Correction, May 12 8:20 a.m. - This article was updated to correctly identify Kristin Carlson, vice president strategy and external affairs at Green Mountain Power as well as for clarity.
When Dick Pecor and his son first approached Comcast years ago about improving coverage in the small dead zone that is their neighborhood, Comcast said Pecor and a very small group of other households would have to cough up about $40,000 each.
But two years ago, things changed and Pecor decided to organize.
The COVID-19 pandemic locked down businesses, forcing many to work or go to school from home. And for the residents of this three-mile mile block of Colchester, including Middle Road, Galvin Hill Road and Wright Farm Road, it exacerbated the already known challenges of poor broadband service.
Pecor’s grandchildren next door were having a hard time using the internet for school. His son resorted to running his business from his phone.
For many communities in Vermont, the answer to a situation like this has been a Communications Union District (CUD) — an organization of two or more towns that join together as a municipal entity to build broadband infrastructure together.
But for communities like Pecor’s, who would benefit greatly from a line extension as opposed to a whole new network, that answer falls flat.
Pecor says its left communities like his feeling like orphans.
“We're on the outside looking in,” he said from his Colchester home. Outside, trucks drove up and down the dirt road, installing new cables on new poles.
Pecor and the cohort of residents in his area banded together, unifying for the same goal, using the Department of Public Service and a grant program to lobby Comcast to commit to the line extension project.
Pecor is clear however, that his community in Colchester isn’t a model for other communities.
His story would not have been a success had it not been for a perfect storm of interests aligning, illuminating the pitfalls of the path forward for underserved communities like his and the lack of answers when it comes to getting access to a reliable network.
This month marks the two-year anniversary of Pecor and Shawn Enterline — who live in the same neighborhood — starting their push for a line extension on Middle Road, Galvin Road and Wright Farm Road.
“I have not run screaming through the woods yet, but my wife insists that I’ve been very close many times,” Pecor told the Colchester selectboard at an April 12 meeting.
Their neighborhood in Colchester currently uses a digital subscriber line (DSL) for service, but their residences are way at the end of the DSL line.
On top of that, the poles these lines sat on were out in the woods, making them easily susceptible to outages as branches and trees would regularly fall down on them. In addition, the poles themselves were rotting, making the lines dangerous to be worked on by Green Mountain Power (GMP).
Public Commision Utility Rule 8.313 lays out the state's rules around expansion into unserved areas and offers a menu that residents of those areas can follow.
Per that rule, Pecor and Enterline first began to aggregate demand, reaching out to all households in the neighborhood to get them to pledge to use the Comcast service they hoped would expand there.
“So everybody opted in, of course, these are people just like us, they have kids trying to go to school over the web, people that need telemedicine,” Pecor said.
Staying together as a community is key in a situation like this, he added. When Pecor reached back out to Comcast again after getting his 35 addresses together, Comcast said each household would have to pay $3,678.
During the pandemic, the Department of Public Service (DPS) set up a program called the Line Extension Consumer Assistance Program (LECAP), said Clay Purvis, director of DPS’s telecommunications and connectivity division.
“The idea of LECAP was to provide consumers directly a subsidy to help them purchase line extensions, basically extensions up a street or down a driveway,” Purvis said in a May 4 interview. “And the idea was to really help people who were very close to internet service, but for a variety of reasons, were not able to get connected.”
The primary issue with the program that Purvis’ department ran into was that all of the money his department had to work with was coming from Coronavirus Relief Funds. These funds had a very short deadline to be used.
The department received their appropriation in the summer of 2020 and the money had to be spent by December of that year, giving them just four months.
Purvis said that even in that short period of time the department was able to help out with several hundred line extensions.
But in Pecor’s case, with the amount of work that needed to be done, the turnaround was originally too short for such a project that required a lot of make-ready, replacing and moving the poles to a better area.
In December though, when an extension on the money was signed in Washington D.C., the department had another year to push forward with the project.
With the help of LECAP, the Colchester community was able to land a $3,000 stipend per household for the project, covering around 80% of the cost.
“So we were in the game all of the sudden,” Pecor said.
What ensued was a lot of back and forth, Pecor said. But a key to the project getting off the ground was Green Mountain Power committing to all the make-ready for the poles.
Whenever the neighborhood lost power because a tree fell or a branch hit the lines, GMP would have to have their line workers hike their equipment into the woods and climb these old poles.
Fixing the poles would not only create a safer environment for GMP workers, it would also create a more reliable infrastructure for the community, said Kristin Carlson, vice president strategy and external affairs at Green Mountain Power.
“It’s about reliability and safety,” Carlson said. “Which is the core of all the work that we do.”
Pecor said that without the commitment from GMP, the neighborhood would most likely still be where they were two years ago, an underserved area with unreliable infrastructure.
“So it just happened to be that GMP took the rebuild of this whole area on as a capital project so there was no cost that was transferred from make ready to us,” Pecor said.
