Letters to the editor (2/22/2018)

Posted

Student choice is at risk

I recently became aware of a proposed Vermont legislative policy change that will affect those students who want to attend college out of state. The Vermont Legislature is pushing for a bill that would eliminate portability of the Vermont State Grant. What this means is that if you want to study out of state you won’t be eligible to apply for the Vermont State Grant, unless you attend an out of state school within 25 miles of the Vermont border.

This causes me great concern for a few reasons. First, I think of those students who have worked hard to be able to attend the postsecondary school of their choice. They could be looking to go out of state for a specific program that is not offered in Vermont or the out-of-state school is simply a better fit for their needs. Students who rely on the Vermont State Grant will be forced to look at a school within the Vermont borders. Vermont institutions do not offer all the programs that low-income students need. The New England Board of Higher Education has identified at least 330 programs not offered in Vermont but that are offered in other states. Some examples – Vermont does not have programs in veterinary medicine or associate degrees in heating, ventilation and air conditioning or cybersecurity and healthcare IT.

Secondly, as an employee of Vermont Student Assistance Corporation, who administers the Vermont State Grant, I have always taken great pride in knowing that we are helping students achieve their educational goals beyond high school. We work hard at VSAC to make sure the Vermont State Grant goes to Vermonters who need it most. To eliminate their choice of school to attend, should they want to go out of state, seems counterproductive to me. Vermont attracts more students every year than we lose. Approximately 25,000 out-of-state students come to Vermont every year to go to college while less than 4,000 grant recipients leave to study elsewhere. In fact, Vermont is second in the nation in the net importation of college students.

Finally, as a Vermont state taxpayer, I would want to be able to see my child receive the assistance they are eligible for to go to the school of their choice. Portability is about equity. It means students from families with lower incomes get assistance toward having the same education opportunities as students from middle- and upper-income families. Portability attempts to address one of the great social justice challenges of our time —unequal access to higher education institutions has become a means to perpetuate economic and social inequality. Restricting portability restricts opportunity and serves to further perpetuate inequality for low-income and first-generation Vermont students.

There is still time to stop this proposed legislation and protect your and other Vermonters’ right to use your Vermont State Grant at a school of your choosing, not one selected for you by the Legislature. But you must act now. I plan to contact our local legislators to express my opinion that eliminating portability of the Vermont State Grant is wrong. What you study and where you study should be your choice, not arbitrarily limited by the borders of Vermont – or by shifting policies in the legislature.

Rosanne Nelson is manager of information technology and project management at VSAC. She lives in Colchester.

Support charter change

In the 50 years I have lived in Colchester, there have been several town clerk/treasurers – some good, some rather interesting, and one I remember was horrible. None have been as good as our current town clerk/treasurer Karen Richard. We have been lucky to have her elected in the first place, because sadly, most elections are popularity contests and not often based on merit. That she has stayed as long as she has clearly has been a boon for the town, but change is inevitable.

In this upcoming March election, you will be asked to vote yes or no on a charter change that will make the town/clerk/treasurer an appointed one rather than an elected position. The town clerk/treasurer job is far more complicated today than it has ever been. If you vote yes, the position becomes one where the best candidate will be hired by the Town Manager with the help of a search committee, and finally approved by the selectboard – clearly, that person will be qualified and certified for the job. Please vote yes for the town clerk/treasurer charter change.

Inge Schaefer

Colchester

Reduce taxes on Social Security

Vermont is one of four states that taxes Social Security benefits. Over half of aging Vermonters rely on Social Security for 50 percent or more of their income. Unfortunately, the tax exemption levels for Social Security have not been raised in more than 30 years. This means people are being taxed the same amount they were 30 years ago on an income that does not adequately support them.

Higher healthcare, grocery and utilities costs make it difficult for older Vermonters to live off their Social Security income.

Taxes on Social Security need to be reduced and eliminated so retirees can live more financially secure. The Vermont Legislature is considering legislation to correct this problem. Ask your representative to support this long overdue fix. It’s a matter of fairness.

Contact information for Colchester representatives: Jim Condon, jimcondon@lycos.com, 655-5764. Curt Taylor, curttaylorvt@gmail.com, 324-7188. Patrick Brennan, patrickbrennan96@msn.com, 863-3773. Maureen Dakin,  mpdakin@comcast.net, 777-8507. Dick Mazza, kfeld@leg.state.vt.us (this is Sen. Mazza’s legislative committee assistant), 863-1067.

Marie Houghton

Colchester

Do not believe what they say. Watch what they do.

Exceptional was my reaction to Gov. Phil Scott’s 2018 State of the State Address, until I learned Gov. Scott plans to eliminate Vermont disabilities funding for the most vulnerable. The following are quotes from his speech.

“Vermonters can be proud of, and our fellow Americans can look to [us] as an example of what it means to truly serve the people.”

“But make no mistake, Vermonters need and expect us to follow through on our promises.”

“A future … where Vermonters can retire right here, after a lifetime of labor.”

“Where we never struggle to meet our obligation to protect the most vulnerable.”

Do not believe what they say. Watch what they do. Jan. 29, 2018, I received a letter from the State of Vermont: “Dear Ms. Viana, During this time of year, the state works to create a budget for the next fiscal year which begins on July 1, 2018. You may have heard in the news that one proposal for the Department of Disabilities, Aging and Independent Living (DIAL) is to eliminate State General Funds for the Participant Directed Care (PDAC) services that you are receiving.”

I, Ms. Viana (Brenda Dow) have had chronic progressive multiple sclerosis for 30 years and am paralyzed. I am losing trunk strength. I must tilt my wheelchair back to sit safely.

