At its March 8 meeting, the Colchester selectboard set a date for a public hearing on reducing the speed limit on East Lake Shore Drive from 30 mph to 25 mph.
The public hearing, set for April 12, comes after multiple conversations at selectboard meetings, most recently in early February when a motion to move forward with the process to reduce the speed limit on East Lakeshore Drive to be consistent with West Lakeshore Drive was sustained.
Then, director of public works Bryan Osborne and Police Chief Doug Allen spoke to the board on the subject, explaining how speed limits are set and the ability of the police department to enforce them.
Osborne said governing bodies like selectboards are not to arbitrarily establish speed limits per the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices as published by the Federal Highway Administration.
A due process is required, Osborne said, including a detailed engineering study for each individual roadway, independent of other nearby roadways that may be similar in nature, according to a Jan. 19 memo.
Selectboard Vice Chair Tom Mulcahy said the existing speed limit on West Lakeshore Drive doesn't have an engineering study backing it.
It is unclear whether or not a speeding ticket on West Lakeshore Drive was successfully challenged in court in the past as a result of the town ordinance that governs it not being backed by an engineering study.
During the Feb. 8 meeting, in response to a question about that, Allen said he would have to do research, but to his knowledge a speeding ticket on West Lakeshore hasn’t been successfully challenged.
Such studies for East Lakeshore Drive were conducted in 2014 and 2021.
The 2014 study by the Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission recommended that the 30 mph speed limit was generally appropriate and even recommended increasing the speed limit for a portion of the roadway to 35 mph, the memo states.
In 2021, Colchester Police conducted a similar study and revealed similar findings to the 2014 study, the memo states.
As a result of the studies, two radar speed signs have been placed along East Lakeshore Drive and a revised sign package has been designed for the roadway including “Share the Road,” “Recreation Area” and “Alternate Route Advised for Thru Traffic,” the memo states.
Chief Allen said enforcement of the new speed limit would also be an issue.
“As you know, as I've come to talk to you before and made several different public statements, we're kind of maxed out at the moment,” Allen said at the Feb. 8 meeting. “Our staffing is low. We are working to improve that but it's going to remain low for the foreseeable future.”
Allen said the department is keeping their heads above water, but to tell the public that enforcement would increase as a result of the speed limit being lowered would be unrealistic.
In the end, the vote in February came to a 3-2 vote, ultimately passing with Mulcahy, Jacki Murphy and former selectboard member Herb Downing. Those opposed to changing the speed limit were Chair Pam Loranger and Charlie Papillo.
Downing said at the February meeting that for the people living on East Lakeshore Drive and the residents who have been asking the board for years to make this change, it wouldn’t be an arbitrary decision.
The change is another “arrow in the quiver,” he said, and is something that will make the road safer.
"I think we have to do something, and I don't think we can have another study and see things are right, I don't think we can do nothing," Downing said. "I think that it’s important for this board to do something in response to what the people on East Lakeshore Drive want and for that reason only we should be responsive."
Mulcahy said that in all the years he’s traveled that road, it hasn’t gotten any better.
"I've traveled that cow path now for 50 years and it hasn't gotten any better," Mulcahy said. "Something needs to be done.”
Loranger said she couldn’t vote to reduce the speed to 25 mph, because she couldn’t vote for something that can’t be enforced.
"I'm concerned about putting an expectation of a change of behavior by putting a sign up and thinking that for the sake of 5 mph people are going to change their driving habits and that there'll be an expectation that this will be enforced. I don't think that that's fair," Loranger said. "And I certainly don't think it's fair to listen to your community to present a false sense of security by virtue of putting up a 25 mph sign that all of a sudden you're going to be safer and people are going to adjust that behavior accordingly."
Since the February meeting when the board voted to have a public hearing on the issues, the members of the selectboard have changed. Selectboard member Maureen Dakin has replaced Downing, who was a vocal supporter of the speed limit change.
Going into the April 12 public hearing, Dakin would most likely be the deciding vote on the issue.
At the public hearing, residents will be able to get their concerns and comments heard.
If the speed limit change passes at the public hearing, residents can expect the signs to change within thirty days of the hearing date, so long as there are no appeals, Town Manager Aaron Frank said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here