On the roads, again

Posted

A sizable crowd gathered in the high school auditorium on Monday evening to plead its case once more, before members of the Colchester Selectboard pick a path forward on a plowing policy that has polarized the town’s residents for half a century.

Since 1970, Colchester has provided snow and ice removal to just 14 of the town’s 41 miles of private road. Town attorney Brian Monaghan recently recommended the town forego the maintenance of private roads altogether, citing liability concerns, cost and an imbalanced treatment of taxpayers.

The board announced it would take up the controversial measure this summer, and more than 200 residents offered comments for three hours at a forum in September.

Though the format remained largely the same as in last month’s meeting, selectboard members this time agreed to occasionally answer direct questions from residents. More than once, the back-and-forth at Monday’s forum prompted chairwoman Nadine Scibek to call for order.

“[Residents] pointed out to us that this is just gosh darn unfair, and they’re right,” selectman Herb Downing said, explaining why the board took up the matter now. “We’re not treating all our citizens fairly, and the sense of this board is that that can’t go on.”

“So you’ve already made up your mind,” one attendee quipped from the audience, prompting loud jeers from others despite the board’s swift and unequivocal denial.

Town officials originally said they would decide between three courses of action: Keep the status quo, halt winter maintenance on all private roads or provide the snow and ice removal service to all. Soon after, the town said it would also entertain alternate options posed by citizens.

Scibek said a steady stream of emails, office visits and phone calls have continued since the first forum. Those comments are also noted on the town’s website, she said.

About a third of the 80-plus attendees spoke at Monday’s meeting, several reiterating the topics debated last month. But among repeated probes of the town’s dataset, cost estimates and emergency service access, residents peppered the board with varied ideas and new hurdles.

Some, like Steve Oakland, wondered whether he would be legally obligated to plow his portion of a private road because neighbors needed to drive on the path to reach their own homes.

Pam Loranger, a Mills Point resident and chairwoman of the town’s planning commission, said the complex issue comes down to insurance and liability and called any continuance of the policy a “bright line which you cannot cross.”

Judy Hillis, a speech-language pathologist at Union Memorial School, said she was concerned about students who receive special education services and currently live on plowed private roads.

“If those roads are not plowed by the town, how are those children going to get to the bus to get to school to receive the services that are mandated in their IEPs?” Hillis asked.

A “frequently asked questions” form available at the door offered a tentative answer: Colchester School District directed the bus company to not drive on private roads to avoid liability.

“There may be instances where Mountain Transit assumed a private road the town was plowing was public,” it says. “This is presently being reviewed by the district with the contractor.”

Hillis later pointed to the town’s estimated savings if all private road plowing ceased — about $20,000 per year with the average homeowner seeing a property tax reduction of $3.16, according to the FAQ form.

Adding 27 miles of private road, however, would require the addition of two more plow trucks and drivers, costing an extra $392,100 in the first year and $191,000 thereafter, town manager Dawn Francis said at the September meeting.

Hillis, who lives on a plowed private road, says her daughter lives on a public road in Colchester.

“If you were to ask my daughter, is your parent’s health and safety and welfare worth $3.16 that you could get back on your taxes, I think you’d have a pretty clear answer there,” Hillis said to applause. “This is not the time to divide, this is a time when we need to pull together and take care of each other, and this is a prime example.”

Resident Buzz Hoerr, president of the Broadlake Road Association for decades, joined a chorus of attendees who volunteered to serve on a task force to further study the conundrum.

“Here we are in October, and we’re enjoying unexpectedly nice weather. However, soon it will do what it always does here, and it will start to snow and not be nice,” Hoerr said, acknowledging his association will need to seek plowing services if the town’s cease.

“We, for 40 years, have not been getting ready for it. Now, all of a sudden, it seems to be an emergency because you can’t get liability insurance, and we’re about to be dumped, literally, onto our private street,” he said.

The selectboard will discuss and potentially vote on the matter at its regularly scheduled meeting on Tuesday, Oct. 10 at 6:30 p.m.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here