Letter to the Editor: Vermont wants to transform education. Why are we going backward on graduation standards?

Posted

This letter is from Lynn Cota, superintendent of the Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union and Bill Kimball, superintendent of the Maple Run Unified School District. 

With everyone’s eyes peeled on merger committees and Cooperative Education Service Agencies in Vermont’s ongoing education transformation process, the State Board of Education is quietly working on something that is arguably more consequential for the future of student opportunity: what it should mean to graduate from a Vermont high school.

Superintendents advocated for statewide graduation standards through Act 73 because there is genuine value in coming together as a state around a fundamental question: What should every Vermont student know and be able to do by the time they graduate? This could be a great opportunity to build a collective vision for Vermont’s education system, something that the education transformation process has sorely lacked thus far.

That question is bigger than how many credits a student earns in math, science, foreign language or English classes. Graduation standards should represent what we want young people to be prepared to do when they leave our schools. What skills should they possess? What should they understand about the world around them? What tools should they know how to use? Can they think critically, communicate effectively, solve complex problems, collaborate, adapt, and continue learning? Are we equipping students to be engaged productive members of their communities, prepared for a workforce that will continue to change throughout their lives?

Unfortunately, the Vermont Agency of Education (AOE) recommendations risk narrowing those opportunities. Rather than strengthening Vermont’s movement toward proficiency, flexible pathways, and demonstrated learning, the recommendations rely heavily on prescribed credits, disciplines, and traditional coursework.

That may sound like rigor. But rigor and prescription are not the same thing.

Before Vermont moves further in this direction, we should pay attention to what employers, Vermont students, and our own Career and Technical Education leaders are telling us.

Employers Are Telling Us the Future Requires Skills

The workforce our students are entering is not one in which mastering a fixed body of information at age 18 will be enough to sustain a 40-year career.

According to the World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report 2025, employers expect 39 percent of workers’ existing skills to be transformed or become outdated by 2030. Analytical thinking is already the most highly valued core skill, identified by 69 percent of employers. Resilience, flexibility, and agility are identified by 67 percent.

The report also identifies some of the fastest-growing jobs including big data analysts, artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning specialists, environmental engineers, network and cybersecurity, the trades, farm workers, truck drivers, and nursing professionals. But the story is not simply that tomorrow’s workers need more technology. Employers need people who can think creatively, be curious, learn, lead, influence others, demonstrate resilience, and adapt to the changes ahead.

In 2024, education leaders from across Franklin County partnered with the Franklin County Industrial Development Center (FCIDC) and dozens of workforce partners from across the county to discuss trends in workforce development. The insights were clear; our workforce partners said they want employees who can enter the workforce with skills like critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, communication, adaptability and leadership.

In other words, employers are describing skills, not specific content.

Tim Smith, Executive Director of the Franklin County Industrial Development Center, said: “In the past the transition of skills to be successful in the workforce would take 10 to 15 years. Computer Numerical Control (CNC) manufacturing machines were few and far between 15 to 20 years ago, now every manufacturer has some version of CNC machines. In today’s work environment the focus is on Manufacturing 4.0 and that is changing by the week and month not the decade. Our education system needs to be prepared to adjust much quicker.”

These insights should matter enormously as Vermont decides what a high school diploma will represent.

Strong academic knowledge remains important. But preparing students for an uncertain future should not mean trying to anticipate every individual piece of content every student might someday need and adding it to a list of requirements. We should be rigorous about the knowledge and skills every student must demonstrate without assuming that every student must acquire them through exactly the same courses and sequences.

Our own students are asking us to understand that distinction.

Vermont Students Are Asking for Relevance

Students were asked directly about the proposed graduation requirements through a statewide engagement process conducted by UP for Learning. Their feedback should give the Vermont State Board of Education members and policymakers pause.

One student described the danger of continually adding requirements:

“If you add a bunch of stuff that are requirements for graduation, students will struggle – they won’t be focused on trying to learn, they will be focused on trying to graduate.”

Another challenged the assumption that rigor is synonymous with course load:

“When you talk about rigor, people talk about course load or complexity but flexible pathways make it so there is rigor in communication and things they have to do in everyday life.”

Those students are not asking us to expect less of them. They are asking us to think differently about what high expectations look like.

Students also offered practical alternatives, suggesting that emerging skills be integrated into existing subjects rather than stand-alone requirements. The report recommends integrating graduation requirements into existing or new courses. As one student noted: “Statistics and Data Science is relevant and should be integrated into other classes rather than making it into its own required course.”

