratic supermajority in the legislature following November’s election, Pieciak, a Democrat himself, expressed confidence in the topic’s prevalence across the aisle. 

“We've had conversations with the Governor's team,” he said. “We hope to make the bill bipartisan in both the Senate and the House, and we’re going to continue to talk with the Governor about it… That’s our hope, to get that bipartisan support.” 

A bill associated with the proposal is being worked on and is expected to be read in the state legislature formally later this week.

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here