2:45 p.m. Sept. 25 Correction: This article has been updated to state eight, not 80, emails received by Austin were critical of her trip to Israel.
COLCHESTER — Rep. Sarita Austin (D-Colchester) and four other members of the Vermont Legislature visited Israel last week while the country faces growing criticism over its war in Gaza.
A total of 250 state legislators from across the U.S. went on the trip, which was sponsored by the Israeli government. The bi-partisan Vermont delegation included Rep. Austin, Rep. Matt Birong (D-Vergennes), Rep. Gina Galfetti (R-Barre Town), Rep. Will Greer (D-Bennington) and Rep. James Gregoire (R-Fairfield).
For nearly two years, Israel has been waging a war against Hamas in Gaza in the wake of an Oct. 7. 2023 attack that killed approximately 1,200 people and in which approximately 250 hostages were taken. Forty-eight hostages are still in captivity with 20 believed to still be alive, according to the Israeli military.
Rep. Austin told the Sun she went on the trip to “listen and understand” perspectives and beliefs that are different from her own. Despite criticism from some constituents, she believes the trip was beneficial for learning more about the war and interacting with top Israeli officials.
“I'm not a spokesperson for Israel,” she said. “I'm not really a spokesperson for Vermont. I feel like I represent the people of Colchester.”
Austin sat down with the Sun to talk more about what she learned and what she thinks should happen next. Her answers have been lightly edited for clarity and length.
Q: Given the controversies surrounding the treatment of Palestinians, why did you want to go on this trip?
Austin: As a legislator in Vermont, and in this instance, I think it's really important to listen and ask questions and gain understanding, even if I disagree strongly about a person's position. That's kind of how I approach things as a legislator. I don't like to just say, ‘Well, that's that person's position, and I'm not going to try to understand it or see if I can learn something from it.’
The book [“Abundance” by Ezra Klein] talks a lot about a different way of doing things. [Part of it] is to really work hard to talk to your opposition and see if there's any agreement anywhere.
So that's how I approached this trip, was to go and listen and understand.
I don't think any of us had had this opportunity before. This was a tremendous opportunity to get to travel around Israel, talk to Israelis and talk to the people on the street, not just from the government. It also was an opportunity to meet people at the highest levels of government in Israel. So it was unusual. I don't think there was precedent for it.
Q: What would you say to people concerned that this legitimizes certain military actions in Gaza?
Austin: I can understand people being concerned, you know, because I think they're kind of putting on us, kind of being used by the Netanyahu government, as spokespeople.
I feel that I'm not a spokesperson for Israel. I'm not really a spokesperson for Vermont. I mean, I feel like I represent the people of Colchester, and that's where I get information that informs kind of how I operate as a legislator in general, not always, but I do listen carefully to my constituents, because that's my role.
Q: What did you learn about Israel and the motivations of the people you visited?
Austin: I think, like any country, it's complex. I was just reading this article that even on the right, a larger share of Israelis support a hostage deal that includes full withdrawal from Gaza.
We talked to some people who want a ceasefire, who want Hamas to recognize Israel as a state. They were very grateful to the United States. I can tell you that every Israeli we met was incredibly grateful to the United States for the support that they get.
When we were there, there were two sirens, so we had to go quickly to bomb shelters. And I was thinking, ‘This is their life.’ This is their life, and I think security and safety are what are driving some of the actions that they're taking.
The other thing that is really concerning to me is the hostages. Because I feel that, if the hostages had been released on Oct. 8 and Hamas had put down their arms and surrendered, there would be no war. You know, none of this would be going on.
I am extremely upset at the level of humanitarian suffering that the Palestinians are going through. I have a lot of faith in Senator Welch and Congresswoman Balint and Senator Sanders. In order for it to be genocide, you have to prove intent. I think it is beyond my capacity to make that determination, but for those three people [Welch, Balint and Sanders] who I have tremendous respect for, to come to that decision, then I do agree. I trust they've seen enough data and evidence to come to that conclusion.
Q: What was it like traveling with your colleagues from the legislature?
Austin: Talk about being able to create closer bonds with people. I think in general, the legislature in Vermont is fairly cordial to one another, and really it's a very nice place to be, because we can have very intense debates on the floor, but when that's over, we don't take that with us.
I knew Rep. Gregoire, just because I think we came in at the same time as a legislator. But Rep. Jean Galfetti, I didn't know her well, and it was really helpful to go through this experience with her and get to know her better and become closer. I think we'll work together.
Q: What were some of the questions you asked the Israeli representatives?
Austin: We definitely asked about the hostages. What are they doing to secure their release? What are they doing to address not only the mental health of the Israelis but the mental health of the Palestinians?
Another one was deep concern about the Palestinian people and the human suffering that they're experiencing. There was one woman who was very concerned that we couldn't ask President Netanyahu questions [directly]. I heard her speaking to some of the some of our guys, and just saying, ‘Hey, I'm really disappointed that we weren't able to ask him questions.’
Q: What have you heard from constituents about your visit?
Austin: I'm hearing a lot of both positive and negative [feedback].
I’ve received maybe eight emails with a consistent message that I [should be] ashamed. People said they can't understand how I could go over and be used by the Israeli government for propaganda.
On the other hand, I heard from an Israeli Vermonter talking about the amount of antisemitism in Vermont and the rising [of it], because they keep data on it, and his concern about that and asking if the legislature is going to take any action this session to address it.
Then, I heard from another woman who is a constituent of mine who has family in Israel, and she was very grateful that we went over to understand. She knew we weren’t acting as spokespeople.
Q: Did this trip change your mind about anything you knew about Israel or enforce any beliefs you had?
Austin: I was in Israel in 1968 right after the 1967 war, and it was sad. I got a glimpse of what the Middle East could look like. I saw what Israel had done with their land, with their agriculture, with their industry, with their economy, with their lifestyle. It was just sad to me that that kind of quality of life wasn't available to the Gazans or to others in the Middle East.
I learned much more in detail about what happened on Oct. 7. Being able to talk to survivors, students as well, like a 15 year-old who survived and made me much more of a strong advocate for the release of the hostages.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here