The debate over Malletts Bay sewers: A town priority for decades is back on the Town Meeting ballot for a third time

Posted

The Mallets Bay Sewer Project has been a topic of conversation and controversy in Colchester for years.

The project, now on the 2022 Town Meeting Day ballot, is a $17 million project to switch 289 properties along Mallets Bay away from individual septic systems and over to a municipal sewer system. Doing so, town officials say, will help ensure a clean Mallets Bay.

The project was first identified by the town as a priority in the 1960s and although it has been listed as a priority in every major planning document the town has created since, it has gone to a vote twice since and been voted down every time.

The last vote in 2019 came down to a very narrow margin, being voted down 1,396 to 1,203.

This year the proposal is different, primarily in the way it's being funded. 

With the addition of grant money from the American Rescue Plan Act, the town is able to offer the project at no cost to Colchester taxpayers, funding the project through grants and fees only to users of the new municipal sewers.

A solution backed by research

Vocal opposers say not only does the project inadequately address the pollution issues in Malletts Bay, but it serves as an excuse for increased developments: buildings, hotels, restaurants, tourists.

Town officials have repeatedly denied these claims, maintaining that any raw untreated human sewage that exists in Malletts Bay should be removed and that the sewer project will fix that issue. They also predict very low growth in development as a result of the project.

The town says an extensive amount of scientific research backs the project.

For four years, beginning in 2013, the town conducted a study using $2 million from the United States Environmental Protection Agency, working with engineers and scientists to put together a report called the Integrated Water Resources Management Plan (IWRMP).

In February 2014, the plan received the Grand Award for Engineering Excellence by the American Council of Engineering Companies – Vermont, the highest honor given by the ACEC – VT in its annual judging of engineering achievements.

As a result of years of research, testing lake samples and studying the land, the scientists and engineers recommended municipal sewers as a solution.

Colchester’s population is approximately 17,524 people, according to data from the 2020 U.S. Census, yet Colchester’s sewers account for only 7% of the town’s parcels, according to the IWRMP.

The proposed service area for the Mallets Bay Sewer Project includes everything on both sides of West Lakeshore Drive from the intersection at Prim Road back to the bayside, all of East Lakeshore Drive and all of Goodsell Point.

The main culprit identified in the IWRMP are the septic systems used by the properties along the bay, of which many have been identified as being on land that can’t support them.

Colchester Director of Public Works Bryan Osborne, who spearheaded the IWRMP along with contracted engineers and scientists, told the Sun these inadequate, failing septic systems have been identified as posing a significant risk to the environment and to public health.

“The septic systems in the Mallets Bay area are on lots that are too small. They have poor soils, they have insufficient depth to groundwater or bedrock. They are too close to the lake,” he said. 

The systems in the area also have a failure rate that is three to four times higher than any other area in Colchester, Osborne said.

Colchester is unique in this way. The town not only has more shoreline on Lake Champlain than any other community in Vermont, it also is the largest community in the state that relies primarily on septic systems.

The IWRMP’s analysis of the town’s geographical ability to support these systems identifies them as an area for concern.

The plan states that based on a town-wide wastewater needs assessment, 32% of developed parcels that are not served by a centralized sewage system in Colchester cannot support an onsite wastewater dispersal system that fully complies with current regulations and environmental conditions.

Many of these parcels are either on land within 300 feet of the lake or directly on the lake, which the plan identifies as high priority areas.

How much waste is in the bay?

Another aspect of the study which has become a topic of debate is exactly how much of the waste in the bay is caused by humans.

As part of the IWRMP, microbiologists at the University of New Hampshire, headed by Dr. Stephen Jones, were tasked with offering a comprehensive analysis of the E. coli contamination in Colchester waters as well as identifying sources.

In the plan put together by Jones and his team, around 8% of samples taken were contaminated by human waste.

“Which was no surprise to us,” Osborne said. “People who have gotten really hung up on whether it's 8%, whether it's 10%, whether it's 80%, the point is, is we have raw untreated human sewage in Malletts Bay as a result of failing, inadequate septic systems. We believe that that's a significant threat to public health and the environment. Therefore we are doing the responsible thing by proposing sewers as recommended by professional water quality scientists and engineers that have studied this for over four years.”

Jones and his team were in charge of doing the testing portion of the project, receiving samples and then analyzing them to find out where the contamination was coming from.

Specifically, Jones was looking for fecal material. 

He told the Sun that all animals and humans carry E. coli in our guts, and through a process called ribotyping, scientists are able to compare the DNA from unidentified E. coli samples against a library of identified samples in order to determine what has been producing the E. coli contaminating the water.

This E. coli has the possibility of carrying disease causing organisms, viruses and bacteria, making it a public health issue. 

“Over time you keep taking these samples. You take them in dry weather, you take them in wet weather,” Jones said. “It's trying to understand what's driving the contamination in the water body.”