I taught art at Malletts Bay School from 1985 to 2000. I was a teacher of 500 children per year. Those were very good years. I am proud of the love of discovery and learning I was instilling in my students. Now the Vermont community is giving back to me. The Vermont Participant Directed Care program gives me much less money than the federal program but more personal control. It cuts out the big cost of Federal government controls and regulations.

My caregivers take care of transferring me with a lift sling many times a day. They shop for and cook my food and help me with dressing and personal care. Thank you to the citizens for supporting PDAC. I now live at home with my pets. I am dependent upon my Vermont caregivers that the governor plans to eliminate.

We are better than that. I am proud to be a Vermonter. Please support continued PDAC funding.

You can phone Gov. Phil Scott’s office at 828-3333 or email governor.vermont.gov

Brenda Dow Larsen Viana

Colchester

Vote yes on charter

On March 6, Colchester voters will have the opportunity to vote on a proposed charter change which will “authorize the town manager, with the advice and consent of the selectboard, to appoint the town clerk and town treasurer.” (Article 14)

It is important to vote yes on this change as the town clerk/treasurer’s responsibilities have increased in complexity over the years, not only through improved technology, but also through statutory mandates. The town clerk oversees all public records, from land records, election records, tax records, to vital records such as births, deaths and weddings. The town banking is done online, voter registration is through the state election system as well as through the Department of Motor Vehicles automatic registration. Election results must be submitted electronically to the secretary of state. It is imperative that the town clerk be qualified to fulfill these duties based on skill, experience, and training. An elected official could earn this position by popular vote without any accountability or training.

An appointed town clerk/treasurer must be accountable to the town manager; an elected town clerk would only be accountable to the electorate.

The greatest difference is that an elected official, if suspected of fraud, could remain in that position without control from the town manager or auditor indefinitely. As we have witnessed in other towns through the state, notably Coventry and Weybridge, elected officials are more difficult to remove from office and do not report to the town manager like other department heads.

Please join me and approve the proposed charter change to appoint our town clerk/town treasurer. Vote “yes” on Article 14.

Charlotte Gardner

Chairwoman, Colchester Board of Civil Authority

Town clerk should be hired

Under the heading “all good things must come to an end”: at some point the Town of Colchester will be faced with selecting a new town clerk. We have been truly blessed to have Karen Richard serve as our elected town clerk/treasurer for the past 20 years. One could hardly find a more conscientious, dedicated or accomplished town clerk.

On the ballot this year, voters will be asked to approve a charter change that would alter the process for how we select our town clerk: appointed or elected. Currently our charter dictates the town clerk is an elected position. The voters have historically wisely and overwhelmingly voted for Karen.

However, when the sad day arrives when we must select her replacement, do we look to the voters or should we approve a charter change which will place that decision in the hands of the town manager with approval by the selectboard?

I would advocate we transfer that decision to a standard hiring process. The days when our town clerk knew everyone by their first name, and probably their dog’s name as well, has passed us by. The town clerk’s position of today requires a technical and legal background that extends far beyond the practices of the past. Regulations and technology demand a level of professionalism and expertise that is better evaluated through an extensive vetting and hiring process to which the average voter would not have access. In addition, a formal hire would be under the scrutiny of normal employment practices with annual performance reviews. This ensures a greater control over a position that has evolved from a casual acquaintance with town records to one that is comparable to any other employment placement requiring a thorough understanding of application and adherence to state statue, as well as the technical expertise to implement and oversee supervisory control of an entire department dedicated to governance conformance.

Please take the above into consideration when you cast your vote for the charter change on the ballot, Article #14.

Pam Loranger

Colchester

Explaining the school budget increase

On Town Meeting Day Colchester voters will determine whether or not to approve the school budget.

The ballot item, whose wording is set by the state, will ask if voters should approve a budget that is a 2.99 percent increase in per-pupil spending. What the ballot doesn’t say is the total budget is up 3.67 percent from the current budget year and, based on information we have at this time, is expected to result in a tax increase to voters of 3.98 percent for those with an annual household income of $90,000 or less and approximately 10.1 percent for those with an annual household income above $90,000. (The actual tax rate will be set after Town Meeting Day after other statewide data are available.)

Why would the school board propose a budget with a tax that is so high?

The biggest drivers of the budget increase are an increase special education staff to address higher demand of services and in some cases out of district placements; salary increases for all staff (net reduction in staff equal to three full-time positions); and an increase in school bus transportation cost.

The remaining 16 percent of the increase comes from smaller increases and decreases in a variety of items.

There a several drivers of the tax rate other than the school budget, including the State Education Fund Stabilization Reserve, which was used to keep statewide taxes lower last year needs to be replenished. These funds are collected through local education taxes across the state. Also, a change in Colchester’s common level of appraisal, which is a ratio in the education funding formula measuring the actual sales price of real estate transactions in a town to their assessed value. Because the transaction prices of properties sold in Colchester were above the assessed values, Colchester’s education tax rate is adjusted upward.

The board and administration have responsibilities to the taxpayers, the students and state statutes. When it comes to costs, these can often be competing interests. We are very aware that no one, including those in the administration and on the board, likes to pay any more in taxes than is necessary. At the same time, we have an obligation to offer services that will help our students succeed in whatever they choose to do. To find out if taxpayers are willing to fund the necessary services we believe the students need, the board is proposing a budget that includes those expenses before deciding to cut staff or services, both of which will likely have a negative impact on students.

We hope you come out to vote on March 6.

Craig Kieny

Colchester School Board Member

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here