The Colchester Selectboard rejected a recommendation from the parks and recreation department last Tuesday that would have raised the town’s recreation impact fee from $735 per dwelling to $2,009 per unit — a nearly 300 percent increase.
Impact fees, leveled on new constructions, are generally used to offset the “unfair” financial burden of upkeep for public facilities and services that fall upon current residents and taxpayers, according to a memo from parks and recreation director Glen Cuttitta.
Vermont towns can require developers pay such fees “to mitigate the negative effects of construction,” the memo said. The revenue can only be used to cover capital project costs, not operation and maintenance needs, including staff salaries.
Colchester last raised its impact fee to $735 in 1997, Cuttitta wrote, and decided to reevaluate the measure earlier this year with help from GreenPlay Consultants, the same firm working on a master plan for Bayside Park.
At the Oct. 24 selectboard meeting, several area developers and board members expressed frustration with the proposal, pressing staff on why the number was rising so dramatically after decades of stagnation.
“Everything we do can’t be paid for by fee increases,” selectman Tom Mulcahy said. “There are other ways to raise money.”
Planning and zoning director Sarah Hadd said consultants engaged in a thorough review of the current level of service. According to Cuttitta’s memo, the town has 110 acres of developed parkland and an additional 80 acres of “developable” parkland.
Currently in the pipeline, Hadd noted, is a 10-year planning effort with 14 acres in lower Bayside and the Bayside-Hazelett property identified for development.
The $2,009 fee does not account for some of the larger projects being eyed, especially the $25.5 million community center that would be voted in via ballot along with a bonding request, according to Cuttitta.
“We’d rather … bring this to you now so this came in line with what our current needs are and then come back in perhaps five years after we know a little bit more concretely,” Hadd told the board, confirming the fee could double then.
Representing O’Leary Burke, David Burke said the increase was too much, too quickly for builders, especially with already razor-thin profit margins.
“Three hundred percent is a lot to stomach all at once, and now we’re kind of being told it’s probably 600 percent because in five years it might double,” Burke said.
Hadd said staff tried to keep the fee formula simple, charging a flat rate for new developments based solely on the number of residential units. According to her presentation, the $2,009 fee would stay competitive with area towns.
But the decision was problematic for SD Ireland representative Pat O’Brien. Though he understood the desire for simplicity, O’Brien noted buildings like his in Severance Corners encompass dozens of units per build. Under the proposed model, he’d be required to front the fee for those units all at once, while the builder of a single family home could pay as they go.
“It’s not fair for a one-bedroom unit, even if it has two people in it, to pay the same as a four or five-bedroom house,” O’Brien said, noting other towns adopted a more tailored approach to determining fees.
After the hearing, board members expressed interest in exploring the developers’ concerns. Several said they would prefer an incremental increase that occurred yearly, rather than the lump raise, and wanted to further explore accommodations for affordable housing builds.
Only selectman Herb Downing was comfortable supporting the amendment as presented.
Per town manager Dawn Francis’ recommendation, the board tabled the discussion and agreed to hear a new proposal after staff consulted with GreenPlay and the town’s attorney about sliding scales, automatic increases and affordable housing accommodations.
Because those changes would be considered substantive, the topic will be warned again as a public hearing, Francis said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here