A fiery dispute between two Vermont municipalities spilled out of their city limits and into a Colchester Selectboard meeting last Tuesday, leaving local town reps wondering whether they had a “dog in the fight” over the Burlington International Airport.
South Burlington city manager Kevin Dorn and city councilor Thomas Chittenden asked the board to join them in a push for regional governance of the aviation hub, citing its far-reaching on neighboring towns like Colchester.
“It’s time for a change. This is a massively important piece of economic development infrastructure for our city,” Dorn said. “Communities nearby and far away are affected by operations and decisions made there.”
In a letter to the board, Chittenden said the airport, which is located entirely in South Burlington but managed as a department by the city of Burlington, “is holding our region [and state] back from mutual prosperity.”
The two cities have gone head-to-head on the issue for years, Chittenden noted, seeing “friction” over everything from taxable property values and home demolitions to dog parks.
In a joint resolution, the South Burlington City Council named Colchester, Winooski, Williston, Essex and Shelburne as communities also “directly affected” by BIA operations.
That document notes the Winooski City Council passed a resolution last November requesting a position on the Burlington Airport Commission and said the municipality never received a response.
On Tuesday, both Dorn and Chittenden lamented a lack of consistent communication from Burlington officials on the matter.
“It doesn’t make any difference what we think should happen in our community about the airport,” Dorn said. “It only depends on what the director of aviation and the mayor of Burlington think should happen.”
But BIA director of aviation Gene Richards fiercely countered their points, saying the South Burlington team was using “scare tactics” and had presented information that was “not necessarily truthful.”
“I think Thomas Chittenden is a very smart man. I don’t think he knows diddly about aviation, and I don’t think he should be making decisions or accusations,” Richards said.
In a letter to town manager Dawn Francis posted on the town’s website, Burlington mayor Miro Weinberger said a change in airport ownership “risks undermining BTV’s historic role as a regional economic engine.”
“I urge you to consider that there is a real risk that regionalization done wrong, or for parochial reasons, could actually weaken one of the region’s most successful economic drivers,” Weinberger wrote.
“It is possible that a regional authority could complicate the airport’s ability to sustain its improving financial health or serve as a catalyst for economic growth,” he continued.
Largely quiet through the back and forth, selectboard members eventually tried to suss out South Burlington’s motivation for acting now and wondered about Burlington’s interest in keeping control of the reportedly cost-neutral airport.
“Some of the claims that were sent, particularly from the mayor’s office, were citing the political issues that you brought up. So I’m trying to grasp what is really behind this driver,” selectman Jeff Bartley said. “Is it the F-35 … is it regionalization? Is it economic impact? … I’m really just trying to grasp what started this.”
Dorn said South Burlington’s motivation was “present, future and past,” saying the decades-long rocky relationship was well known.
For his part, Richards noted Burlington has been at the helm of the airport for a century and cited the investment of city residents.
At the conclusion of the meeting, the board indicated it would hold a “brief” discussion on the matter during a work session scheduled for September 18 at 4 p.m. in the town offices.
“Right now, it sounds like a family dispute,” selectman Tom Mulcahy said. “And I’m not a relative.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here