That isn't a student asking to learn less mathematics. It is a student asking us to think differently about where and how mathematical learning can happen.

The Up for Learning report emphasized that course relevance and personalization drive engagement. Students want graduation requirements that prepare them for life beyond school, not just fulfill academic expectations.

We should listen.

CTE Shows Us What Is at Stake

Governor Scott has repeatedly identified Career and Technical Education as an important part of his plan for education transformation in Vermont. He has called for expanding CTE opportunities and making it easier for students to access career and technical pathways. Yet the proposal coming from his own AOE risks creating new barriers to those very opportunities.

If CTE is truly a priority of this administration, the Governor should be asking whether his Agency’s proposed graduation requirements advance that priority, or work against it.

Vermont’s CTE directors are telling us they are concerned it is the latter.

The directors are not opposing statewide graduation standards. They explicitly support “greater consistency in graduation expectations across Vermont” and the goal of improving “clarity, portability, and access for all students,” including those participating in CTE and other flexible pathways.

Their concern is how the AOE proposes to achieve that consistency.

The CTE directors warn that the proposal “may unintentionally create barriers for CTE students” because it relies heavily on:

“strict credit-based criteria in specific disciplines rather than proficiency- or competency-based expectations that can be demonstrated across disciplines and through applied, work-based, and technical learning.”

That distinction is crucial because CTE does not organize learning into the same neat disciplinary boxes as a traditional high school schedule. High quality CTE is intentionally interdisciplinary; rigid credit frameworks increase scheduling constraints for students balancing academic and technical coursework, locking them out of applied pathways.

Nate Demar, Director of the Cold Hollow Career Center in Enosburg said, “these new graduation requirements may create a barrier for students to access CTE programs. A student may feel they have no choice but to complete discreet courses at their high school because they need those ‘credits’ to graduate. Let’s not create a system that results in students deciding that enrolling in the CTE center might become a barrier to graduating on time.”

One Vermont student put the consequence much more simply:

“That one credit could stop you from doing the tech program that you wanted.”

We cannot claim to prioritize expanding CTE access while simultaneously adopting graduation requirements that make technical programs harder to fit into a student’s schedule.

What Does It Matter Where a Student Learns?

To see how this works in practice, consider a student participating in a work-based learning experience.

The Northwest Career and Technical Center and Bellows Free Academy (BFA) in St. Albans offer work-based learning opportunities to students who want to show their learning through real-world applications. Because faculty have identified student proficiencies and how to assess knowledge and skills, students can demonstrate learning across multiple content areas and transferable skills standards. Students can show their learning through an application that engages them as learners.

The policy question Vermont should be asking is: What knowledge and skills should every graduate be able to demonstrate? Once defined, we should be open to students demonstrating those standards and skill based competencies through traditional academic courses, CTE, interdisciplinary learning, work-based learning, internships, dual enrollment, and other high-quality flexible pathways.

While some students may prefer to take a class, graduation requirements should define what students learn, not the time in course or the number of credits they need to earn. It is about what a student knows and can do.

That distinction matters enormously for CTE so they can integrate skills and standards into programs, but it matters beyond CTE as well.

Consistency and Flexibility Are Not Opposites

Vermont should establish clear, rigorous, statewide expectations for what every graduate knows and can do. A student’s zip code should not determine what a Vermont diploma means.

Rigor should reside in the standards students are expected to meet and the quality of evidence required to demonstrate that they have met it, not in the uniformity of the path they took to get there. There is nothing inherently rigorous about accumulating another credit. Putting “Geometry” on a transcript does not, by itself, tell us whether a student can reason mathematically. Sitting in a classroom for a prescribed period of time does not tell us whether a student has mastered the material.

What matters is what students have actually learned and what they can do with that learning. That isn't lowering the bar.

It is putting the bar where it belongs.

Vermont has spent years building a policy foundation around proficiency-based learning, flexible pathways, CTE, work-based learning, and personalization. Now, in the midst of a statewide effort explicitly described as education transformation, we have an opportunity to build on that foundation.

We should not squander it by looking backward.

Employers are telling us they need adaptable, analytical, creative, technologically fluent lifelong learners. Vermont students are telling us they want relevance, flexibility, and meaningful ways to apply what they learn to prepare for life beyond school. CTE leaders are telling us that overly rigid credit requirements can actually restrict students’ access to the very pathways we say we want to expand.

Let’s create graduation standards that are rigorous about what matters most: what Vermont students know, what they can do, and whether we have prepared them for the future they will actually inherit. We are asking the AOE, State Board, lawmakers, and education leaders to help us to change course.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here