PHOTOS: A tour of Colchester’s historic log schoolhouse with selectman Tom Mulcahy

Posted

COLCHESTER — Selectman Tom Mulcahy showed the Sun around Colchester’s historic, 19th century log schoolhouse at the end of June. Mulcahy coordinated the restoration of the schoolhouse to nearly original condition just over a decade ago. It’s been a prized landmark in town ever since. 

Here is what we learned. 

How the restoration came to be 

On Spauldings East Shore Road in the year 2000, Colchester resident Angela MacDonald found the circa-1815 schoolhouse inside her home when her family was expanding their house. It had originally been located on West Lakeshore Drive, and moved to Spauldings East Shore in 1931. 

The schoolhouse at the time that she discovered it in 2000 had been divided up into two girls’ bedrooms, some type of an entryway and a garage. But she paused renovations after stumbling upon seven-inch square logs unlike any other construction in the house. The town had it assessed the year it was extracted. 

MacDonald gave the schoolhouse to the Colchester Historical Society. However, after extracting the schoolhouse from MacDonald’s newer house, a camp that had been built right around it, the schoolhouse sat in disrepair behind the police station in the impound lot for a number of years. 

The town couldn’t seem to figure out what to do with it. 

Meanwhile, Mulcahy had just retired from his career at International Business Machines Corporation and had gone on to volunteer at the Shelburne Museum. 

“The Colchester Historical Society knew that [I’d been getting into volunteer historical work], and they said, ‘Can you restore our schoolhouse?’” Mulcahy told the Sun. “I said, ‘I don’t know anything about restoring schoolhouses.’” 

That was in 2004. 

At the time the historical society appealed to Mulcahy, the selectboard wanted it out of its hands and the fire department was getting ready to burn it as part of a training practice. 

But there was local, 19th century history worthy of preserving right at everyone’s fingertips and the historical society wanted to save it — and ultimately, Mulcahy agreed to step in and help. 

Having spent his career as a project manager, Mulcahy hired some consultants for the log schoolhouse restoration project and they got to work from there. 

“First of all, we needed some money, they didn't have any money,” Mulcahy said. “So I went to the selectboard. And at the time I was on the planning commission. And I said ‘We want to move to the schoolhouse and we're going to restore it.’ They laughed and said, ‘That's funny.’” 

But its members at the time gave Mulcahy their blessing to move it and work on it if he could find the funds. He then went to Sen. Dick Mazza — who passed just this spring — for help. Within two weeks, Mazza had $127,000 in grant money for Mulcahy to make it happen. 

The only catch was that it had to be an information center on an alternative transportation route, as the grant dollars were affiliated with the Vermont Agency of Transportation. And the schoolhouse to this day, does indeed have information pamphlets to offer to bike path travelers. 

It ended up costing around $325,000 in total to adhere to the Secretary of Interior federal standards as well as state standards. 

Though Mulcahy hit some bumps in the road along the way in getting timely state approval, obtaining additional grant money, conducting restoration, and moving the schoolhouse in a custom-made trailer at 4 a.m. when there was no traffic to its final resting place — he ultimately ended up getting the job done, with help from the contractors and some area college interns. 

When asked how he pulled off such a feat, Mulcahy his career experience in solving problems that previously seemed impossible. 

“In my position at IBM when I was working, I was always in project management,” Mulcahy said. “I’d always been given a job that couldn’t be done. And normally they wanted it finished by a certain date, and you just went and did it.” 

Colchester’s log schoolhouse first opened its doors to the public in May of 2007, at its final destination in Airport Park along the bike path. It is the oldest known structure in Malletts Bay. 

And to this day, the names of people from far and wide who come to town to ride the bike path or visit other landmarks — such as the Causeway or nearby tourist attractions in Burlington — can be commonly found ever-accumulating in the visitor log book. 

Some of its most recent visitors, as of the date of the Sun’s visit, are from as far as Canada. 

“I had a guy from Canada when I was here one day a while ago who came in and wanted to sit down on the desks,” Mulcahy said, of a gentleman who attended school in a schoolhouse long ago in his own childhood. “And he did and he just started crying. Took him right back.” 

It’s the little things 

Vermont’s distant past was home to many schoolhouses, as the state didn’t want them built any more than two miles apart prior to the invention and popularization of cars and related infrastructure which made longer distances easier to travel. 

Most schoolhouses were built to similar standards — for example, the presence of students’ desks, a dunce cap as is seen in the cartoons, and a stage-like elevated floor for the teacher’s podium, so students could look up to their instructor not only figuratively, but also literally. 

However, Colchester’s restoration team wanted its schoolhouse to be restored with as much historical accuracy as possible, sensitive to the specific character of this particular building. 

Having already had scraps of wood with old “ghosts” of paint remnants from the structure, Mulcahy and his interns ran the paint from the interiors and siding through a spectrophotometer to do accurate color-matching. They used Sherwin Williams mossy sage-green and snowflake-whites for the indoor walls and trim, and a buttery-colored paint for the exterior siding. 

At one point in the restoration process, the historical society had black-and-white historical photos of the exterior from all sides but one — and miraculously, a photo of that missing piece appeared on the historical society’s kitchen table one morning at 10 a.m., Mulcahy said. 

No one ever knew where it came from or who placed it there, he said — but it certainly helped.  

Another special aspect of the schoolhouse in Colchester is what lies in the frame of the trap door to an unfinished cellar below the teacher’s platform: a time capsule of collectibles from Colchester children who compiled signs of the times in the early 2000s during the restoration. 

It’ll be reopened 50 years from the 2007 opening date, in 2057, as yet another historical event. 

All other artifacts inside — from the desks to the woodstove and beyond — are antiques, most sourced from Colchester Historical Society members, Colchester residents or antique shops in other Vermont towns, though the vintage wall map scrolls were discounted from an eBay seller. 

The chalkboard, sourced from Dartmouth College, came with a crack that allowed it to fit perfectly onto the schoolhouse’s warped wall, as its logs became slightly bowed over the years. 

Many of the items inside were donated, to the cause of historical preservation and education. 

Opportunities to get involved 

These days, the historical society is in search of volunteers to keep the log schoolhouse open and adequately supervised as both a historic site and visitor center for long into the future. 

To get in touch about volunteer opportunities this summer at Colchester’s Log Schoolhouse, please email Carol Reichard of the historical society at winchris65@comcast.net. 

“It’s a great way to meet people, enhance your own education — this thing’s full of information — and to give back a little time to the community,” Mulcahy said. 

Those interested in visiting may do so free of charge — though there is a donation box on site to benefit the historical society — at 500 Colchester Point Road all summer from June 1 through Labor Day, Fridays-Mondays between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m. 

Anyone interested in setting up a field trip for today’s schoolchildren or summer campers can rest assured that visiting kids are encouraged to learn by doing and invited to engage in respectful, interactive learning, by exploring the schoolhouse and sitting at the desks inside. 

A precise timeline of the restoration process with before and after pictures can be found here, with a mini-documentary on the restoration of the building, complete with footage from the process and the 2007 opening day event, on YouTube. 

Additional information available with the purchase of the DVD “Colchester: A Living History,” copies of which can be found for sale at the Log Schoolhouse itself.

#csnltop, #colchester log schoolhouse

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here