Purvis said this type of situation however is not unique: line extension projects hindered by the amount of money needed to build the infrastructure.
“It would have been very costly for a broadband provider to do that on their own and you have pockets like that all over the state,” Purvis said. “Lots of people who are called 'near net.' They're near the network but they, for a variety of reasons, perhaps it's the need to underground the infrastructure because of the way the pole line is set up or a whole host of different reasons, it becomes cost prohibitive.”
These “near-net” areas of poor service are not addressed by the Vermont Community Broadband Board or CUDs, and currently there isn’t much of an answer to the question of where towns like Colchester get funding to fix their broadband issues.
The deadline for the CRF money expired and LECAP is no longer.
“There is no funding source for consumers to get their own broadband,” Purvis said.
Act 71, which was signed by Gov. Phil Scott in June of 2021, created the VCBB and the grant programs administered by the VCBB.
Per Act 71, the VCBB and its funding explicitly need to be used to provide service on a system that’s capable of 100/100 Mbps network, meaning 100 Mbps on the upload and download.
Colchester doesn’t necessarily fit into that equation because most of Colchester’s underserved addresses would benefit from a simple line extension from Comcast or Consolidated Communications who do not offer that high of a speed.
Christine Hallquist, executive director of the VCBB, said that through its funding, the VCBB is not able to offer consumer assistance for line extensions, like LECAP, though they know it’s an issue that needs to be addressed.
“It would have to come from another program. We would not be supportive of directly deflecting any of these funds, because ultimately cable is not going to be an adequate network for the future,” Hallquist said.
On top of that though, when the LECAP program was still in existence, it was incredibly labor intensive, not only becoming a full time job for many DPS staff but a huge volunteer undertaking as members of these communities fought to stay together as a unit.
As part of the agreement for Pecor’s neighborhood, all 35 addresses had to sign on, pledging to remain a Comcast customer for at least two years.
Purvis said communities that had the most success were those with a local champion, volunteering their time, going door to door, making sure everyone had the right information and all questions were answered.
In Colchester, that was Pecor and Enterline.
“I'm a retired guy and I've got time on my hands and I can sit in my office and type away and bother people until they do something,” Pecor said.
Pecor and the folks in his neighborhood are not alone in Colchester. Around 200 addresses within town borders meet the definition of unserved or underserved and are dispersed in small pockets throughout the town.
At the Colchester selectboard’s April 12 meeting, the board adopted the proposed Local Hazard Mitigation Plan which included an action to pursue opportunities for improved broadband.
The plan itself however doesn’t get more specific than that, mostly because towns like Colchester are not well addressed in current legislation.
At that selectboard meeting, part-time project manager Meredith Dolan and Town Manager Aaron Frank laid out the hurdles to fixing the broadband issue, which hinge on the fact that a large-scale, town-wide project would not be the best and most efficient approach to getting service to these folks.
The biggest impediment for Colchester is funding, Dolan said at the meeting.
Although the funds allocated through the VCBB are anticipated to cover around 60% of the project costs in more rural areas, in Colchester that number is more like 3.5% to 6.5%.
The VCBB has a formula they use to determine the amount of funding allocated to specific towns based on their “uncabled” road mileage. Through this formula, Colchester would only have access to $460,000.
Town officials estimate that a town-wide project would require overbuild of existing Comcast and Consolidated Communications infrastructure and would cost between $7 million and $13 million, according to an April 8 memo from the town.
In recent months the town has engaged in multiple conversations with legislators, CUDs and officials working in the field, surveying the town's options and advocating for funding.
On March 25, Dolan presented Colchester’s challenges to the House Committee on Energy and Technology. There and at the April 12 selectboard meeting, she spoke of the requirement of a Universal Service Plan also being an impediment to Colcehster’s access to funds.
In order to access VCBB funds, the town needs a Universal Service Plan which explains specifically how each unserved/underserved address will be provided access to 100/100 Mbps service.
Dolan said this plan would likely not accomplish the goal of getting Colchester’s unserved pockets service as quickly as possible.
Additionally, town officials say the current legislation strongly favors communities that belong to CUDs for funding.
Frank said the town has had multiple conversations with CUDs such as Northwest Fiberworx and Maple Broadband. Frank and Dolan have said that there is no overwhelming justification for joining a CUD.
Instead, town staff would like to see the VCBB change the way it determines funding allocations, a loosening of the requirement for a Universal Service Plan for access to these funds and non-CUD towns to be grant recipients.
The solutions aim to address the issues hindering Colchester’s broadband progress, however, all solutions as laid out in the memo and at the selectboard meeting in April, require legislative action.
“We’re kind of trying to fit a square peg into a round hole,” Frank told the Sun in a May 10 interview.
In terms of a solution on the town’s end, Frank said that right now there isn’t one. However, he said they are working diligently to find one.
“We've learned through COVID this is important for healthcare, education, employment and we're working on this to hopefully serve those folks better,” he said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here