This letter is from John Tague, Franklin West Supervisory Union; Lynn Cota, Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union; Bill Kimball, Maple Run Unified School District; and Julie Regimbal, Missisquoi Valley School District.
The latest attempts at school funding reform are a stark reminder of how disconnected the current legislative process is from the realities facing our local districts. The Senate version of H.454, while masquerading as a solution, does little to address the core drivers of skyrocketing costs: the unsustainable burden of healthcare, the ripple effects of housing shortages, the crumbling infrastructure of outdated facilities, and the escalating mental health needs of our students. In fact, it actively makes the situation worse for many schools and communities.
The bill ties future education spending to FY25 levels and applies an inflation index that fails to account for projected spikes in healthcare and other costs. Both the House and Senate versions of this bill establish a foundation funding formula based on student weights; however, the Senate version does not rely entirely on evidence-based modeling.
The Senate version of H.454 creates a model that will increase education funding levels for most districts in Franklin County, except Maple Run. However, this model comes with a catch: it also increases taxes between 3% and 30% for residents of Franklin West, Missisquoi Valley, and Franklin Northeast school districts. In Maple Run, the school district taxes will decrease by 6%, but overall district spending will also decrease by 3%.
This approach will force some schools to make deep cuts, eliminating valuable programs for students. Other communities may benefit from more funding, which will likely be coupled with substantial increases to their tax rates. Using our current tax structure, this new foundation formula would significantly increase taxes in many towns, without a vote by residents. While offering a slight decrease for some towns, it imposes harsh financial burdens on others, at the expense of student opportunity.
Furthermore, the House proposed an experienced and skilled subcommittee under the Commission on the Future of Public Education to guide the drawing of new school district boundaries. The Senate replaced this with an all-legislator task force, lacking the essential expertise and politicizing an evidence-based process. The absence of educator voices in this bill draft is a serious concern. We must remember that these decisions profoundly affect our children's education and the overall health of our communities; the perspective and insights of people with educational expertise are essential.
As Franklin County superintendents, we need to point out that the Senate version offers piecemeal changes rather than advancing a complete, evidence-based funding model. This approach lacks coherence and transparency and could expose the state to legal challenges under the Brigham decision (Brigham v. State, 166 Vt. 246 (1997)).
Our schools are not failing. They're being starved and manipulated by a system that seems designed to create winners and losers. Until our elected officials demonstrate the courage to confront these fundamental cost drivers and craft equitable solutions, we're simply rearranging the deck chairs on a sinking ship. Our children deserve better than this political charade. They deserve a real investment in their future and a fair funding mechanism.
We collectively agree that our education system is too expensive, inequitable, and that our infrastructure is failing. Reform is needed, and we ask that our legislators commit to working across party lines and chambers to pass legislation that improves Vermont’s public education system for all of our students. Vermont needs legislation that meets the goals they were tasked with achieving: affordability, improving educational opportunities for all students, while addressing the tax burden this places on Vermonters. We don’t have the control or a vote on this legislation, but our Senators and Representatives do. If you have questions or suggestions, we recommend that you reach out to them directly.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here