UPDATED: Driver involved in fatality on Clay Point Road and U.S. Route 2 to appear in court in December, Colchester selectboard to address next steps for safety improvements

Posted

Editor's note: This story was updated at 3:44 p.m. Oct. 13 with a correction as to the nature of the charges Pugh will face. It was updated again Oct. 19 at 12:50 p.m. to reveal additional information from the police report. 

COLCHESTER — Colchester Police have issued a citation for Christopher Pugh to appear in court on felony charges relating to the death of Colchester resident Nicholas Ringuette.

Pugh, 38, of Grand Isle, will respond to charges of Driving Under the Influence of Drugs and Grossly Negligent Operation of a Motor Vehicle — both resulting in Ringuette’s death — on Dec. 7, according to an Oct. 12 press release from the Colchester Police Department. 

The hearing will take place in Vermont Superior Court, Chittenden County Criminal Division. 

These charges follow an extensive investigation by CPD with the assistance of the Vermont State Police Crash Reconstruction Team and a drug recognition expert from Essex Police Department. 

Since the time of the accident back in July, neighbors and friends town-wide have been demanding action be taken, advocating for the swift implementation of increased safety infrastructure at and around the intersection at the location of the crash on U.S. Route 2 and Clay Point Road. 

The same region saw another death about just one year prior to Ringuette’s. 

The selectboard heard input on the subject from numerous community members at a past public hearing, as well as in the form of written submissions that trickled in after. The selectboard had been waiting for the conclusion of the investigation before proceeding with next steps.

“A few meetings ago when we had the public hearing about safety on Route 2 to kind of just hear what people thought before we had more information, we said the first thing we're going to do is wait for the police report,” Town Manager Aaron Frank told the Sun. “That is now done.” 

The selectboard will hold a second public hearing about safety on Route 2 near Clay Point Road at its next meeting, Oct. 24. 

At this meeting, the board will consider public input and town staff recommendations in order to make a formal request for traffic changes to the Vermont Agency of Transportation. 

Town recommendations will become available by Saturday, Oct. 21, according to a town newsletter released Oct. 17. 

Prior to yesterday, the investigation had been ongoing for nearly three months, and two selectboard members came out publicly to say the duration of the wait was unacceptable. 

Although they had hoped to have more time to consider the contents of the report, Frank said on Monday or Tuesday of next week, in the next installation of the town’s weekly newsletter, the town would put out information regarding its input and intent about what might be done next.

Resident-proposed safety improvements include safer traffic patterns such as jug handles or a rotary, additional speed limit reductions on Route 2 where it intersects Clay Point Road, additional signage to indicate the highway’s intersection with a residential street, a stop light or yellow blinking light at the intersection, increased police presence, rumble strips, guard rails, deeper grass medians or flattening the existing hill where the intersection is for visibility. 

The details of the investigation — with an initial investigation carried out by Colchester Police Department and a crash reconstruction by the Vermont State Police — revealed new details about the high-speed collision. 

Ringuette’s vehicle was sitting stationary on Clay Point Road as Ringuette waited for an opening in traffic to turn onto Route 2, when he was hit by Pugh’s vehicle at 55 miles per hour — with Pugh driving only 5 miles per hour over the posted speed limit, which had been set at 55 before a slight speed limit reduction was made in response to a previous fatality at that same area. 

Pugh had drifted over the grassy median between the two roads to hit Ringuette’s vehicle. 

Ringuette received multiple fatal injuries including a fracture of the first cervical vertebrae and laceration of the aorta. There were no obvious defects with either vehicle, nor any unrepaired recalls in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s database. 

Officials discovered central nervous system depressants as well as cannabis in Pugh’s drug tests. Ringuette had not been wearing a seatbelt when he was hit by Pugh’s vehicle. 

The crash occurred on a portion of road where the road is straight and level when traveling west. The paved road surface was dry and clear of debris. 

Pugh said in interviews with officials that day that he had left work at Rotunda’s Auto Body and was on his way to the Islands to pick up his child, when he felt his vision go gray, then black. 

Pugh said he believed that he then hit the brakes. His next memory was “tumbling.” He used a knife to cut his seatbelt and was able to crawl out of his overturned truck. 

According to the event data recorder for both vehicles, Pugh’s vehicle did not brake, and tire marks from his vehicle on the grassy gore were not consistent with emergency braking. Ringuette’s vehicle was stopped at the time of impact with the brakes applied. 

While in a cervical collar and hooked up to medical equipment monitoring his vitals at the hospital, Pugh told officials he’s had episodes in the past of getting lightheaded accompanied by waves of severe dizziness during which the room spins and his vision “gets squiggly.” 

Pugh’s wife told officials that he tends to get lightheaded if he didn’t eat with one of his medications, which he had taken that morning without eating. 

Pugh told officials he had last smoked marujuana on his way to work in the morning and had stopped feeling its effects by 9:30 a.m. and the crash didn’t take place until late afternoon. 

However, investigating officers believe Pugh was under the influence of a CNS downer at the time of operation. 

Pugh has no history of seizures and it is not abnormal for him to not eat during the day. 

Investigating officers believe the cause of the crash to be Pugh failing to maintain his lane of travel — a violation of Title 23 VSA 1038 — while under the influence of CNS depressants, plus Pugh taking his taking prescribed medication without eating coupled with an admitted history of knowingly becoming “light headed” when taking his prescribed medication without eating. 

“We will look at [the police investigation] and then consider the situation and then make a recommendation to the selectboard,” Frank said. “Our processes to develop these things, and they're not final until they go into a selectboard packet for the public and the selectboard.”

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here