Vermont Futures Projects puts out action plan: Here’s what you need to know

Posted

After years of compiling research and spreading awareness about the possible futures Vermont has in store, the Vermont Futures Project released an action plan, aiming to secure a bright one. 

Published this past January, the plan is a comprehensive, data-informed roadmap designed to address the state’s workforce and housing challenges and secure a prosperous future — shaped by public engagement with over 5,000 Vermonters across all 14 counties. 

The plan puts a focus on actionable strategies for recruiting and retaining working-aged people, increasing labor market participation, expanding housing and infrastructure and aligning policies with evolving community needs. 

Kevin Chu, executive director of the Vermont Futures Project, said Vermonters have spoken up this last year about the affordability challenges in particular. 

The scarcity approach toward affordability would be to cut services, close hospitals and consolidate schools — the latter of which has already begun under Gov. Phil Scott. Chu sees short-term savings in school consolidation, but also some potential long-term consequences and a foreshadowing of the loss of other local resources, like health and community centers. 

But the action plan provides an alternative path: accelerating growth and embracing abundance. 

The bottom line is, if Vermonters want a lower cost of living, they simply can’t do nothing. 

"Vermont is a leading indicator for the country in terms of the economic impacts of demographics and housing scarcity,” Chu said. “Data isn’t destiny. If we don’t like where the trend lines are going, we can do something about it.” 

Key goals: Targets for 2035 

Overall, the plan lays out four main goals for Vermont:

  • Population Growth: Increase Vermont’s population to 802,000 residents.

  • Workforce Engagement: Raise the labor force participation rate to 70%.

  • Housing Expansion: Increase Vermont’s non-seasonal housing stock to 350,000.

  • Efficient Development: Reduce development timelines and regulatory costs by 40%. 

“This process over the past two years not only was to bring information out to communities, but also to listen to the hopes, dreams and ambitions of Vermonters, to understand what are their challenges today, and where would they like to see the state in the future,” Chu said of the plan. 

“And that's where we heard loud and clear that the status quo is not sustainable,” he added. 

The framework for the plan focuses on people and places, through categorized strategies related to efficiency and expansion. For instance, increasing the labor force participation rate for efficiency, and increasing the labor force working age population for expansion. 

These strategies must work in conjunction with one another for the plan to be viable. 

As an example, we know that median household size goes down as a population ages, and that a large number of Vermonters are now aging in households too large for their wants or needs. 

An expansion strategy to address this could be developing new housing to meet the needs of aging Vermonters, which would serve simultaneously as an efficiency strategy, because it’d open up more single-family homes to younger Vermonters looking to start or raise families. 

But building more housing at an ideal rate requires more workers than are currently available, partly because there is not enough housing to house more workers, leaving Vermont in what many view to be a sticky sort of chicken-or-the-egg situation. 

“This is where some creative, innovative thinking can be really helpful to get us unstuck,” Chu said. “I was chatting with a friend of mine, a Bosnian refugee. He works in development now, and he has family who still lives in Bosnia. They travel around Europe seasonally to help build homes in other countries. And we were thinking: Why doesn't Vermont try a similar strategy?” 

Vermont already has temporary and seasonal workers in the healthcare, agricultural, recreation and tourism industries, so perhaps there is a model by which this could be implemented for trades and construction. 

Vermont State University has a lot of extra capacity on its campuses right now, which are 30% overbuilt on average and have even more capacity during summer when students are away, Chu said — and conversations are underway with VSU about leveraging some of that capacity to support partnerships that house seasonal workers who are expanding permanent housing. 

Chu personally has been invited to testify a number of times at the statehouse and said legislators are paying attention and wanting to learn more. So Chu’s role is to set the stage — but the plan’s success can’t be fueled by him alone. 

Shifting to achieve the above will require incremental progress of 2% population and housing growth annually over the next decade. And any statewide action plan requires collaboration to accomplish. So the Vermont Futures Project has emphasized a shared responsibility for residents, visitors, businesses, educational partners and policymakers. 

Personalizing the plan 

“It can feel overwhelming when we only focus on the big numbers, and we're talking about targets that are 10-15, years down the line,” Chu said. “I think it's a bit more sort of encouraging to just focus on, ‘What can I do as an individual in the place that I live.’” 

So to reach some of these long term goals, Vermont would only have to grow by 2% annually, Chu reiterated, which at the hyperlocal level substantially changes the conversation and the thinking to: “How can I show up and do my 2% in my community?” 

A town of 1,000 people, for instance, has to create the conditions to welcome 20 new people to town next year. That might mean building eight to 10 homes if everyone can just embrace the incremental growth mindset, fostering transformative change when done all across the state. 

