By JASON STARR
Following a Vermont Supreme Court victory last week, Costco can now proceed with the installation of 12 discounted gas pumps and a store expansion at its Colchester location.
When it will is anyone’s guess – even general manager Chris Stafford’s.
“I’ll believe it when I see it,” he said after the nine-year legal battle with two neighboring gas station owners reached an apparent conclusion in the state’s highest court. “We haven’t heard from corporate. We are all waiting to hear about some sort of timeline.”
The Colchester store is located near the Exit 16 interchange of Interstate 89. A request for comment from Costco headquarters in Washington this week went unanswered.
The Supreme Court upheld a 2015 ruling in environmental court that denied appeals by R.L. Vallee — owner of the nearby Maplefields gas station and store — and Timberlake LLC — owner of another Exit 16-area gas station — of Costco’s expansion permits. Colchester’s Development Review Board originally approved the project in 2007.
Vallee appealed on grounds that Costco’s mitigation plans for the expansion’s effects on a nearby wetland and on traffic congestion are insufficient.
The environmental court ruled, and the Supreme Court upheld, that “the project would have no more than a minimal effect on the wetland’s ability to serve its core functions.”
Regarding traffic impact, Costco had agreed to add new turning lanes at the intersection of Lower Mountain View Drive and Route 7 to mitigate the 155 vehicle trips per day of increased traffic anticipated from the expansion. Vallee argued that a pending Vermont Agency of Transportation overhaul of the Exit 16 interchange is the only remedy for the traffic increase the expansion will cause.
The Supreme Court affirmed the environmental court’s ruling that the Lower Mountain View Drive improvements are sufficient traffic mitigation for Costco’s project.
“[The] impacts did not warrant conditioning the project on the completion of the planned I-89 improvements,” the court’s ruling states.
“We are disappointed in the result and we are studying the decision,” Vallee’s attorney, Jon Anderson, said.
Vallee has also filed an appeal of stormwater permits related to the VTrans project.
Costco’s Burlington-based attorney, Mark Hall, said Costco will follow Vallee’s case against VTrans, although the corporation is not named in the appeal.
“Costco hopes Vtrans a speedy victory,” Hall said. “Everyone knows [the Exit 16 project] is needed. It will be an improvement for the area.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here