COLCHESTER — Like other town departments and public-facing entities in the area, the Colchester Police Department works to uphold diversity, equity and inclusion standards.
The CPD has continued its cultural awareness and anti-bias training and has increased funding for supportive services, such as community outreach, under contract with the Howard Center and the Essex Community Justice Center.
In addition to cultural competency trainings for staff, restorative justice pathways as an alternative to the traditional criminal justice system, proactive community engagement and body-worn cameras as an accountability measure, DEI-related efforts within CPD also encompass the conversations surrounding police reform which gained momentum following the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement in summer of 2020.
Get to know Colchester by way of this fourth installment of our five-part DEI series.
Colchester Police Department, along with town employees as a whole, started doing annual DEI trainings before the state began mandating such training every other year. These efforts aim to grow town staff’s cultural competency and understanding of diversity both within the workplace and in interfacing equitably with the community.
In the last several years, 24 CPD staff members — both sworn and non-sworn — have completed two and a half hours of Structural Competency and Cultural Humility training.
Eight staff members participated in two-hour Cultural Diversity and Cultural Brokers Trainings, three employees attended an eight-hour training on Cultural Diversity, and Police Chief Pete Hull completed 16 hours total of training through the Clifton Strengths Workshop and Cultural Diversity Competency Workshop.
The department has also taken on include Drug Impairment training for the cultural brokers.
Dr. Maria Mercedes Avila — assistant professor of pediatrics and adjunct professor of nursing at UVM Medical Center, who ran DEI trainings for town staff — was a panelist for the hiring of the CPD’s new Evidence Technician position.
The town is continuing to engage with diverse parts of the Colchester community at events like a recent Police Department open house event that took place this past fall.
“I think they've been effective,” Hull said of the various DEI-related training his staff have undergone. “And I think that we have come a long way in understanding implicit and explicit bias and in knowing enough now to check — prior to acting on something — for our bias.”
Hull said he and his staff have learned to ask themselves where they are coming from on the topics they engage with community members about.
“And checking yourself and making sure before we implement something that we're doing what we need to do,” he added. “I think it's been pretty successful, and I think the newer the officer, the less of a change it is.”
In other words, Hull believes that younger generations are already much more “self-aware,” he said, when it comes to themes related to diversity, equity and inclusion.
“It wasn't even a topic,” Hull said, of back in the earlier parts of his career when he was in his early 20s. “The culture has shifted for the good, and we try to stay as current and on top of things as we can. The state has really been on top of moving policing forward and we actually, I think were a little bit ahead of the curve at the time.”
The state-mandated training for law enforcement officers requires a program approved by the Vermont Criminal Justice Council designed to demonstrate achieved law enforcement officer competency in fair and impartial policing.
This state mandate, for two hours of training every other year, went into effect in 2018. Colchester’s anti-bias and DEI training meets the state’s program content standards and as aforementioned, exceeds the state’s required frequency standards.
CPD trained in 2014 to be sure that officers understood an update to its Fair and Impartial Policing Policy. An outside trainer delivered training to all officers in anti-bias policing in 2015. Also in 2015, two police officers received “train the trainer” training through the Vermont Police Academy and in 2018, CPD’s certified trainers in turn trained all other police officers in the department on anti-bias policing. In 2020, 2021 and 2022, outside contracted trainers came in to train CPD police in these areas.
In recent years and still today, the police department has expanded its community justice efforts to also provide more supportive services to all populations in the community.
Through the department’s work with the Essex Community Justice Center in partnership with the Town of Essex and the State Department of Corrections, Essex Community Justice Center provides restorative justice programming for officers with a focus on crime prevention, conflict resolution and meeting the needs of those affected by crime.
Its program offerings include community restorative justice panels, community dialogue education and the circle of support and accountability program, which helps those recently released from incarceration to successfully re-enter society.
Additionally, the Colchester Police Department can refer cases to restorative justice panels instead of court. These panels, facilitated by trained community volunteers, serve as a proven and cost-effective means to address low-level offenses.
In a series of conversations, the panel process holds those responsible for crime accountable for their actions and provides an important opportunity for those affected by crime to share their stories and identify needs for repair.
Prior to the establishment of CPD’s partnership with the ECJC, Colchester had its own independent reparative justice board for many years in the early 2000s and 2010s, which later merged with the ECJC. The town’s original restorative justice board was founded by Colchester resident, author and former local news editor Inge Schaefer.
“I think it's huge,” Hull said, of these programs’ importance. “I'm a big proponent of alternative justice. I think that for a big portion of the folks that we deal with, it's really appropriate and very effective, and it has become an integrated part of our criminal justice system — so the State's Attorney's Office promotes it, the court system promotes it. And the goal is to have as few people going through the actual criminal justice process as possible.”
