Letter to the Editor: What to know about the Reproductive Liberty Amendment

Posted

This letter is from Rep. Sarita Austin (D-Colchester).


Recently, I have been hearing from my Colchester constituents asking for clarification about the Reproductive Liberty Amendment (Article 22) and if passing this amendment will change any past practices that Vermont has followed for over the past 50 years regarding reproductive rights including the right to a safe and legal abortion.

The Reproductive Liberty Amendment, previously Prop 5, is a ballot measure in Vermont’s 2022 general election. If passed it will amend Vermont’s Constitution to protect a person’s right to make their own reproductive decisions. This would include decisions about pregnancy, contraception, permanent birth control, and abortion.

This amendment does not expand, alter, or eliminate any past practices or regulations as to how access to abortions has been available to Vermont women since 1970.

The proposed language of Sec. 2 Article 22 of Chapter 1 of the Vermont Constitution reads:

Article 22 (Personal Reproductive Liberty)

“That an individual’s right to personal reproductive autonomy is central to the liberty and dignity to determine one’s own life course and shall not be denied or infringed unless justified by a compelling State interest achieved by the least restrictive means.”

The Vermont Legislature began this process four years ago. In 2019, the general Assembly passed H.157, which with the Governor’s signature, became the Freedom of Choice Act. In practice nothing changed. The passage of H.157 simply codified Vermont’s long standing commitment to a woman’s right to safe and legal access to reproductive health care, including abortion. This policy has long recognized that decisions related to reproductive health care are to be made in a private, safe, and protected space between the individual and their doctor.

Vermont’s Reproductive Liberty Amendment echos a standard well known in U.S. Constitutional law. This legal standard, known as “strict scrutiny,” provides the strongest protection against fundamental constitutional rights-in this case, the constitutional right to personal reproductive autonomy that Article 22 would create.

According to Representative Maxine Grad, Chair of the House Judiciary Committee, it is very difficult for a law to overcome the ”strict scrutiny” standard. Enshrining that standard in Article 22 is the most effective way to limit a future legislature from placing restrictions on reproductive liberty.

This does not mean our state government would be forbidden to regulate or limit those rights under Article 22. It would be able to do so if the Legislature has an extremely imperative reason to enact a restriction and the restriction is the only way to achieve that purpose.

Currently, Vermont leaves decisions on whether to have an abortion to patients and their medical providers.Those medical providers do not perform elective abortions after 21 weeks and 6 days. In cases beyond 21 weeks and 6 days an ethics panel at the University of Vermont Medical Center (the only provider in the State where abortions can occur at 22 weeks or later) may only approve an abortion in cases involving severe fetal anomaly, a fetal condition incompatible with life, or a dangerous, possibly life threatening risk to maternal health.If the ethics panel does not agree the abortion does not occur.

According to Representative, Dr. George Till, (OBGYN at UVMMC), “Hospitals are very highly regulated and the UVMMC maintains these clear guidelines prohibiting elective terminations from 21 weeks and 6 days onward. A physician can lose their license for a single episode of “failure to conform to the essential acceptable and prevailing practice”. “Additionally, state regulators require every pregnancy termination be reported to the state, and if beyond 20 weeks, reported with a complete death certificate that requires extensive background information. We only do three to five terminations after 21 weeks and 6 days per year at UVMMC. Article 22 will not change that.”

As Dr. Till emphasizes, "Article 22 enshrines a Vermont woman’s right to make informed decisions about their personal reproductive health.As stated, there are and will continue to be restriction procedures in Vermont. Article 22 will ensure that politicians will not be able to determine these restrictions and only the Board of Medical Practice and professional medical associations will be permitted to set the standards of care of which providers must comply.

This is the truth about what Proposal 5 (Article 22) will and will not permit regarding a woman’s reproductive rights. It will continue to allow the very personal and private decision’s a woman makes about her reproductive health to occur between herself and her provider.

Representative Sarita Austin

Colchester 19

285 Crooked Creek Road

Colchester, Vermont

05446

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here