Race for Vermont State Auditor: Ashe and Kronick share differing approaches

Posted

VERMONT — For the first time in 14 years, the state auditor’s office will have a new leader.

Deputy State Auditor Tim Ashe and Ivar Kronick are vying for the role this November, as longtime State Auditor Doug Hoffer prepares for retirement.

The State Auditor holds state government accountable by conducting multiple different kinds of audits, including financial reviews of state agencies and programs receiving federal dollars.

The auditor is predominantly a fact-finder and data collector, who presents their findings to the governor and state legislature. Ashe, a Democrat, and Kronick, a Republican, agree that’s the primary responsibility of the position, but they differ in what they believe the impact of the work should be.

“Faith the government can actually tackle problems is probably at a low point,” Ashe told the Messenger. “The auditor can help rehabilitate people’s confidence, by pointing to instances where government is getting it right and where it’s falling short.”

While Ashe wants to prioritize review of the state’s healthcare spending in order to identify potential savings, Kronick believes the office should not have a "political agenda.”

“I am concerned it has deviated from its statutory mission and become a policy workshop,” Kronick told the Messenger.

Kronick has never before held state office, though he said he previously served on the city council in Pittsfield, Mass. He is not an auditor by trade and currently works in accounting for Domestic UK Blind Systems LTD.

Despite saying the office should not have an agenda, Kronick told the Messenger he’d like to seek out fraud and take a closer look at the Agency of Education, if elected.

“I would bring attention to education spending and the distribution of it,” he said. “I don’t know if it’s entirely possible. I’m just sort of thinking off the top of my head.”

Ashe has been Deputy State Auditor for the last five years and previously served as a State Senator, a Burlington City Councilor and an affordable housing developer.

He said the auditor’s office should do more than point its finger at failures and can instead help guide solutions.

“There’s the science of the work, and then there’s the art of trying to get the impact from that work,” Ashe said. “At our best, our facts speak for themselves and are persuasive. We have to always avoid appearing like we are trying to be policymakers or political … but [the auditor] wants to make things better.”

Ashe’s way forward

If elected, Ashe said he would continue, and expand, the auditor’s review of healthcare prices and access.

“I view those as really the primary economic drags on the state, and something needs to be done,” he said.

As deputy state auditor, Ashe helped author a report on how Vermont could lower the price tag to taxpayers for the state employee health plan. The report included the idea of reference-based pricing, which has since become the centerpiece of the state’s healthcare reform strategy, though not yet fully implemented.

“I believe the state has the ability to lower the price it pays for all public employees, which includes teachers, by using reference-based pricing as the launch point,” he said. “That is a strategy that’s sitting right before us … [and] an example of how the auditor’s office can play a role.”

On the access front, Ashe said he is interested in assessing how long people wait for healthcare services and where in Vermont they are available. One way to do that, he said, is to audit the state’s healthcare provider recruitment and retention programs — which receive millions of dollars a year.

“If we were to find that money disproportionately was being awarded to people who work at UVMMC or Central Vermont Medical Center, we might say, well, those are among the most resourced hospitals. We then might suggest how to steer the resources to actually plug those access gaps in St. Albans or St. Johnsbury or Bennington.”

Ashe is also interested in assessing municipal staffing. More and more communities around the state are having trouble finding people to serve as town clerk or business manager, which can lead to frequent turnover and a lack of experience in leadership positions.

“Towns are leaving money on the table because they don’t have the capacity to write the grant for a state program, and then even if they did, they wouldn’t have the capacity to manage and administer,” he said.

While the auditor’s office spends the majority of its time conducting performance audits of state agencies and programs, it does also look at the state’s use of federal funds.

Ashe said he thinks the office can do a better job of scrubbing accounts to identify where there may have been duplicate or erroneous payments for benefits. But the investment should be worth the result.

“Vermont has good systems in place, so my suspicion is these are not huge opportunities to rake in millions of dollars,” he said. “People often forget it might have cost $30K to do the analysis, and it only recovered $10K.

“But I do believe the state needs to do a better job communicating to taxpayers that we care about the misuse and waste of funds, even the small amounts.”

Kronick’s approach

Kronick said he would take that scrubbing to the next level with a “renewed effort in fraud.” He pointed to recent counts of benefit fraud in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program in Massachusetts and is concerned about similar abuse happening in Vermont.

“It is happening next door to us, a few miles south, and it's just kind of like if not now, when?” he said.

As a city councilor, Kronick said he was known for his scrutiny of Pittsfield’s spending. He would bring that same eye to Vermont’s much larger state budget.

The current auditor’s office, he said, is too focused on performance audits of small, individual programs. He would move away from these and instead focus on audits aimed at looking for fraud, waste and abuse.

To do so, he would target the state’s biggest spending sectors, including its education and transportation budgets.

“They are highly-focused on performance audits, and performance audits are not looking at the big spending. They are looking at millions of dollars in economic grants, which are small amounts of money,” Kronick said. “It’s the billions of dollars which have been escaping scrutiny.”

If there are mistakes in that spending or it is not making a return for taxpayers, Kronick believes it's the auditor’s role to ensure the department comes back into compliance through rigorous follow-up.

“The auditor does not simply write a report, file it in, and hand it over and walk away and say we did our job,” he said.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here