The state has proposed issuing boat owner Matthew Yarbenet a violation for abandoning his vessel in Malletts Bay, documents show.
The Vermont Agency of Natural Resources is allowing public comment on a proposed administrative order against Yarbenet, saying he illegally disposed of solid waste outside a certified facility, the document says.
The vessel, which the administrative order describes as a 1993 BT Sentra 25-foot speedboat 150 yards off Malletts Bay, incited complaints over environmental, aesthetic and safety impacts.
Colchester police determined Yarbenet hadn’t broken any criminal statutes and passed any enforcement to state authorities, who vowed in January to find a way to hold Yarbenet accountable.
ANR posted the order for public notice on February 15, opening a 30-day comment period that ends this Saturday, March 17. ANR procedure says any comments could modify the final order.
ANR attorney John Zaikowski said if the agency moves forward after the commenting period ends, the order will be issued to Yarbenet, who will then have 15 days to request a hearing by the Vermont Environmental Court.
If Yarbenet doesn’t request a hearing, the agency can enter the administrative order as a judicial order, setting off the 30-day timeline to remove the boat and pay a $6,000 fine.
The order includes the agency’s original Dec. 5 complaint, describing the boat as “half sunk and half tipped over” in Malletts Bay and the observation of the boat by environmental enforcement officer Edmund Cantwell on December 8.
The boat is described as having a fiberglass hull and inboard motor “partially submerged and resting on the bottom of the lake.” It lists the boat’s registration as “VT 4799K” and belonging to Yarbenet.
Zaikowski said ANR also sent a letter to Yarbenet’s last known address in January asking him to voluntarily remove the boat from the lake. The letter was not picked up, he said.
If the judicial order is violated and the boat is not removed, Zaikowski said the agency will evaluate its “enforcement avenues” and could potentially file a contempt petition in environmental court.
After the Sun first reported on the boat in December, Colchester residents took to social media directing their ire at the boat owner, state and local officials and the apparent hole in state law.
ANR commissioner Emily Boedecker said her agency’s issuance of a waste management violation was clunky but it “was quite simply the only legal process open to us today, so we are pursuing it,” she said.
Boedecker said a “void between multiple jurisdictions” has prevented more expedient action by local and state officials since the boat first appeared on their radar in December.
She said she doesn’t know what contents were on board when the boat initially went down, but said there was no evidence of “hazardous waste.”
Going forward, she said the agency’s No. 1 priority is due process and operating within the law. She said she hopes future legislation will make the process less onerous.
“The amount of legal resources that we would need to apply in these situations is substantial,” she said.
Boedecker said the Senate Committee on Transportation, headed by Colchester’s Sen. Dick Mazza, has picked up the conversation and is looking into legislation that will allow state and local agencies to take swifter action in the future.
Previously, Michele Boomhower of the Vermont Agency of Transportation said the Senate committee was looking into tweaking the state’s abandoned vehicle statute to include boats.
Boedecker said it’s still early in the legislative process, and a lot of options remain on the table.
She said the agency has still not made contact with Yarbenet.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here