Though “not-in-my-backyard”-ism remains prevalent across a number of Vermont’s rural communities, a Vermont Futures poll found that 60% of people support new housing to increase the population in Vermont and 57% were in support of doing so in their towns. 

“We need to find a way to empower the yes voices,” Chu said. “There needs to be more intentionality about including the supportive voices in these public processes and the burden of appeal [needs to be redistributed].” 

If a project gets delayed and costs go up because that project takes three to five extra years as a result of red tape raised by complainants, then those extra costs then get passed on to the people who are seeking housing. 

“That burden of the cost, it doesn't rest on the people that are saying no. They can say no all they want, with very, very little skin in the game,” Chu said. “Vermonters are already saying the cost of housing is too expensive, so by streamlining some of these processes and regulations, we can actually bring down the cost of developing new housing.” 

A big step in the right direction would be to reconfigure policies to start with yes as the default. 

“This plan is not the end, it's the starting point for the next phase,” Chu said. “Folks should see the recommendations in this plan as guiding principles, and there will likely be more ideas that emerge. There's always more data to analyze… So be ready for more.” 

This plan calls to action all Vermonters in joining this effort, by welcoming new residents, fostering inclusive communities, supporting growth initiatives and policies and beyond. 

But where does that leave local leaders? And what do folks in development think of all this? 

Expanding housing 

Charlie Baker, executive director for Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission, has been following the work of the Vermont Futures Project for quite some time. The CCRPC works to plan healthy economic development and support efficient transportation in Chittenden County. 

Baker has welcomed Chu to CCRPC meetings within the last year and likes to think the work of his organization and that of Vermont Futures inform each other reciprocally. 

The CCRPC has developed a comprehensive economic development strategy for its region, and has worked on its regional plan and on housing issues and provided input to Chu. 

“And now that this [the plan] is out, I think we'll be looking at if there are some pieces to it that we should be considering including in our regional plan,” Baker said. “I’ve had a chance to look at it a bit… A lot of the issues and perspectives are familiar.” 

Baker has a number of thoughts on the action plan itself already. 

“One theme that I think is very applicable and helpful to Vermont is… the need to kind of grow the pie,” Baker said. “It’s kind of a big theme that we've been kind of working on, also. The other mindset, like our pie’s never gonna grow and that we’ve got to fight over who gets what shares of the pie, is kind of a negative look at things.” 

“One that we haven't been as focused on is population growth as an objective in itself, but more on housing growth,” he added. “Obviously, with more housing comes more people, and you know so and there's also a connection… A lot of things are connected.” 

Chittenden County has had its “Building Homes Together” campaign for eight years or so now, with housing being CCRPC’s primary focus because of its function as a property tax base, the need for more affordability in the housing sector, and an expanded housing stock’s ability to grow the school-aged population and support a growing number of workers as well, he said. 

“It's gonna be a lot of hard work, and it's some significant change,” Baker said. “We haven't had a lot of growth in Vermont in the last 20 years, especially, but the growth rate in Vermont has been slowing the last 30 or 40 years — particularly slow the last 20.” 

“So it is going to be a lot of hard work,” he added. “But I'm also appreciative. I think [Chu] did a good job going around the state and listening to all kinds of perspectives, but also feeding into the policy work that has been going on, particularly in the legislature.” 

The legislature has been highly focused on housing in the last few years as well, Baker said, pointing to a set of state-sponsored regional housing targets — which happened to drop just a week before the Vermont Futures Project multi-sector action plan. 

Baker is curious to see continued legislation to support increased housing stock growth, which would in turn support a more vibrant and robust population, such as recently-passed bills dealing with Act 250 exemptions, and is excited that conversations around abuse of appeals processes are surfacing now. Baker and the CCRPC remain committed to the cause. 

“They did a great job,” he said, of the new Vermont Futures Project action plan. “I do think this is a useful document for the policy makers at the state and municipal and regional level to look at. I’d just encourage folks to take a look.” 

Growing the workforce 

Tim Smith, executive director for the Franklin County Industrial Development Corporation — who happens to also be the mayor for the City of St. Albans — said the FCDIC has been engaged with the Vermont Futures Project since its inception, even contributing to its genesis. 

In the early days, Smith recollects the focus being mainly on people and less so on housing and workforce as it is now. Smith appreciates that the Vermont Futures project has since taken the discussion to the next level of depth and framing. 

When asked how the FCDIC’s work is informed by or aligned with that of the Vermont Futures Project, Smith noted his is a small organization. 

