Scott vs. Janoo: Vermont governor candidates make final pitches

Posted

VERMONT — Next Tuesday, Vermonters will weigh-in on what is set to be the tightest race for governor in more than a decade. 

Republican Gov. Phil Scott, seeking his sixth term in office, has found a formidable challenger in Amanda Janoo, a Democrat/Progressive who has taken the state by storm with her positive outlook and populist agenda. 

Both are spending their last days on the campaign trail making final arguments to voters through hard-hitting advertisements and in-person events. 

Scott says he has “unfinished business” when it comes to education reform and Vermont’s stubborn affordability crisis. Janoo, meanwhile, argues it’s time for a new generation of leadership focused on building the economy from the bottom up. 

We caught up with both candidates during their final pushes. Scott spoke with publisher Bridget Higdon-Boudreau by phone for a 45-minute interview, and Janoo sat down with senior staff writer Josh Ellerbrock before an event at the Saint Albans Museum. 

Here’s what they had to say. 

Seeking sixth term, Scott pushes for scale 

According to Gov. Phil Scott, Vermont is open and ready for business. 

“I think we're going to be okay,” he said in an interview. “But we have to make sure we do have that labor force they desperately need.” 

The conversation was backdropped by rising concern about the state’s business climate—especially in the wake of recent announcements from Perrigo, Dairy Farmers of America and Vermont Information Processing they would either be closing their facility or laying off employees.

While Vermont enjoys a low employment rate—an average of 2.4% since 2022—businesses across the state have hiring signs in their windows. 

Scott believes the biggest barrier to growth is the state's limited workforce. By 2030, Vermonters ages 25 to 64 are projected to make up less than half of the population. 

The governor has long been a proponent of increasing Vermont’s citizenry to lower the tax burden and strengthen the workforce. On the other hand, Janoo, argues Vermont spends too much time in a “deficit mindset,” when it should be supporting what’s already here. 

“We're not going to solve every problem with an ax, but we can grow our way out of this. I know we can,” Scott said. “We have a lot of attributes, and there are a lot of business-minded people who could be coming right down the rail trail this week.” 

People may have flocked to Vermont during the COVID-19 pandemic, but Vermont posted the largest population decline by percentage in the country in 2025, losing more than 1,800 residents.

So how does Vermont attract new residents? Keep its young people from leaving? After five terms in office, Scott’s playbook isn’t exactly new, but he argues it's proven. 

‘A lot of attributes’

Scott pointed to IBM as one example of how Vermont’s recreational assets drew needed business. The technology company came to Vermont in the 1950s because CEO and chairman Tom Watson was an avid skier at Smugglers’ Notch. 

The Lamoille Valley Rail Trail, completed during Scott’s fourth term, is the state’s newest attraction. At 93 miles, it’s the longest rail trail in New England and close to Scott’s heart. 

“When [people] say, ‘Geez, we put all this money into the rail trails, we should be putting it into the roads,’ I say, ‘Actually, we get a huge bump from what we're doing here,’” he said. “There are many stories we can tell about how outdoor recreation really does benefit the economy.”

Today, GlobalFoundries operates the former IBM campus and still employs thousands in Essex Junction. The semiconductor manufacturer got creative this year, setting up its own solar array in order to produce the electricity it needs at a more affordable rate. 

Other companies concerned about the price of utilities, Scott said, could think about doing something similar on a smaller scale. 

During the gubernatorial debate hosted by Vermont Public Oct. 21, Scott said he believes it is possible to lower the state’s utility costs while reducing its carbon footprint. Doing so would make it easier for larger corporations to set up shop and protect the environment.

Scott said he has been in talks with Nova Scotia about the potential for Vermont to buy energy produced by the province’s offshore wind. Scott's office announced Oct. 28 he signed a three-agreement with Premier Tim Houston which establishes a framework for collaboration and planning.  

