COLCHESTER — When the all-Black 10th Cavalry arrived at Fort Ethan Allen in the early 20th century, its soldiers were not quite welcomed with open arms.
The 10th Cavalry’s arrival to the area “sent Burlington into demographic shock,” according to “The Buffalo Soldiers in Vermont, 1909-1913,” by David Work. “Almost overnight, the small city acquired a substantial Black community, a situation that clearly dismayed many residents.”
This is in spite of Burlington and the state having been a center for abolitionism prior to the Civil War and later sending representatives and senators to Congress fighting for Black civil rights.
The 10th Cavalry Regiment, a sect of the Buffalo Soldiers, arrived at Fort Ethan Allen in Colchester on July 28, 1909, to replace the second squadron of the 15th Cavalry and the first squadron of the 11th Cavalry, according to local historian William Parkinson.
The 10th Cavalry was the most famous of four Black regular army regiments which were collectively nicknamed as the Buffalo Soldiers. The 10th’s arrival was “alarming” and seen as a cause for “dismay” to Vermont’s almost-exclusively white population, according to Work.
Many whites feared the presence of sizable numbers of Black soldiers in their community, and a bitter debate ensued about whether the city should adopt Jim Crow facilities. Though they ultimately did not, largely due to national disapproval, de facto segregation still occurred.
Some Burlington saloons adopted separate bars for Black troopers or refused service to any Black in uniform — giving rise to a few small Black-owned businesses, like the African American establishment, Hiawatha Club, which offered drinks and dancing until it burned down in March of 1912.
For the next four years, the 10th Cavalry would encounter similar reactions and treatment as the troop traveled throughout the northeast and as far south as Winchester, Virginia.
They faced fear and suspicion from whites everywhere they went and had to demonstrate exceptional behavior to win the acceptance of established white populations in power — despite the numerous feats and accolades the troop had earned prior, at home and abroad, on behalf of all Americans.
Their stationing at Fort Ethan Allen was the first time ever Black troops had been quartered in New England, and theirs was one of the first peacetime all-Black regiments established in the regular U.S. Army after the Civil War.
The Buffalo Soldiers’ arrival in Colchester nearly doubled the Black population in Vermont for four early years of the 20th century, according to Parkinson.
The 10th came up to Fort Ethan Allen from New York City where they had just arrived by troop ship from their last posting in the Philippines, having been stationed there from 1907-1909.
Bringing the 10th to Chittenden County brought 750 Black enlisted soldiers in addition to their families, friends and affiliates — with total estimates of the influx of the Black population to the region being as high as 1,500 new people.
Prior to their arrival, the greater Burlington area had a total Black population of just 117, and the state as a whole had only 826 Black residents.
Despite the locals’ wariness of outsiders and the racist sentiments many held, the 10th was — partly out of necessity — better behaved than most white troops while present.
Created in 1866, the 10th Cavalry achieved its greatest fame in the late 19th Century on the western frontier and then served with distinction in the Spanish-American War, during which the regiment charged up San Juan Hill with Theodore Roosevelt’s Rough Riders to win public renown as the “fighting 10th Cavalry,” according to Work’s writings.
In the early 20th century, the 10th fought in the Philippine War, served in Nebraska and traveled worldwide, but the Black soldiers faced increasing racial hostility from white Americans determined to keep them in their place.
Racially-motivated bias incidents occurred in Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Texas and Nebraska, all of which served as a cumulative, constant reminder that they heroically served a nation that viewed them as second-class citizens.
Still, they continued to serve — with the 10th boasting one of the lowest desertion and highest reenlistment rates, Work wrote. In 1910, for example, the 10th’s desertion rate was only 1.52%, while white regiments’ desertion rates averaged 3.77%.
In 1912, the average time of service throughout the regiment was just over five years, with thirty-three men holding over 20 years of service, the longest duration being 26 years for Corporal William Thacker.
The Black men in the 10th were experienced, disciplined, professional and relatively well educated considering resources available to Black Americans at the time and were considered one of the best units in the army, according to Work.