“We definitely align with it, but that doesn't mean we have the manpower to address some of those areas,” he said. “We coordinate twice a year, a luncheon meeting with our partners to discuss those areas that we don't have a lot of activity in — it might be transportation, childcare, housing, healthcare, education.” 

“Our focus right now is probably more on workforce training and reaching out to the high schools and to the tech centers to work with them to educate their students as to what the opportunities are in the region,” he added. 

One quick local survey through BFA-St. Albans and the Northwest Career and Technical Center shows 46% of their graduates are looking at college, meaning presumably over 50% of graduates are looking for work. That’s where the FCDIC’s energy has been focused lately: business tours, job fairs and connecting prospective workers with local employers and training. 

Smith’s initial thoughts on the recent action plan from the Vermont Futures Project is that it’s “very ambitious to say the least.” 

“We can recruit,” he said. “The FCDIC believes we have about 400 kids graduating from high school [each spring]. If 200 go to college, we have another 200 here to start filling the voids in business within Franklin County. That’s just ballpark.” 

But one aspect of the workforce issue is many of the people who chose to move to Franklin County or Vermont at large during the height or in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, remain remote workers with out-of-state employers, meaning a substantial number of new residents aren’t contributing to the local workforce at all while housing remains all-the-more crunched. 

“Many, many of the manufacturers in the region are still looking for employees,” Smith said. “And it's not two or three, it's usually 30 or 40.” 

“We still have 10,000 people getting on the interstate and driving south to go to work on a daily basis,” he added. “So if we can capture some of those to stay local, we are of the belief that it makes for a better community.” 

Still, Smith sees definite value in the Vermont Futures Project action plan. 

“The issues have been ongoing for eight or 10 years, and we haven't made enough strides to have an impact,” he said. “And that's all I speak to. It's ambitious, because history has shown them that we haven't had a significant impact over the last six, seven years.” 

Smith thinks low birth rates and rapidly declining school populations are contributing to the problem, as well as the fact that baby boomers are leaving the state, and the fact that Vermont still taxes its veterans’ pensions, causing many folks in that group to move out too. 

“All of those are potential workforce employees,” he said. “I’m not sure what’s to be done about growing families… But I think there's things that can be done to keep people here.” 

Smith hopes to start by raising awareness of the reality at-hand — that if they can’t start filling jobs and ensuring businesses can find employees and operate effectively and sustainably, Vermont’s local economy will shrink, as will the landscape of tax-paying businesses. 

“They're going to find someplace else to go,” Smith said. “There are many options for businesses, and if we cannot help them grow and accommodate them, to get them to a strong workforce, then we start taking steps backwards. I don’t mean to be pessimistic.” 

“We’ve worked hard to have a strong economy,” he added. “It's taken decades, but we were sitting pretty good prior to COVID. But it’s not always secure, and it can start going backwards at any time… We need to do a better job of employing the employable.” 

Moving the needle bit by bit 

While the Vermont Futures Project action plan’s goals are admittedly bold, and considered ambitious by some, Chu said feedback to the plan’s launch has been overwhelmingly positive. 

Plus, there are countless organizations in-state chipping away at these targets from a variety of different angles and perspectives towards a thriving future for Vermonters near and far. 

For instance, Age Strong Vermont is working to empower older Vermonters to remain in the workforce if they desire, by improving their health outcomes and addressing workplace ageism. 

The Vermont Housing Trust and Habitat for Humanity offer below-market-rate housing options, for rentals and home ownership respectively. HomeShare Vermont offers dual support to aging Vermonters who need affordable in-home services, and to younger Vermonters in need of affordable housing, by pairing hosts with guests for matches that can help each other out. 

The Champlain Valley Office of Economic Opportunity also connects Vermonters with affordable housing, as well as temporary shelter programs for those exiting homelessness and escaping domestic violence, plus free food assistance, free personal finance courses and beyond. 

The more you look for it, the more you’ll notice uplifting signs of progress and positive change in your local communities and all around you. So keep an eye out. Donate to causes you believe in. Or volunteer your time to organizations you support. Spread the word around a dinner table. 

The Vermont Futures Project intends to re-engage with the communities it involved in the plan’s development process soon, to show them how their ideas were taken up in writing and to empower local grassroots champions to lead this growth from the ground up. 

Those interested can learn more about the Vermont Futures Project in our previous reporting and on the organization’s website, or to really dig in, folks can read the action plan in full. 

And if you share a similar vision to that of the action plan that thousands have contributed to, don’t be afraid to welcome new neighbors, speak your mind or extend a helping hand. Because Vermont’s Green Mountain grass will gleam even greener, if everyone works together to water it.

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here