“But there are times when the traditional criminal justice process is appropriate,” he added. “It still needs to happen. So the magic in it is just trying to find the right spot, right? So that will always be a moving target, I think.”
CPD’s work with the Howard Center began in 2018 through the Howard Center’s Community Outreach Program which has created a supportive presence in several municipalities.
The Howard Center hires, trains and supervises staff to serve as Community Outreach Specialists in communities involved with the program. The program has expanded to include nine Chittenden County communities.
In collaboration with local law enforcement and service providers, the Howard Center Outreach Specialists work to coordinate support for individuals who have mental health, substance use, housing or other social service needs.
This collaboration has enhanced the well-being of local communities like Colchester and allowed the municipalities’ police resources to focus on persons who have committed crimes.
Read more about the CPD’s partnerships with the ECJC and Howard Center Community Outreach Program in the Sun’s most recently updated coverage on both here.
Other DEI-related endeavors include the CPD Body Worn Camera initiative, fully realized in 2022 at a cost totaling more than $100,000 to purchase cameras for each officer, along with associated technology. Initial funding for this equipment came from asset seizures.
Colchester’s department began procuring and utilizing body-worn cameras in fall of 2021, but it had already had cruiser cams for a long time. The selectboard supported this expansion of existing camera use to include body-worn cameras throughout the department, “despite significant initial and ongoing costs of doing so,” according to Colchester’s annual town report for the 2021-’22 year.
The use of body-worn cameras by all uniformed personnel is state-mandated as of 2022, except for in certain privacy-priority settings. For example, cameras are turned off in settings with privacy concerns, such as in hospitals, for the sake of patient confidentiality.
“We adopted a state mandate, essentially — they have a statewide policy and our policy pretty much mirrors theirs,” Hull said. “This wasn't wasn't an issue where we were waiting to be forced to do it. The town and the department were enthusiastic about this. This wasn't something that was forced upon us. We look at it as a good tool.”
The selectboard has also publicly engaged with the CPD on key policies related to use of force, evidence and property, pursuit, fair and impartial policing, workplace behavior, complaints and internal investigations, employee selection, promotions and transfers, search and seizure as well as handling encounters involving mental health.
Approaches to law enforcement have changed somewhat in the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement, which gained significant traction during the summer of 2020 and brought to light systemic racism as a nationwide issue — with many Vermont leaders, including Gov. Phil Scott, having expressed agreement with such sentiments and a belief in the need for change.
“I think it created a lot of beneficial conversations,” Hull said of the movement. “Like any other big social topic, I think that anytime you're talking about racism and bigotry, it's pretty huge, right? The more conversations, the better.”
“And not all of them are positive,” he added. “It's really hard for people when it’s an emotionally charged topic like that, right? To step aside a little bit and have that rational conversation versus an emotionally-based one, but you're never going to take emotion out of something like that because it's a pretty visceral, guttural feeling.”
Although much of the conversation and change to come out of this shifting status quo has been positive, Hull believes “there's good and bad.”
“Not all that came out of that was good,” he told the Sun. “‘Defund’ is horrible for communities. The defund [movement] didn't take into consideration the needs of the community. It wasn't thought through. That whole extreme piece of things is damaging policing and departments’ abilities to serve their communities, and it's hurt the criminal justice system.”
“I'm not suggesting that they didn't need reform,” he added. “Because I think that we should always be looking to change and improve. And I think reforms in the criminal justice system are ongoing and need to be. There were some pieces that weren’t great, but I still stand by that I think overall, the fact that we're still having discussions and conversations and are trying to learn and improve and change, and that it's been recognized that it has to continue is a good thing.”
Hull said he believes these changes toward greater equity and cultural competency have not only been a good thing for society, but also a good thing for law enforcement, when addressed properly, with an understanding of potential ramifications of certain approaches, as opposed to just pushing “change for the sake of change.”
“We have to be part of the conversation,” Hull said. “Because anytime that you're looking at changing, especially something as fundamental as public safety, it needs to be done thoughtfully.”
Still, he recognizes the importance of constantly looking to improve, and of circling back to these subjects frequently.
“In a lot of ingrained systems, regardless of the discipline, I think change is hard,” he said. “And so society tends to move kind of slowly when it comes to fundamental change. So I think some things we've been successful with and some things we haven't.”
“I think that that conversation has to constantly be a constant conversation,” he added. “And I don't think that it can just [be] ‘well, we got through that, now we're done with it.’ That's not okay. I think that in history, when we have done that, what happens is the problems resurface, because you haven't really dealt with it. If you boil it down, is it really that new?”
While Hull believes the social justice movement sparked important conversations which have led to beneficial reform, the shifting reputation of law enforcement careers as a result has made hiring more of a challenge in a post-pandemic era in which Vermont’s labor market is experiencing a worker shortage already.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here