COLCHESTER — Aside from the murkiness of Act 127, there are many other components to education reform being considered by Vermont’s legislature this session.
In the midst of the session, most bills are still just propositions. Rep. Sarita Ausin (D-Colchester), who sits on the House Committee on Education, spoke with the Sun about what her committee has been working on and discussing in recent weeks — and what she hopes to see materialize following the session’s end.
“I think there's this overall feeling, I know on my part there is and I think I can speak for the majority of the education committee, that the current model that we're using for education funding and the process is unsustainable,” Austin said. “With lowering enrollments, and a lack of people coming to Vermont, in terms of taxing capacity.”
Over the course of the last several weeks, the education committee has organized a task force study group to work out feasible financing and incentivization opportunities for addressing deferred maintenance and school construction — a major problem in school facilities statewide — while simultaneously seeking to streamline and consolidate educational offerings in districts with declining enrollments to keep budgets sustainable.
“I think there's a recognition across the legislature that something needs to change, something needs to shift,” Austin said.
Though nothing yet is set in stone, the committee has looked into consolidating smaller schools, but that could see pushback as small schools are often important to Vermonters as community centers.But with enrollment statewide having dropped in recent years by tens of thousands of students, Austin doesn’t feel the state can justify the same budgeting figures they had a decade ago.
As an extension of the consolidations being considered, there’s been talk of collaborative entities with representation from all districts that sign-on to Boards of Cooperative Education Services, which could help districts with provisions for certain common needs. This could entail, for example, ordering supplies in bulk for multiple districts for efficiency and monetary savings — among other collaborations.
“We have to start reflecting,” she said. “There are less students in school and so the cost of education should begin to drop with there being less children. It's just, it's hard for me to understand how costs are going up so dramatically, in that landscape.”
Still, there are a number of factors driving costs up in the education sector for other reasons, which Austin said needed to be addressed and taken into consideration.
“It's a complex formula,” she said. “I go to every single workshop on educational funding and I can follow the different silos and it's just when they start to intersect with one another and then developing the yield — this year, I always felt like it was like the perfect storm.”
A large part of the inflated school budgets issue this year is most likely due to the stipulations of Act 127 and the fact that a number of schools tried to squeeze much needed construction projects into their budgets this year, largely as a result of the deferred maintenance aforementioned, but the scale of such efforts are likely to drive up taxes significantly.
Other drivers include the increasing costs of health insurance for employees as well as the increasing need for counseling and mental health care for students. In the last four years, many schools have seen more children unable to regulate their emotions and behaviors.
One of the suggestions floated in committee was to potentially revisit insurance pricing negotiations as one of several ways to partially contain these rapidly rising costs.
“Before I was a legislator, I was a school counselor,” Austin said.
As a school counselor, she studied the psychological impacts on students and school communities in the wake of a school shooting, and how to help a school recover psychologically from that. Now, there are other factions at play in the national socio political landscape that might be contributing to an increase in mental health issues in schools, she said.
Although it’s largely speculation, and likely a result of a combination of factors, Austin believes it’s possible the transition back to in-person from isolation following the height of the COVID-19 pandemic might have led some students’ social skills to atrophy or to their mental health declining in other ways.
“There was a lot of unknown which I think brought a lot of fear,” Austin said.
“I think that was very stressful for families and as a result was very stressful for children,” she added. “And so, what we say in the field with disaster recovery is the behavior is normal to an abnormal situation. So you look at it more that the anxiety of the deregulation is a normal reaction to a very abnormal situation, which COVID was.”
Austin said she wishes the federal government would have allotted more money for collective pandemic recovery, to go beyond just meeting the needs of people’s physical health.
The new pupil weighting formula that was a part of Act 127 also likely gave the state a more accurate depiction of the additional support needs of the state’s youth. The weighting system in place prior to Act 127 was not backed by data and was very arbitrary, Austin said. Now, a UVM study has found that schools with less funding and resources tend to have more students with additional needs for support in order to succeed academically.
“All of that kind of contributed to where we are today,” Austin said.
Balancing the real resource needs of students and staff while addressing numerous deferred maintenance challenges in school facilities statewide in conjunction with inflation, while also attempting to bring overall costs down in alignment with declining enrollments, will prove tricky.
“Again, it's a multi-pronged approach in terms of how to bring these costs down,” Austin said.
Aside from the idea of further health insurance negotiations, one of Austin’s biggest points of hope is the consolidation of school programming in districts with declining enrollments and class sizes, and possibly establishing a class size minimum in middle and high schools, following more testimony and study of the current state of enrollment.
Additionally, there’s been talk of possibly making changes to the bylaws of negotiations for teachers and school board unions to find more compromises that could slim school budgets down moving forward. Austin also said having high-quality teachers could perhaps lessen the need for paraeducators — again, in an effort to keep budgets more fiscally conservative.
The legislature is also looking at schools’ bonding capacities for the sake of addressing deferred maintenance projects.
Statewide, the deferred maintenance problem is huge, with spending needs sitting at over $300 million over the next 20 years to address facility deficiencies in a 21st century learning environment, according to a recent study on school construction aid.
There is still room for more specific financing models, incentivization plans, strategy developments and staggered implementation moving forward within the task force her colleagues are setting up for addressing school construction needs, Austin said.
For the time being, PCB testing and remediation is slowing down, if not soon to be paused altogether, due to inadequate funds available for testing and related logistical challenges, and legislators hope to align the process more efficiently with school construction and consolidation.
Read more reporting on PCBs here, and find testimony from the Agency of Natural Resources’ secretary Julie Moore earlier this legislative session here and here.
Other topics of discussion in the House thus far have included evidence-based literacy bills and ideas for putting technical skills training opportunities on more public school students’ radars.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here