COLCHESTER — Building and publicizing a school budget can come with confusion on the part of taxpayers, especially in a year like this when the funding formula is changing drastically.
In an effort to give the public the answers to some common questions about district needs, the budget and associated taxation, the Colchester school board held a budget Q&A session at its meeting Tuesday night, filmed by partner Lake Champlain Access Television.
“We encourage all of our Colchester residents to get out and vote,” said Superintendent Amy Minor. “You can vote in person on Tuesday, March 5 at Colchester High School from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. There is no deadline to register, you can register any day up to and including the day of the election. You can register in person at the town clerk's office, online or in person at CHS.”
Minor also encouraged folks to vote early or with absentee ballots if need be by requesting a ballot be mailed to one’s address or by voting early at the Town Clerk’s office.
Student school board representative Phoebe Richardson served as Q&A moderator, posing different questions to different administrators and board members throughout the event.
The first question Richardson relayed was directed to Minor: What does student enrollment in the Colchester School District currently look like?
Minor said enrollment in CSD is stable and strong. In 2013, the district had 2,148 students and this year it has 2,151.
Every five years, the school commissions a demographic report to see how enrollment is projected to look for the next several years. Enrollment is expected to stay strong at just under 2,200 students for years to come, even before accounting for students who might join the district from towns that don’t offer middle or high school grade level education.
In one classroom with one teacher, the Vermont Education Quality Standards outline recommended class sizes for grades K-3 to have no more than 20 students per class, and in grades 4-12 to have no more than 24 students per class, with upper grade level teachers also not teaching more than 100 total students in their roles.
This school year, grades K-3 saw 19-20 students per classroom and in grades 4-12 there are 20-22 students per classroom — in other words, CSD is currently just within the state’s quality standard benchmarks, Minor said.
The district was out of compliance with these standards when Minor first became superintendent eight years ago.
“We've seen a tremendous investment by this community in the students in Colchester,” she said of the progress they’ve made in more recent years.
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, students have had continually increasing needs.
In 2008, Colchester students qualified at about 23% for free and reduced lunch. This year, it's 38%. In 2008, 11 students in the Colchester school district were experiencing homelessness; this year there are 95 students in CSD experiencing homelessness.
The percentage of students in the district that qualified for special education services in 2008 was 12.5% and this school year is 18%.
“I think we've seen a number of reasons why the needs are rising, and we've seen a tremendous change in our students post-COVID,” Minor said. “One of our strengths that I'm really proud to report is we have amazing employees in our district.”
There are 10 support staff also licensed as teachers and 82% of CSD teachers hold master's degrees. The school has also invested in mental health support provisions for students and post-COVID the district saw numbers of students participating in co-curriculars rise again after decreasing at the height of the pandemic.
“We've made quite an investment in our employees and the stronger our employees the better services our students are receiving over the last couple of years based on the needs of students in our district,” Minor said.
The next question was for Gwen Carmolli, director of curriculum for CSD: As a district, our goal is to close the achievement gap and increase students’ performance goals — can you share some investments the district has made?
The district has added standardized, computer-adaptive Star Assessments from kindergarten through grade 10, which looks at early literacy in the primary grades, and reading and math for higher grades, Carmolli said.
They’ve also added a software called Panorama which helps compile assessment data to view academic and social emotional learning, including engagement data, attendance data and more, to then drill down into for educational support and intervention.
The district has also added literacy and math interventionists to provide enhanced instructional coaching in those areas, and has added professional learning opportunities for staff focused on instructional strategies for teaching literacy pedagogy and math pedagogy.
CSD now ranks above Vermont averages in literacy, English language arts and mathematics, and since having implemented the above changes, scores went up at CSD in how its students of color did and how students experiencing poverty and students with disabilities did.
“So our investments are starting to pay off,” Carmolli said. “We're really excited about that [...] The improvement for students with disabilities is something we've had flat results for about a decade and we've been working really hard on that.”
Students have also been more engaged in the classroom since the implementation of these multipronged investments.
“We do acknowledge that this is a work in progress,” she said. “We are above the state. We've seen some nice growth and we have room to grow.”
For school board vice chair Nic Longo: Can you share with the Colchester community what is included in the FY ‘25 budget?
“We have a lot of strengths and a lot of academic achievements that we're pursuing, and this current budget maintains that current programming and that level of services throughout the district,” Longo said.