“As a small state, we can’t generate affordable, clean and reliable energy alone, which is why regional partnerships are critical to reaching our goals,” Scott stated in a press release Wednesday.

Those relationships built with Vermont’s neighbors to the north give him an advantage over Janoo. Scott said more than a decade in office has afforded him time to develop strong ties with Canadian Premiers, and those partnerships are especially important at a time when the relationship at the federal level is tenuous at best. 

“They're angry, but they're not angry at Vermont,” Scott said. “They're angry at Washington, and they keep reminding me of that.”

The governor also believes Vermont can bank on BETA Technologies and wider aviation work to keep new residents coming and the economy growing. He said BETA will “be the next IBM for Vermont” and recent renovations to Franklin County State Airport will unlock new opportunities. 

State and local officials have been hyping up the potential for development at the airport for years, but acres of hangar space still remain available. 

‘Have to do something’

Throughout his time in office, Scott has touted opportunities in the trades will keep young people in Vermont—and he’s still tooting that horn. A product of technical education himself, he knows careers in the trades can be steady and lucrative. 

While his messaging has certainly caught on in Franklin County—where tech programs have waitlists and apprenticeship fairs are abundant—career and technical education centers still seem to be an afterthought in the larger statewide education system.

In some instances, for example, the latest district merger studies and Cooperative Education Service Areas separate a high school from its tech center. 

“They (the legislature) don’t have the same view I do on tech centers,” Scott said. “If I had a magic wand, I would have a tech center linked to a high school in every region, make it into a mega school because I think it’s so important.” 

This discrepancy is just one of many he has with the Democratic-majority legislature. Lawmakers this past biennium nixed Scott’s call for mandatory school district mergers and instead moved forward with study committees which leave much up to local control.  

He stands by his belief that Vermont cannot afford current education costs, especially as student enrollment continues to drop. 

“We have to do something to make Vermont more affordable,” he said. 

Scott’s campaign ads this election promise “real plans” to lower costs. Asked for more detail, he pointed to changes Republican lawmakers already helped him to pass, including expanding the child tax credit and exempting military pensions from state income tax. 

“We have some other ideas,” he said without specifics. “We just need a little bit of help in the legislature to make sure that we can go further.” 

Janoo’s new challenge to old thinking

While Gov. Phil Scott may be her opponent on the ballot, Amanda Janoo said her biggest challenge these days is “cynicism.”

“We’ve become so accustomed to the message about what government can’t do, that the idea that government could do these things feels so unrealistic, which is kind of sad,” Janoo said. 

Less than a year ago, she was a political newcomer, ready and enthusiastic to try something new, but now she’s now got a shot at being Vermont’s next governor.

“I think people have kind of lost faith that the government can make anything else more affordable,” she said. “... and it requires challenging some power in our system.”

The power of ‘magical thinking’

“Thank you all so much for coming out,” Janoo said, introducing herself to the Saint Albans Museum crowd. ”It's been a real joy throughout this campaign to be able to come to St. Albans quite a few times.”

Over 100 people had gathered in the Bliss Room that Thursday evening to hear Janoo, who stood behind the podium in the corner of the room. 

“Every time I’m here, I learn something new about this incredible community, about the things that you are advancing, the innovations,” she said. “And so, for folks who haven't met me before, I'll introduce myself, share a little bit about myself. But this is definitely going to be a bit more of a dialog than a monologue.”

Since starting her campaign, Janoo’s public playbook has repeatedly emphasized that collaborative approach. While traveling around the state, listening to those willing to share what they like best about Vermont, she’s often the one taking notes at the front of the room. 

It’s a far contrast from 2016 when President Donald Trump took over the national Republican Party, convincing conservatives he was their man with a simple phrase: “I alone can fix it.” 

“When I was starting out. I would get a lot of pressure to use much more ‘I’ language,” Janoo said. “Like ‘I'm gonna do this. I've done this. When I'm governor, my administration’ — so I'm viewed as the leader. And I was like, ‘Well, I can't do this. But we can do this.’ That is clear to me.” 

