The Colchester High School production of “Footloose,” scheduled for mid-November, was abruptly cancelled this month after school leaders say the program’s director resigned unexpectedly.
The departure adds to the tumult the theater program has experienced over the last two years, cycling through directors at an unusually rapid rate.
If and when a new director is hired by springtime, Anna Eaton, a senior involved with CHS theater since she was a freshman, will have worked under five directors in her four years in high school.
Eaton said her class is used to bouncing back amid challenges, but found the most recent shake-up especially hard to swallow.
“We hit a point that we didn’t even realize we could reach and how devastated we would eventually become,” Eaton said. “After that, we were like, we’re not going to let this go.”
Taking matters into their own hands, Eaton, along with fellow seniors Natalee Garen and Bella Lopez, have decided to self-direct two one-act plays in lieu of the fall musical. Sitting in the auditorium on Monday, the girls chattered with excitement as they planned out marketing, fundraising and rehearsal schedules with CHS principal Heather Baron.
The two shows, “Check, Please” and “Small Actors,” are both humorous — providing some much needed comedic relief, the students said with a laugh.
“These kids are passionate and committed and resilient,” Baron said. “For me, they have embodied the best of what we would want our kids to do in the face of adversity.”
Before the director turmoil, retired CHS English teacher John Coon (who all but created the school’s theater program) said he directed more than 130 shows during his 37-year tenure. In an interview last week, Coon said he never cancelled a show outright.
“I don’t know what’s going on, but it breaks my heart,” said Coon, who left the district in 2015. “I put 37 years of my life into that program, and I care about the kids.”
Coon’s original replacement began directing the musical “Little Shop of Horrors” in fall 2015 but left before the show took the stage due to a family emergency, Baron said.
CHS English teacher Amanda Hughes stepped in to finish at the last minute and stayed on to direct “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” at the end of 2016 and “Beauty and the Beast” just this spring.
Baron said Hughes made it clear she was planning to move on from the time-intensive co-curricular midway through last school year, and the district began looking for a replacement.
A hiring committee chose Tim Barden, highly experienced in Vermont theater, to take the helm. Once school was back in session, Barden cast students in a production of “Footloose” and began rehearsals. His wife, Jen Barden, was choreographing the show, and their son was a member of the cast.
Then, on Thursday, Oct. 5, Barden resigned.
In an emailed statement, the former director said the conflict stemmed from problems with the technical equipment installed as part of the voter-approved $730,000 upgrade to the CHS theater completed at the end of last year.
Barden said the malfunctions, including equipment that would turn on and off unexpectedly, threatened “to compromise what was an otherwise very promising production.”
“I was spending much more time trying to find a resolution for these issues than I was managing the artistic elements in the show,” Barden wrote. “This should be unacceptable given the dollars Colchester taxpayers have pumped into the facility.”
When Barden recommended the school reach out to independent experts for a second opinion on the issues, he said administrators declined.
“[Administrators] suggested that, if I didn’t trust the equipment, I could simply do the show without it,” Barden wrote. “It was at that point that I realized I had to choose between continuing as a school employee and accept this untenable situation or offer to resign.”
For her part, Baron said the school was working to find a solution before Barden’s departure and never refused to hear suggestions.
The new, more complex, theater equipment came with one year of support from the company StageWorks, she said, and officials are currently working on contracts that would extend the partnership past the expiration date.
“The school and Tim have a difference of perspective about the challenges that existed,” Baron said, pointing to successful presentations and shows that have been held in the theater since the renovation.
Baron said she was searching for a director to step in when she learned Jen Barden and a student cast in the leading role had also left the show.
In a separate statement, Jen Barden said she saw the tech equipment “needed improvements” during her work on previous shows in Colchester, but felt positive changes would be made.
“Never in my wildest dreams could I have imagined a musical being cancelled,” she wrote. “From a parent’s point of view I am devastated that this production is cancelled for what seems to me could have and should have been a very simple fix.”
Coon said he called the school as soon as he heard Barden resigned and offered to come out of retirement and direct “Footloose” himself. He said he was more than disappointed when the school never called him back.
Baron confirmed the account and said Coon’s offer, along with similar propositions from other local directors, were “very generous.” She credited a slew of shifting variables and challenges tracking down contact information for the disconnect with Coon.
“Time-wise, my priority was making sure the students were set,” Baron said.
She facilitated a parent information meeting and student brainstorming session last week, hoping to make a realistic plan that could get the kids back on stage. It was there that students Garen, Lopez and Eaton decided to direct themselves and perform a medley of “Footloose” songs as a tribute to their work thus far.
In an interview this week, the girls said their combined cast for the two shows was currently 30 students strong. At the start of the year, the program had one of the highest freshmen turnouts on record, Lopez noted.
A director with Burlington’s Flynn Theater will supervise their work, but Baron said the girls are in the “front seat.” They plan to stage the shows during two of the four November dates originally set aside for “Footloose.”
Baron said the students will also partake in a musical in the spring, though it’s still unclear whether they’ll work on the same show. The district has already posted the position for a new director.
The girls said it was important for theater veterans and newcomers alike to look past the conflict and create a robust reputation of the company as a whole.
“In a lot of ways, we wouldn’t have had as strong of a bond had we not gone through this,” Garen said. “Coming together in this way doesn’t have the same value, but it is so incredibly valuable that we’re salvaging, that we are rising from the ashes.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here