The impending Malletts Bay sewer project will cost residents less than anticipated, according to Colchester public works director Bryan Osborne’s presentation to the selectboard November 13.
After developing the project further and narrowing down funding sources, Osborne said the project will cost Malletts Bay residents $427 a year, down from the estimated $1,200 he presented last April.
Osborne called the first estimate “extremely high in comparison to statewide averages” and said his team can lower the cost by using approximately $2.15 million in future local option tax funds over the project’s 30-year period.
The sewer project currently has an estimated $14.3 million price tag, which has increased slightly since the April presentation to take inflation into account, Osborne said. Some funding will come from a loan subsidy and a pollution control grant, but the bulk of the cost, $8.9 million, will be covered using the state’s clean water revolving loan fund.
The loan would be paid back at a rate of 2 percent over 30 years, which raised concerns from selectman Herb Downing about the town taking on too much debt. Town manager Aaron Frank maintained the viability of the project, saying the town’s interest on the debt is subsidized by federal funds.
“[The project is] one of the cornerstones of the community,” he said. “That’s why we’re proposing this first amongst all of the capital projects because we feel it’s the highest priority.”
Downing and other selectboard members nodded in agreement.
The town’s five-year capital plan shows about $110 million in unfunded capital projects.
Paying off the sewer loan, therefore, would cost bay users approximately $385,000 per year, Osborne said. However, by using $250,000 in local option taxes annually, that rate drops down to $135,000 per year, costing users about $427 per single family home per year in debt payments.
Osborne added the local option tax revenues will pay for constructing the service lines that connect each home to the sewer line. If the clean water loan was to fund the laterals, the town would have to own and individually maintain each homeowner’s connection, putting an “unusual burden” on the utility, Osborne said. This way, the project pays for the laterals, but homeowners own them, which is how most utilities work, he added.
In addition to paying down the debt on the project, Osborne said bay residents would pay $364 in annual user fees to fund the system’s operation and maintenance, making a $791 cost per year for the entire project.
This is just slightly more than what residents on the town’s existing sewer service system pay, which is about $718 per year, making costs comparable, he added.
In a follow-up email, Osborne explained two factors for the higher costs for bay residents as opposed to town residents on the current system:
“The lower levels of development density found in Malletts Bay … means more capital debt cost per user which translates into higher user costs,” he said. “Other factors influencing this is inflation, where building sewers today is much more expensive than building sewers 20 plus years ago.”
He added this is comparable to costs to maintain a private, on-site wastewater maintenance system, which range from around $12,000 to $32,000 over 30 years. The town’s 30-year Malletts Bay sewer project will cost a single-family home around $24,000, right in the middle.
“It meets our definition of affordability,” Osborne said.
Osborne noted the significant return on investment the town will see from this project, something the selectboard was very interested in. Connection and user fees from future and existing development in the bay area will generate about $9.64 million and will cover the LOT investment in 43 years, he explained.
Osborne said the current private sewer systems serving residents in Malletts Bay are old and failing, and environmental constraints prevent residents from having reliable on-site wastewater systems.
Connecting residents to the town system, then will be “the most effective and efficient way to preserve and protect this valuable community asset for future generations,” Osborne said.
The selectboard cancelled its regularly-scheduled meeting on Nov. 27 to host a special presentation about the project for bay residents. Osborne said there will be more presentations for the general public, and he hopes the selectboard will make a decision at a December or January meeting on whether to send the project to the voters on Town Meeting Day in March.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here