This includes keeping all of the current course offerings and maintaining all professional staff, as well as access to support services, school counselors, co-curricular activities like sport and summer school programming, as well as facility maintenance resources.
The new budget also includes two new positions: the addition of a 504 coordinator at the Colchester Middle School and the addition of a multilingual department teacher for district newcomers, as multilingual student enrollment is slated to see a significant uptick next year.
For Minor: Can you share with the community how Act 127 has impacted Vermont’s education funding formula?
This is the first year Act 127 comes into play in Vermont, in the spirit of providing funding to districts with students that cost the most to educate and distribute funding more equitably. The state changed the weighting categories of students in an effort to achieve this.
Multilingual learners and students of lower socioeconomic status now are weighted higher under Act 127, for example. One of the components of Act 127 that went into place this year was a 5% tax cap. Colchester qualified to cap educational spending taxation at a 5% increase.
For school board chair Lindsey Cox: What are some of the major driving factors of the school budget?
Seventy-eight percent of the school’s budget goes towards employee salary and benefits, for the more than 400 employees employed by the district including the number teachers needed to stay within class size quality standards, as well as administrators, support staff, counselors, coaches, interventionists, food service workers, maintenance workers and more.
In contract negotiations among employee bargaining units, it takes a lot to keep competitive and enticing packages desirable for qualified employees in times of the level of inflation and worker shortages seen in this day and age, she said.
The statewide health care contract, which is not negotiated at the local level but at the state level, increased by 16.4%, which is an astronomical increase and student transportation increases also went up over 5% after two years of increasing in the double digits.
It is also costly to operate and maintain six aging buildings over 100 acres of property, much of which is in need of repair to ensure safe and positive learning environments.
For board clerk Ben Yousey-Hindes: Can you share with the community how Colchester’s per-pupil spending compares to other districts across the state?
Comparing CSD’s per pupil spending to other school districts, it's clear that Colchester continues to take very seriously the need to balance strong education and support our students with the demands that are placed on our communities, taxpayers and businesses, he said.
Historically, Colchester has been one of the lowest spending districts, if not the lowest, in all of Chittenden County. The district has been the lowest spending district per pupil in the county since fiscal year 2021.
For the current school year, the district is spending about $1,900, or about 13%, less per equalized pupil than the statewide average. Even with the additions that the new budget requests, Colchester would remain one of the lowest spending districts in Chittenden County based on per pupil spending and, per usual, well below the statewide average.
For school board member Felix Anderson: Can you share with the Colchester taxpayers what the tax impact has been over the past nine years?
The average residential tax increase over the past nine to 10 years has been 1.53%, Anderson said. There have been years that were higher than that and two years in which there was a decrease in the residential tax rate which was in 2017 and 2023.
Last year at this time with a similar increase in the overall budget, we were still looking at an estimated increase of 2.61%, which will speak in part to the role that Act 127 is playing in this year's budget tax rate — as well as demonstrate the board’s and administration's commitment to being fiscally conservative while still supporting education for all Colchester students.
For Longo: Can you share what the common level of appraisal is and how it impacts the tax rate?
“The CLA for sure is one of the variables in the education funding formula that is set by the state,” Longo said. “It has a significant impact, however, on our local educational tax rates.”
The CLA measures how close a community's assessed property value is to its fair market property value, and is designed to ensure everyone who pays an educational property tax in Vermont pays based on their property's estimated fair market value, which levels the playing field from town to town.
The last appraisal in Colchester was initiated over a decade ago in 2011, which creates a disparity between assessed and the fair market values.
This gives the impression that the school tax rate or school tax increase as a percentage is quite a significant increase, but the school district does not have the authority to conduct a town reappraisal to redistribute how the owed taxes are collected, only the that the town of Colchester does, and until an appraisal is completed, taxpayers in Colchester can expect to see a higher educational tax rate percent increase as a result of the CLA, Longo said.
Once this is calculated into the state's funding formula, this proposed budget would have led to a 5% increase, if it was capped at 5%, Longo said. However, with Colchester’s CLA adjustment, the resulting estimated tax impact is 15.5%.
“Again, this factor is completely outside of CSDs control,” he said. “Approximately 80% of the increase to the educational tax attributed to the town of Colchester is because of this CLA adjustment.”
For Minor: The legislature has been talking about making the late adjustment to Act 127, can you share what and why this is?
In early January, lawmakers started to realize there were some unintended consequences for the way Act 127 was written, Minor said. When they modeled Act 127, the modeling did not reveal the high tax increases that are resulting not just in Colchester but across the state.
