COLCHESTER — Shrouded in brown paper scrawled with words like “profanity,” “pornography,” “drugs” and “violence,” this week’s stars of the Burnham Memorial Library are all banned books — standing defiant in the face of censorship.
Banned Books Week spans from Oct. 1- 7. Started by First Amendment and library activist Judith Krug with the help of the American Library Association and the Association of American Publishers in 1982, Banned Books Week is widely recognized as a time to celebrate the freedom to read and is honored in libraries nationwide.
“There's a quote, I won't get it exactly right. But it says that there should be something in the library collection to offend everyone,” said Kelly McCagg, director of the Burnham Memorial Library, referencing librarian Jo Godwin. “You want to have all perspectives represented.”
At Burnham Memorial Library, the display table this week sheds light on books that have been banned in various libraries across the country — from classics like George Orwell’s “Animal Farm,” Vladimir Nabokov’s “Lolita” and Ray Bradbury’s “Fahrenheit 451,” all the way up to contemporary literature such as Maia Kobabe’s memoir, “Gender Queer,” the latter of which has been banned in more states than any other book.
Typically, when books are banned it’s because a patron or parent finds its content offensive in some way or manner, and the individual brings it either to a library board or school board — depending on where the given library is situated — to request it be removed from the institution’s collection, McCagg told the Sun.
“I don't think there are legitimate reasons for a book to be removed,” McCagg said. “I think that librarians go through a pretty stringent process when they're selecting books for their collection.”
The only reasons McCagg sees for excluding material from a library collection are in the case of books containing either hate speech or misinformation, both of which are vetted for by either editors, publishers — or in the case of self-published material and outdated medical information or scientific hypotheses — combed through for hate speech and updated for accuracy by library staff during the selection and curation process.
Outside of those standards, which are upheld inherently in the practice of building and reviewing a collection and without a need to formally ban material, McCagg said there should be something in the building for everyone that they don't personally agree with.
This practice in public libraries is intended to serve as a basis for giving voice to diverse perspectives and inspiring respectful, civic engagement and discourse in a community, as well as to promote critical thinking skills in the information environment among the general populace.
“We look at lots of different reviews, lots of different sources,” McCagg said. “We try to make sure that our collections aren't just varied as far as content but also that we have authors from different races and genders and sexual orientations.”
“And the same is true for publishers, we don't just want like the big six,” she added. “We want smaller, independent ones, and we try to make sure that the collection is a good reflection of the community and every member that we serve.”
In her decade spent working at the Burnham Memorial Library, McCagg is glad to have never seen a book or other material banned from the library’s collection. On a few occasions, people just want for books to be relocated from one area to another.
For instance, there was once a book that had initially been placed in the children’s section due to a recommendation from a professional teen magazine called Voice of Youth Advocates. However, the book contained cocktail recipes in the back. Upon reviewing a related complaint, the library agreed it was more appropriate it be moved to the adult section.
McCagg told the Sun a lot of book bans tend to happen in school libraries, because it's an easier process to achieve as a complainant, but that it's also becoming more common for it to happen in public libraries, especially down south, as a result of increased political polarization.
“It's through listening to other voices, especially ones we have that we don't necessarily agree with, that we grow as individuals,” McCagg said. “I think that was really seen with the presidential election, like with Trump, when you saw how when people didn't agree that really divided our country.”
In 2022, the American Library Association tracked the highest number of attempted book bans since ALA began compiling censorship data in libraries over 20 years ago, with 2,571 titles challenged last year alone.
“I think we've been working as a country since then to kind of come back together and find common ground,” McCagg added. “So I think that if we can read about things that we don't necessarily agree with, we can try to find some commonality.”
Illinois passed a law making it illegal to ban books, and there's a bill in the Senate right now that would make it illegal in Vermont to ban books as well — the passage of which McCagg is rooting for behind the scenes from the local library in Colchester.
“It's super important that people are aware of it,” McCagg said. “They think ‘Oh, it's Vermont, it doesn't happen here.’ But it happens with books in school libraries, and it happens a lot with programs and displays.”
People protest programs to try to control information in other formats, too, not only with books.
“As a librarian [Banned Books Week] is one of my favorite weeks because I think that we need to hear everyone's voice,” McCagg said. “When we ban something, we're silencing voices, and whether we agree with them or not, everyone's voice is valid.”
Maya Angelou’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings”
Margaret Atwood’s “The Handmaid’s Tale”
Alison Bechdel’s “Fun Home”
Ray Bradbury’s “Fahrenheit 451”
Juno Dawson’s “This Book Is Gay”
Shaun David Hutchinson’s “We Are the Ants”
Susanna Kaysen’s “Girl, Interrupted”
Maia Kobabe’s “Gender Queer: A Memoir”
Susan Kuklin’s “Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out”
Harper Lee’s “To Kill A Mockingbird”
David Levithan’s “Two Boys Kissing”
Patricia McCormick’s “Sold”
Toni Morrison’s “The Bluest Eye”
Toni Morrison’s “Beloved”
Vladimir Nabokov’s “Lolita”
George Orwell’s “Animal Farm”
Jodi Picoult’s “My Sister’s Keeper”
Jodi Picoult’s “Nineteen Minutes”
Jonathan Safran Foer's “Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close”
Alice Sebold’s “Lucky”
Art Spiegelman’s “Maus I”
Kurt Vonnegut’s “Slaughterhouse Five”
Those interested in stopping by to browse the selection can also check back later this week for additional related materials being put out by library staff — a children’s picture book and chapter book display for Banned Books Week is on its way.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here