Lieutenant Ker Riggs said they served with “tremendous unit pride.” Additionally, Corporal Howard Queen wrote that “the brave colored soldier in war… has always stood his ground… [and] in time of peace he is practically invaluable.”
Unfortunately for these soldiers, their accomplishments hardly mattered by 1909 when they arrived in Colchester, largely due to the memory of the infamous Brownsville Affair and its stereotyped distortion within white folks’ perceptions and generalizations about Black soldiers.
Just prior to the 10th’s arrival in Colchester, high racial tensions in a Texas border town between the white population and a garrison of the Black 25th Infantry Regiment led unknown assailants to shoot up the town in August of 1906 — with the Black soldiers unfairly blamed.
President Theodore Roosevelt discharged 167 of them without trial, but bills which sought to eliminate Black regiments altogether were introduced, though they ultimately failed to pass following the uprising. The infamous affair tainted all Black soldiers as potentially dangerous men in the eyes of whites.
The sudden influx of a substantial Black population to Chittenden County led some residents to protest their assignment to the local fort, with some even expecting “rioting and carnage.”
The then-editor of the Burlington Free Press disapproved of the all-Black regiment, writing that if the federal government believed there would be “no objection to the presence of so large a body of negroes, they were in error.”
Several bias incidents followed the soldiers’ arrival to town: a Black sergeant who attempted to cash a pay voucher at a local bank was refused service despite his voucher’s validity and on several occasions white residents left restaurants when Black soldiers entered, with many whites including then-editor of the Rutland Herald demanding institution of Jim Crow trolley cars and segregating the soldiers from Burlington saloons due to their perceived “menace.”
However, some sought to defend the town’s commitment to equal rights, and found the above reactions disturbing. Former Burlington Mayor Lucius Bigelow wrote the Free Press that there “will not be any Jim Crow cars” because no “manly Vermonter” wants them.
Elias Lyman, president of the Street Railroad Company, agreed with Bigelow and the editors of the Burlington Daily News — the Free Press’ rival — all of whom were opposed to Jim Crow cars, and Lyman vowed not to put any segregated cars into service.
Locals against the implementation of Jim Crow were only partly motivated by a commitment to civil rights. They also feared the state’s opposition to the 10th’s arrival was ruining Vermont’s reputation, with the New York Times deeming the reaction “unpatriotic and unworthy.”
Some national press outlets even compared Vermont’s behavior to that of the South.
The editor at the time of the Saint Albans Messenger wrote that this perception was “humiliating” and branded Vermonters as “stubbornly bigoted, narrow-minded, rural… negroe haters.”
The Buffalo Soldiers themselves remained officially silent on the Jim Crow proposition, having encountered similar reactions in the past.
Held to much higher standards to earn public acceptance than their white counterparts who had nothing to prove, and denied the safety to be openly assertive and expressive, only a few isolated criminal incidents came out of the 10th Cavalry while in Vermont, the worst of which didn’t even target white community members.
One incident of violent attack was found falsely blamed on a Black soldier by a white woman — with the false allegations and other damaging rumors reported out by media outlets at the time, followed by few to no subsequent corrections.
Despite the hardships, the soldiers became active, beneficial community members, performing in spectator-friendly baseball and basketball games, playing publicly in a band four times a week, performing a Shakespeare play, playing mandolin at a benefit for Burlington’s public library, as well as by allowing the public at the soldiers’ daily mounted drills and weekly parades.
Their extraordinary conduct surprised many locals who held unrealized, underlying fears of the soldiers’ presence — with a Bennington Banner correspondent at the time writing to express shock that the soldiers hadn’t shot up the town or mobbed trolley cars yet, and the editor of the Montpelier Journal, once assured they weren’t a threat, writing that “the presence of a few colored soldiers at Fort Ethan Allen will not endanger white supremacy in Vermont.”
Those interested in learning more about the 10th Cavalry’s activities and its members’ navigation of racist, early-20th century ideals may find further reading in Work’s writing.
Additional reading can also be found beginning on page 76 in Parkinson’s book, “Fort Ethan Allen Step by Step: A Walking History Tour,” published in 2017, which may be purchased at his place of work, located at the once-home of the 10th Cavalry: the Fort Ethan Allen Museum.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here