The adage is: “Laws are like sausages; it is better not to see them being made.” Sausage making has changed a lot since the 1800s when that statement first appeared. I’m not so sure about the making of laws.
With the capital bill now passed on to the Senate, my committee (House Corrections and Institutions) is turning its attention to any corrections policy bills that have been submitted in both the House and the Senate. It’s fascinating (almost painful) to see how bills can change during the process.
Any legislator can submit a bill. Attorneys at the Statehouse are paid to help turn a constituent’s harebrained idea or diamond-in-the-rough proposal into a workable piece of legislation. If the bill pertains to the state’s corrections system, it comes to my committee.
Last week we took testimony on one such bill. The bill’s stated purpose was to allow “compassionate release” for terminally ill and aged inmates. Not such a bad idea considering the cost of keeping a person in prison.
The committee heard testimony from corrections, the parole system, victim’s rights organizations and anyone who wanted to weigh in. The 10 of us asked questions, listened, discussed, pondered and spun our wheels. At least an hour was spent agonizing over the difference between “debilitating condition” and “serious medical condition.” That’s what legislators do.
As a result, we amended the bill. We slashed the paragraphs relating to age and inserted words to prevent inmates from making themselves sicker so they might get parole. We changed the motivation behind the bill from compassion for aged inmates to a means of safely freeing up a few more prison beds. This week we report our changes to the full House for a vote.
For the poor soul who sponsors a bill, the most dreaded amendment is the strike all. It begins with the words, “strike all after the enacting clause,” which means “we’re taking everything you worked so hard on and replacing it with what we think is better.”
This session there has been at least one strike all amendment completely reversing the intention of the bill. Another committee chopped a bill in half to create two separate bills. Everything is up for grabs. That’s why I have yet to sign on as a bill’s sponsor. A bill may look good at the start, but where it ends up … you never know. And once a sponsor, always a sponsor.
Summer is coming. What comes out of the legislative meat grinder will be put on the grill and tasted. Sorry, one more: The proof is in the pudding.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here