Letter to the Editor: How to clean up the waters of inner Malletts Bay and respect its fragile environment too

Posted

Jack T. Scully is a former Colchester selectboard member and past chair of the Malletts Bay Advisory Commission.


 

On Aug. 20, 2019, Craig Heindel, a senior hydrologist at Waite-Heindel Environmental, told the Colchester Planning Commission and dozens of citizens that a portion of the town’s 14-acre wooded lot on East Lakeshore Drive has good potential to act as a community septic system for inner Malletts Bay. 

“This site will work,” he said  citing his professional experience and similar site evaluations. Heindel advised that if a “drip-dispersal community system” were permitted and installed, damage to the natural habitat would be minimal. Technology exists to snake dispersal piping around trees and bushes with little loss of natural habitat. 

Added bonuses include: 

  • Drip systems do a better job of removing phosphorus and nitrogen from wastewater than conventional sewage treatment plants.

  • Colchester will not contribute additional effluents that flow into Vermont’s 92 sewage treatment plants. All plants eventually discharge into Lake Champlain, its rivers, or bays. All told 15 billion gallons of varying degrees of treated wastewater are annually discharged into our waterways. Along with stormwater, impervious surfaces,  and agricultural runoffs, they are major contributors to toxic blue-green algae blooms, fish kills from oxygen depletion, murky water, and the proliferation of nuisance weeds.)

  • Elimination of human wastewater leaching into groundwater or Malletts Bay while replenishing the aquifer.

  • Preservation of  an environmentally sensitive resource when offering people a number of passive four-season recreational uses, including a multipurpose bike trail connecting to existing bike paths. 

  • Compatibility with the Colchester’s Master Plan. Development of the back 10 acres of the property can still be sited, as planned, for recreational purposes. 

At that Aug. 20, 2019 meeting, citizens were told by town planners that the community septic system should be designed to accommodate all 289 properties in the inner Bay’s sewer service area. This is an unnecessary budget-busting requirement. Water sampling and a $2 million EPA study have confirmed that, at best, 5-8% of the E. coli found in the inner Bay can be traced to human bacteria. 

By limiting the size of the community system, more funds will be available to attack the major sources of polluted water in the inner Bay: stormwater discharges, runoff from hard surfaces, the flow of pollutants from Smith Hollow Brook and Crooked Creek, as well as boat discharges, and the droppings of pets and wild animals.  

A cost-effective, win-win approach for the environment, water quality, and public health is to connect failed, failing or unstable septic systems only. Included here are all “high risk” Goodsell Point and East/West Lakeshore properties with inadequate septic systems on the fragile rim of the Bay. 

Exemptions to forced connections should be granted for the following:

  • Waterside East Lakeshore properties that are presently pumping wastewater to compliant mound and cluster septic systems on the landside of the road.

  • Landside East Lakeshore properties in which residents have invested significant dollars, ranging in some case from $20,000-$45,000, to engineer and install compliant septic systems.

  • Goodsell Point properties (presently 6 of 16 by one count) that have developed upgraded septic systems.  

  • West Lakeshore properties whose septic systems pose no threat to water pollution. 

VOTE on March 1, 2022: The critical next step in protecting water quality and the natural environment of Inner Malletts Bay is to say NO — once and for all— to a public sewer. Only then, can we implement a truly comprehensive program to save Malletts Bay for future generations.    

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here