Martell appeals conviction

Posted

A Colchester man who could spend the rest of his life in prison after admitting to sexually assaulting a 12-year-old boy is asking for a new trial.

Paul A. Martell, 54, has asked a judge to vacate his conviction for aggravated sexual assault on a minor, claiming his lawyer’s performance “fell below an objective standard of reasonableness.”

In a handwritten letter, Martell says his attorney, William Norful, filed only one motion that had yet to be resolved at the time of his sentencing, misrepresented a plea offer from the state and failed to object to inaccuracies in a presentence investigation report. Norful did not return a call for comment.

“The de facto admissibility of such inaccuracies,” Martell wrote, “influenced the trial court’s imposition of the total sentence of 30 years to life.”

Claiming the judge’s decision at sentencing relies on false statements in a pre-sentencing investigation report, Martell’s letter doesn’t point to specific inaccuracies, nor does it seek to demonstrate his innocence.

The letter is dated for March, a month after Martell pleaded guilty to the lone assault charge, which carried a sentence of 10 years to life. Prosecutors agreed to drop two other charges in exchange for his plea – a deal Martell says progressed under a false pretense.

He claims his attorney said the state was prepared to seek a minimum sentence of 15 years, while giving him an opportunity to argue for a sentence of just five years, if he accepted the deal.

Instead, prosecutors requested a minimum of 30 years at his sentencing hearing in February, arguing that his “premeditated” and “predatory” behavior during a nine-year-long abuse of a former victim and repeated offense after treatment shows he deserved a longer sentence.

The judge in the case, David Fenster, agreed. He believed the sentence needed to address the risk Martell posed to the community, which he said “cannot be overstated.”

Martell says if he had known the true nature of his plea deal, he would have taken his chances at trial, which he believes would have resulted in a “more favorable outcome,” or fewer than 30 years.

Deputy state’s attorney Dana DiSano, the case’s lead prosecutor, didn’t return a call for comment.

Martell has been imprisoned since his April 2016 arrest. His appeal is not the first time he’s taken issue with an attorney’s performance. He requested a new attorney last year when his then-attorney missed a court date.

Police testified Martell admitted the abuse, which began in December 2016, while being treated in the hospital for a pill overdose. He told detectives the overdose came after a confrontation with his ex-wife, to whom he confessed his victim’s accusations were true, court records show.

Martell’s attorney, William Norful, argued for leniency by pointing to his client’s age and his remorse, demonstrated by Martell’s attempt to commit suicide shortly after family members confronted him about the abuse. Norful said he was certain if Martell were ever free again, he would be under intense supervision and free from the “temptation” that led to this new crime.

Briefly addressing the court, Martell said he was truly sorry for his actions and planned to check himself into a hospital once he’s free to treat the “underlying problem, which is what happened to me as a child,” alluding to his own abuse.

“Suicide,” he said, “that’s always right there, because I’m disgusted with myself.”

Martell previously served seven years for sexually abusing another minor he knew. He was released to furlough status in 2010, granted parole in 2015 and maxed out his sentence a year later. He’s being represented in his appeal by Patricia Lancaster, an attorney with the Prisoners’ Rights Office of the Defender General, who could not be reached for comment.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here