“I know enough about government that no single individual is going to be able to do any of these things I'm talking about,” she added.

Because, in more ways than one, Janoo’s platform is a new challenge to 20th century economic theories. As she explained it, both liberals and conservatives politicians have relied on standards that rewarded the top economic players for decades to reinforce existing hierarchies. 

Even Democratic initiatives hardly changed the underlying dynamic, she said. The result, Janoo argued, is today’s economy that serves the wealthiest at the detriment to everybody else. 

“We feel like if we do these things it’s going to benefit all of us, but I think we’ve reached a point where it’s clear it’s not benefitting all of us,” she said. “It's like how do we use this as an opportunity to advance a really different way—a vision for the state—and types of solutions and ways of thinking about the economy and our role in it.”

Her message is starting to gain attention. Just this past week, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) was in Winooski stumping with Janoo on the campaign trail, echoing her economic sentiments around universal primary care.

“I think Amanda’s desire to bring, among other things, universal primary care to the state of Vermont is exactly what we need,” Sanders said at the event.

Healthcare plans

Why does Janoo think universal primary care can work? Conservative commentators and Scott supporters have largely pointed to an earlier cost estimate created by state officials decades ago as a final argument, but Janoo said she sees a way forward, although she’ll need more government data and resources to be specific.

The general idea, however, is to lay a “foundation for universal healthcare” by shifting the focus of most healthcare spending away from reactive downstream costs—like surprise emergency room visits, hospitalizations and specialized care needs—to re-examine problems occurring upstream. 

In theory, the addition of public funding to help cover “community health teams” would also remove some of the profit motive, as well as cut out insurance mediators, to try to keep costs down. The types of professionals who would be included in these health teams include primary care providers, community nurses, mental health professionals, community health workers, care coordinators and independent pharmacists, according to Janoo’s online platform. 

If successful, Vermont would focus more on preventive care, such as maternal health, mental healthcare, nutrition, chronic disease management and early intervention in an attempt to make healthcare more efficient and stop problems before they escalate into more substantial needs.

To fund it, she proposed clawing back the gains the top-earners made from President Trump’s landmark legislation—the Big Beautiful Bill—which gave households earning up to $1 million an extra $50,000 per year, according to an analysis by the Center for American Progress.

An additional analysis by Fair Share Vermont estimates the state’s top 5% of earners brought home $440 million due to Trump’s political ideas put into practice.

“Those who have benefited most from decades of rising wealth and tax cuts should help ensure every Vermonter can access the healthcare they need. At the same time, we’re not simply spending more—we’re spending smarter,” her platform reads.

While her political opponents label the plan as “impossible,” Janoo said many of her economic instincts stemmed from growing up in a rural Vermont community, where people helped each other without sending bills. In standard economic models, those actions were rarely tracked or monetized, but people can still benefit from a helping hand. And businesses can still do good even if it shows up outside the balance sheet. 

Janoo said state government could change its economic approach to encourage those values and better take advantage of Vermont’s strengths, instead of focusing on its detriments.

“My economic approach comes from answering ‘What do we need in this moment? How do we make sure everybody has it? And how do we protect the things that we love most here?” she said. “I really believe in more of a rather than starting with problems, start with the vision. What is it that we're actually trying to achieve? Then let's look at ‘What is the existing system? And why it isn’t aligned?”

During their gubernatorial debate last Wednesday, Gov. Phil Scott argued against Janoo’s economic plans, explaining “there’s nothing free in this world.” Online attack ads, too—covered by a $175,000 ad buy bankrolled by the Republican Governors Association—have emphasized Janoo’s “magical thinking.”

“Even now, the worst they can say about me is that it’s ‘magical thinking,’” Janoo said. “And I'm just like ‘That's kind of awesome, right? Because first of all, all of the things I'm saying, we’re either already doing it or it’s definitely been done somewhere.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here