Time limits on teacher licensing tests measure the wrong thing

Posted
Text reading "Commentaries" and "Opinion pieces by community members" with a speech bubble icon.

This commentary is by Ben Mitchell, a reading interventionist at Riverside Middle School in Springfield and the publisher of Divergents Magazine.

In January I found myself at my computer, watching a digital clock aggressively count down the seconds. As a reading teacher in a Vermont public middle school, I love my job; this work challenges me to be my very best. Nevertheless, because I am on a provisional license, my entire career hinges on a number. Vermont requires a score of 164 on the Middle School English Praxis exam to be a candidate for licensure. That winter day, I scored a 159.

According to the remote workers who score the tests, I was five points short of being qualified to do the job I was already doing every day. The problem wasn’t my knowledge. After nearly 40 years of teaching, I know the material inside and out. The problem was that I ran out of time on each section. My brain processes information differently: I have dyslexia and ADHD, so under the frantic sprint of a strict time limit, my executive function faltered. Determined to stay in my classroom, I used the official Praxis appeal process. I was denied. I appealed again. Denied a second time. They wanted me to get $3,000 worth of testing just to secure a basic accommodation: 50% more time.

In July I took the same exam — new questions, same standards — with that extra time. The result? I scored a 171. When given the space to breathe and actually demonstrate what I know, I passed the 164 mark easily. The only variable that changed was the clock. My story is proof of a systemic flaw: Time limits on professional licensing exams do not measure competence. They measure processing speed, anxiety management and privilege. It is time to eliminate them entirely.

Professional licensing should ensure subject-matter expertise, whether for the classroom or the courtroom. It should not just be some kind of appreciation circle for the fast processors. Time-limited testing rests on the flawed assumption that speed equals mastery. In the real world, a professional’s effectiveness is rarely measured by a stopwatch. In reading instruction, decoding, student engagement and perseverance take time and patience; they cannot be rushed. No actual educational scenario requires a teacher to answer dozens of complex pedagogical questions in a frantic, high-pressure sprint. Instead of evaluating true competence, strict time limits simply measure how quickly a person can regurgitate information.

For professionals with ADHD, dyslexia or other processing differences, these timed tests act as a barrier to entry rather than a metric of quality control. Capable, passionate individuals are systematically locked out of professional careers due to these rigid, arbitrary structures. To make matters worse, forcing candidates through grueling bureaucratic appeal processes just to secure basic accommodations is exhausting and becomes an exclusionary barrier. The systemic absurdity is clear: Any framework that labels a teacher “unqualified” in January and “highly qualified” in July simply because they were granted a time extension is fundamentally broken.

To build a just and effective educational system, evaluations should focus on what a candidate knows, not how fast they can click a mouse. Allowing everyone to finish the test is a fundamental principle of universal design and widely considered best practice in contemporary education theory. Eliminating time constraints standardizes equity, allowing all candidates to demonstrate their true capabilities without having to jump through bureaucratic hoops. Testers can still record how long an individual takes to complete the assessment, allowing timeliness to be considered by employers.

I ask the state of Vermont to pass a law banning time limits for professional testing. Removing these artificial bottlenecks will not only promote equity in the workplace but also help qualified, dedicated individuals enter critical fields like education, resolving labor shortages in areas where talent is needed.

Read the story on VTDigger here: Time limits on teacher licensing tests measure the wrong thing.

Courtesy of VT Digger

Commentaries, Opinion, opinion, proficiency-based learning, teachers