In response to the realization, lawmakers started to go to work to figure out what they could do at this point in the process to try to make a change. One of the components that they looked at was really studying the impacts of the 5% tax cap.
“Some districts decided to add millions of dollars to put in their capital reserve fund or to use for projects that quite frankly, were probably needed in those districts because of deferred maintenance, but the more districts that took advantage of the tax cap, the more our spending went up as an entire state,” Minor said.
Now, the legislature is working to remove the tax cap, incentivizing higher-spending districts to look at what their spending was to potentially make a reduction, like removing those millions of dollars that they added for capital reserves.
“Colchester was not in a position where we were one of the districts that made that decision,” Minor said. “The other side of the 5% tax cap, which is a little complicated to understand, it gives you room to add millions of dollars to your budget, but it also makes it really difficult to then reduce your budget.”
In short, under the old stipulations, if CSD were to try to decrease its tax rate as a district with the cap in place, the district would need to cut $4.8 million from the CSD budget or the equivalent of 50 full-time employees in order to get the tax rate from 15.5% to 15.49%.
This will all change when the modifying bill, H.850, is made official by Governor Phil Scott, removing the tax cap altogether and instead adding in its place a cent reduction as a transition mechanism for what's going to happen over the next five years.
Act 127’s modifying bill H.850 has been passed at this point by both the House and Senate. Colchester on its tax rate will receive an eight cent reduction in taxes as a result.
The other component that House Ways and Means is working on that will impact the tax rate is what they are going to set the yield at. The higher they set the yield at, the lower the tax rate. The yield will be set at the end of the legislative session.
For Cox: Now that we know some of the needs in the district, can you share what the estimated tax rate will be and what it means for Colchester residents?
“I feel like this year especially this feels like a trick question,” Cox said. “Having been on the board for a decade now, every year I continue to understand and uncover more and more layers on education funding in our state and with Act 127 really changing that landscape.”
Most years the district is able to give taxpayers a good estimate of tax impacts in February or March to Colchester residents. However, given the new formula and the continuing changes in the legislature, providing that sort of estimate this year will prove to be hard.
If everything stayed exactly the same the way that it is the way the Act was passed, and if the dollar yield stayed exactly what it is today, the potential residential tax rate would have been 15.5% with the warned budget of just over 57 million.
However, with Scott expected to officialize H.850 soon, that number will drastically change.
“Felix just mentioned that over the past decade, we have had an average increase of 1.53%, with two years seeing decreases,” Cox said. “This year and the 15 and a half percent is obviously an anomaly due to this new legislative landscape.”
For Anderson: Can you share how Colchester residents can take advantage of the state’s property tax credit?
All households that make less than $128,000 a year are eligible for a form of assistance called property tax credit, which calculates a homeowner's taxes based on their income instead of by the value of their home. The income threshold is reset each year.
In Colchester, just over 60% of taxpayers qualify for this property tax credit. Those who qualify and want to apply must file two forms — programs like TurboTax automatically suggest them.
For Yousey-Hindes: Can you share a little bit with the community about what the school board’s focus will be over the next year?
“Once we hopefully have most of the budget in the rearview mirror, we will turn to focusing on facilities,” Yousey-Hindes said. “The district has six buildings. And I think one of the themes that's very clear, especially in the middle school and Porter's Point and Union Memorial — these are schools that are very big on heart and passion, and pretty darn tight on space.”
The district will take input from community members to develop a facilities plan, seeking to increase space available to serve students needs, especially for the district’s youngest learners. Preschoolers are at the Malletts Bay School currently, where other students are in grades three-five, though they shouldn’t be separated from kindergarten.
Colchester Middle School is also very tight on space, with many licensed teachers borrowing classrooms and wandering with their materials in carts in the halls between — let alone the need for space to offer support services.
For Anderson: As an outgoing school board member, can you share the challenges that school boards face in ensuring schools are providing a high quality education for students?
“It's clear the basic challenges are to enable the best education in a most fiscally responsible way and achieving this doesn't happen by accident,” he said. “There are many things, obviously, that need to be considered, argued about and acted on.”
These include attracting and retaining people to work here in all capacities, fostering a supportive environment that enables curriculum to reach all students, driven by strong, clear, up to date policies, good communication between the schools and administrators, maintaining the aging buildings, and being advocates for the community.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here