Messages from Montpelier

Posted

On January 10, South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard announced during his State of the State address that online retail giant Amazon had agreed to begin collecting and remitting sales taxes to his state starting February 1. Why is this of interest to Vermont?

Like Vermont, South Dakota was unable to collect from Amazon because the internet behemoth has no physical presence within the state.

In a 1992 case, Quill Corp v. North Dakota, the Supreme Court ruled Amazon wasn’t liable to remit sales tax revenue to North Dakota because they had no physical presence in that state. The court said, however, that Congress could fix that through legislation. Twenty-five years later, Congress has tried but failed to pass so-called Fairness to Main Street legislation.

Last year, Chief Justice John Roberts announced the court would review the ruling if a new case was brought. In 1992, online shopping was still a concept. Amazon started in 1994 and now has annual sales of more than $100 billion.

When you purchase something online or by mail order that is normally taxable in Vermont, you are required to remit a 6 percent sales and use tax on your state income tax return, but only 10 percent of filers bother.

South Dakota enacted legislation challenging the Quill decision, saying any out of state vendor with more than $200,000 in sales in their state must remit sales taxes. Amazon and others brought suit, and the case is now in the courts.

However, Amazon has already opted to remit sales taxes to South Dakota, possibly realizing the Quill case could be overturned.

Last year, we passed legislation that calls on vendors such as Amazon to provide its Vermont customers with an annual statement of purchases and the taxes due to the state. That will go into effect July 1.

Out of state vendors with more than $100,000 in annual sales in Vermont must also collect and remit the sales taxes once Quill is overturned. Amazon’s decision regarding South Dakota bodes well for Vermont, I believe.

In 2007, Vermont joined the Streamlines Sales Tax Agreement, a collection of 24 states aiming to make it easier for these vendors to remit taxes to Vermont, which total $1 million annually. That number would be dwarfed by Amazon.

Amazon remitting sales taxes would level the playing field with local retailers and ease our property tax burden since 35 percent of each sales tax dollar goes directly to the education fund, with the rest going to the general fund. A significant increase in sales tax revenue would take pressure off of the statewide property tax.

In his inaugural address, Gov. Phil Scott pledged a budget that won’t rely on new taxes or fees. Having Amazon remit taxes that are already due but go mostly uncollected would be a big help in his quest to keep that promise.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here