The Colchester selectboard voted to revert ownership of the causeway back to the state of Vermont due to the stark increase in repair costs within the last 30 years.
Town Manager Aaron Frank brought the recommendation to the selectboard Oct. 12, saying that ownership of the causeway has become too risky, and the town cannot front the costs associated with frequent damages.
The causeway, a path extending into Lake Champlain frequented by walkers, runners and bikers, was first built in 1900. Beginning the following year, it was utilized as a rail line on the Rutland Railroad.
In 1962 when Vermont’s interstates were completed and a decline in use as well as an employee strike caused the railroad to cease operation, the state acquired the causeway.
The Colchester portion of the causeway, the section south of the cut where the South Hero portion begins, was given to the town in 1966.
During the 30 years between 1962 and 1992 the causeway saw a loss of just 1,775 cubic yards of rock.
Because of high water levels and an increase in storms, over the last 25 years the causeway has lost over ten times that of the previous 30, about 20,000 cubic yards of rock, according to an action sheet provided to selectboard members by Frank and parks and recreation director Glen Cuttitta.
Oliver Piersen, manager of the lakes and ponds management and protection program at the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources, said long term trends in Lake Champlain don’t necessarily show a rise in water levels, but do show a significant rise in variability, meaning the levels are fluctuating at higher rates.
“We’ve seen periods of drought broken up by very large storms in a 10 year period,” Piersen said. “We set the record for the highest lake levels, but also sustained periods of drought.”
Two of the most notable events shaking the causeway occurred within the last ten years.
Following a storm in 2011 and the subsequent 67 days in which Lake Champlain remained in a flood stage, the causeway lost 8,600 cubic yards of rock, almost 6.5% of the causeway’s total volume.
During a storm on May 4, 2018, Lake Champlain was close to 100 feet above sea level and winds hit 60 to 80 mph. The causeway was pummeled by hours of waves that overtopped it by as much as four feet.
In that incident, the causeway lost around 12,450 cubic yards of rock, or 9% of its volume.
Piersen said Vermont should expect the variability in weather, precipitation and flooding associated with large precipitation events to put a greater strain on our infrastructure.
Piersen said water drainage will particularly be affected by this, but things like culverts and transportation infrastructure adjacent to rivers and lakes will be as well.
In addition, engineers tasked with building new infrastructure are no longer planning for floods that occur every 50 to 100 years. Instead, they are structures with more frequent catastrophic precipitation events in mind, he said.
Colchester has been able to pay for repairs to the causeway over the years with help from the state as well as the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
After the 2011 flood, FEMA funded 75% of repair projects, and following the storm in 2018, FEMA and state government ensured Colchester only had to pay $30,000 out of a $1.8 million project cost.
As Frank noted at the Oct. 12 meeting however, the town has been lucky to receive this help considering the stipulations needed to be considered.
Frank said FEMA can only help if there is at least $1 million worth of damage. The governor must also declare a statewide emergency, and the U.S. president must concur that statewide emergency.
Frank said various insurance carriers the town has engaged with have let them know the causeway is uninsurable, meaning too risky to be insured.
As the action sheet notes, the town could someday be fronted with a $999,999 bill, a burden that would fall to Colchester taxpayers.
Therefore, the selectboard unanimously voted Oct. 12 to revert ownership of the causeway back to the state of Vermont.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here