The Friends of Mallets Bay in opposition

In opposition to the project, is a vocal group of Colchester residents under the name Friends of Mallets Bay. The group is co-chaired by a former selectboard member and past chairman of the Malletts Bay Advisory Commission, Jack Scully.

The crux of the group’s skepticism lies in their belief that the sewer project does not effectively target where most of the waste is coming from. They say much of the E. coli contamination comes from animals and that a sewer in the proposed area does not effectively target where human E. coli contamination is coming from.

That’s a claim town officials involved in the study by experts have repeatedly denied.

Osborne said if the town wasn’t confident the sewer would address the human E. coli issues in Malletts Bay, they wouldn’t be proposing a $17 million project.

“The point is, we have human waste bacteria in the lake, regardless of what the percentage is, and it's a problem and we need to address it,” Osborne said. “And the recommendation of the professionals that are actually looking at this, versus the citizen groups that are trying to evaluate it, is to sewer Malletts Bay.”

The Friends of Malletts Bay’s read on the IWRMP study is that resources would be better spent on a more comprehensive approach to cleaning up the bay. They lay this out in a “Seven Point Plan.”

According to Scully, the group of citizens have spent a total of 500 hours putting together the alternate report and plan.

The group says its report incorporates advice from the Vermont Department of Environmental Conservation and Northern Lake Champlain Tactical Basin Program, but no members of the group themselves are experts in this field.

In its plan, the group lays out seven different actions that the town could adopt in totality to fight the contamination within the bay. Those actions, among others, include: 

  • Cleaning up Bayside Beach

  • Fast-tracking zoning revisions for East Lakeshore Drive to control conversion of small dwellings into tall structures 

  • Setting up a Colchester land conservation fund to acquire a limited number of dwellings along the west side of East Lakeshore Drive as they become available for purchase

The plan also recommends the creation of a community septic system to deal with the inadequate and failing individual septic systems that are causing the problem along Mallets Bay.

“All of the sampling done over time, they only came up with about 8.5% human E. coli, and now, the town is jumping to the conclusion that the human E. coli is coming from the camps, and we have to spend $17 million to hook them up to a central line,” Scully told the Sun.

Scully and his group’s understanding of the study is that most of the human E. coli isn’t coming from the properties where the sewers are being proposed, but is instead flowing into the lake through two tributaries, Crooked Creek and Smith Hollow Creek.

Town officials have said this is false.

“If it was in the creeks we wouldn't be proposing sewers for Mallets Bay, because it wouldn't do any good,” Osborne said.

Osborne said the town is trying to combat the baseline issue, that untreated human waste is in Malletts Bay as a result of failing septic systems.His perspective is that the 900-page IWRMP is an extremely intensive report to sift through in order to come to the right conclusions.

“The IWRMP was such a massive and complicated study, and it's so easy to dive into sections of that and to come away with pieces of information that just don't paint the entire picture and that's been one of the frustrations here,” he said.

The Friends of Malletts Bay say that two years ago, it was promised by town officials the opportunity to present its seven point plan to the selectboard. They say that promise has not been fulfilled. 

In fact, the group was surprised to find out that the selectboard was voting on Jan. 11 to approve the article appearing on the town’s ballot.

“You usually don't do these things overnight,” Scully said. “Usually there is public discussion and debate about an article, especially spending $17 million

Marilyn Sowles, a member of the Friends of Malletts Bay, attended the Jan. 11 meeting and said she was surprised to see the vote on the agenda through Front Porch Forum.

Sowles hoped the board would consider the group’s proposal before going through with authorizing the Town Meeting Day vote.

Town officials have said the Seven Point Plan from the Friends of Malletts Bay has already been reviewed. 

The planning commission, Colchester Town Manager Aaron Frank said, spent seven months reviewing alternatives to the Mallets Bay Sewer Project. The group’s plan was considered, he said.

“The planning commission spent seven months reviewing alternatives to the Mallets Bay Sewer Project as proposed in 2019 and considered the input of the people from that group, and they came to the conclusion that the most cost effective plan and efficient plan in addressing the wastewater issues was the proposed project,” Frank told the Sun. 

At the Jan. 11 selectboard meeting, Sowles told the board she believes the plan was not sufficiently considered in those planning commission meetings.

The alternatives study done by the Colchester Planning Commission lays out a review of different options for dealing with the contamination, including the acquisition and conservation of land along the bay and the community septic system, both of which are part of the Friends’ plan.

Cost of the project and support from the Vermont DEC

The Vermont Department of Environmental Conservation has also looked at the IWRMP and determined that the Malletts Bay Sewer Project is necessary to maintain water quality in Malletts Bay. 

Its made millions of dollars in grant money available for the town to complete it, Osborne said.

The current estimate for the project comes out to about $16.7 million of which 64% ($10.6 million) would be paid for by grants. The remaining 36% ($6.1 million) would be paid by user fees.

The loan used to pay for the non-grant funded portion of the project would be a 30-year 2% loan to the state of Vermont, with an annual payment projected to be around $270,000 for 30 years.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here