A Plattsburgh man accused of committing fraud at last year’s Lake Champlain International Father’s Day Derby appeared in court Thursday morning.
Craig Provost, 44, pleaded not guilty to the felony offense of false pretenses in Vermont Superior Court – Criminal Division.
The 10.26-pound walleye Provost claimed as his was actually caught by his derby teammate, James Braid, court documents show.
Provost had purchased “cash extras” that Braid had not, LCI director James Ehlers told police, making Provost eligible for the extra rewards, Sgt. Michael Fish’s affidavit says.
According to the document, the “cash extras” for a derby record amounted to $10,000.
Initial allegations were brought to Ehlers’ attention by Provost’s ex-girlfriend, the affidavit says.
Ehlers subsequently filed a complaint on May 31 with Colchester police, the only one he’s filed on LCI’s behalf in his 18 years with the organization, he said.
Braid and third derby teammate Kyle Laporte, of West Chazy, N.Y., both told police Provost pressured them to go along with his plan, the affidavit says.
The money was split between the three teammates, with about $3,500 each going to both Laporte and Braid, leaving a about $3,600 for Provost after paying $2,700 in taxes, Provost told Fish.
“[Provost] told me that James Braid had caught the fish that he registered as one he caught during the previous year’s LCI,” Fish wrote.
Provost’s court appearance was his first of the case, but it’s not his first to date. Criminal records show Provost has a lengthy rap sheet, including driving while intoxicated, violent acts and arson. He’s also been incarcerated.
If convicted, Provost faces a maximum possible sentence of imprisonment for up to 10 years, a fine up to $2,000 or both.
Police initially arrested Provost on June 14, said police, four days before this year’s 35th Father’s Day Derby. This year’s derby was not affected by the fraud allegations, Ehlers said June 20, noting LCI has a good community involved in the event.
Fish are weighed in at various stations around the lake during the derby. The fish in question was analyzed at a Plattsburgh weigh-in station, police said. Provost’s plan may have gone under the radar for a year, but “we think the process works,” Ehlers said.
An anticipated community event, the Father’s Day Derby is a catch for over 5,000 participants. In 2015, a total of $22,500 was awarded to the three super bonus fish, according to LCI.
Provost’s record is voided from the derby books. This year’s walleye winner, reeled in by Keith Levesque of Massachusetts, weighed in at 8.64 pounds, and the record stands at 9.97 pounds, according to LCI.
Provost and his two teammates are banned from all future LCI events, Ehlers said.
Bill McSweeney Sr. of Milton earned runner-up in the 2015 walleye category, has now claimed the No. 1 spot and will be re-awarded the prize money if allegations prove true, Ehlers said.
In court Thursday, Provost’s defense attorney, Leroy Yoder, introduced his client to Judge A. Gregory Rainville as “Tom Brady.” When leaving the courthouse, reporters followed Provost to the elevator, questioning the reference and whether the allegations are true.
To which Provost simply responded, “Don’t you guys have anything better to do?”
Provost is set to appear in court again on August 24.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here