LCATV Forums: Hearing from Grand Isle Senate candidates for 2024 election

Posted

COLCHESTER — Lake Champlain Access Television, as part of its 2024 election forum series, hosted the Grand Isle district’s Vermont state senate candidates last night at its office in Colchester. 

Moderated by Sun reporter Ella Ruehsen, with assistance from Shannon Gunderson of the Milton Independent, Sen. Andy Julow (D-Grand Isle) and Pat Brennan (R-Colchester) joined hosts and moderators to answer a number of questions, both planned and viewer-submitted. 

The following is a transcript of questions and responses, edited very slightly for clarity. 

Opening remarks 

Brennan: I'm Pat Brennan. I'm a candidate for the Vermont Senate, representing Colchester and the islands. I'm a lifelong Vermonter, long time small business owner. I owned and operated the Blooming Onion concessions at the fairgrounds forever, Brennan's Quick Stop for over 20 years. My message tonight is about Vermont. Vermont is broken. We are facing numerous crises. We have a population problem, affordability, taxes, housing, health care, food, addiction. I believe I have the tools we need to succeed in bipartisan relationships, understanding governance. I've been in the legislature for 22 years. I have the support of Democrats, independents, Republicans like Governor Phil Scott and Mike Mazza, Sen. [Dick] Mazza's son, Chris Conant of Claussen’s Greenhouse and so many others. Our state needs honest leadership, folks, someone who listens, is transparent and fair, with a focus on affordability. In recent weeks, my opponent has decided to focus on negative partisan attacks, rather than what Vermonters really need, and that's economic relief. You may hear some accusations which blur the lines of truth, but I know you're smart and can analyze the facts for yourself, and that said, I look forward to serving you in the future. 

Editor’s note: Brennan’s opponent, Julow, sent out mailers to area residents making note of Brennan’s voting record on certain social issues. 

Julow: Thank you to the Colchester Sun, Milton Independent, LCATV for hosting this event tonight. I'm Andy Julow. I am the senator from Colchester and Grand Isle. I was appointed by Gov. [Phil] Scott to fill the remainder of Senator Mazza's term. I'm a lifelong Vermonter. I've been a husband for 27 years and a father of two daughters. I'm running because Vermont needs experienced leadership capable of working together with multiple parties and tackling the considerable issues we face in the state of Vermont. Today, I'm the executive director of the Lake Champlain Islands Economic Development Corporation and the president of the Regional Development Corporations of Vermont. I served my community for nine years on our school board, eight years as chair. As your senator, I will leverage these experiences to reform our education funding system, to work better for our students, teachers and taxpayers, to address the systematic problems we've seen in our healthcare system around cost for our entrepreneurs and small businesses. As an economic developer, I work with small businesses every day. The challenges have changed since COVID[-19] and our programs have not kept up. So these are the things I'm thinking about as I run towards the Nov. 5 election. 

Viewer-submitted questions 

Q: We have a staffing shortage all over Vermont. It is essential that we find a long term solution. Lack of affordable housing is just one of the factors. How can we address the staffing shortage beyond the housing issue? What other level levers are there? 

Julow: Workforce development is something that I work in, in economic development all the time, and there is not a good connection between our workforce and our education system, particularly in our technical centers. Technical centers do a great job. They are not well funded and they're not well supported. We have a system that somewhat penalizes high schools for sending kids to the technical centers, and we really need those jobs the most. So I would look to boost our technical center support. Automation, I think, is another thing we need to really rely on to boost our workforce and supporting our small businesses with those programs that I was just talking about, to help them grow and help them realize ways they can grow with the current staff that we have, and ways they can grow without needing to drain down additional resources and require more staffing. 

Brennan: I believe in a strong education, and I believe Vermont children are receiving a good education, but they're leaving the state. So in order to keep a good workforce here, we do need housing. We do need Act 250 reform. We have graduates graduating from St. [Michael’s College, [the University of Vermont], our state colleges, and they're fleeing the state. They can't afford to live here. It trickles back to affordability and housing. So I believe if we don't get these, these particular pieces under control. We're not going to have a workforce that is sustainable here in Vermont. 

Q: Which presidential candidate will you be voting for? 

Brennan: You know, [Julow] and I aren't running for President right now. We're running for State Senate in Colchester, for Vermont. I'm concerned about Vermont. I get asked the question all the time, I don't know who I'm voting for. And you know what? I'm concerned about Vermonters right now, folks. We're in a crisis here. We have an affordability problem. We have many more issues the legislature has refused to address over the years, and that's what I'm concerned about. 

Julow: I will proudly be voting for Kamala Harris this November, probably before this November. She's the candidate that stands for democracy. I mean, we saw what happened when Donald Trump was president and he lost and he would not accept it. We can't let that happen again. Kamala Harris stands for democracy and a peaceful transition of power. I used to work in the building in Philadelphia where George Washington walked in as President and walked out a private citizen, handing that over to John Adams. And I would try to make kids understand, adults, even, understand how special that was, in the context of the 18th century, and it was just blasé to them, because that's what we did. And then years later, just a few years later, it all collapsed, that run of peaceful transition of power ended in the United States of America because of Donald Trump. So I will happily be voting for Kamala Harris because of that. I will also vote for her because of her stance on reproductive freedoms. I think the American people, particularly in states, not Vermont, have been subject to something they do not approve of through a Supreme Court ruling, a stacked Supreme Court ruling, that was unfair. And I also think she stands for the right economic policies to grow our economy, get our young people into the workforce and build a better America. So I will happily and proudly be voting for Kamala Harris. 

Host-curated questions 

Q: With school budget systems failing and property taxes increasing around the state, how would you approach education funding reform? Is there a different way to fund Vermont’s education system? 

Julow: Vermonters are clearly hurting over this issue. Taxes are a struggle for a lot of people, and those stories are very moving. I think being the kind of people we are, as as I talk to people at doors, it's really very motivating to know that not only are people struggling over the taxes, they don't want to see our students suffer too, and they know the programs are slipping, they have neighbors who are teachers who are paying for supplies out of their pocket. And it's not just that they're paying a lot, it's that they don't feel they're getting value out of the system, and not enough of that is going to the kids. And that's a real point of frustration for a lot of people as I talk to them. We had some unique challenges this year. We had the COVID money disappear, and we had a new per-pupil weighting formula that came into play this year, but a lot of this has been building up for decades. We've seen a collapse of our health care system that has forced schools to hire, particularly mental health providers. We've gone from 140 to 790 mental health providers employed by our school districts in just the last five years. We've seen a 70% increase in unhoused students over the last five years. These things have significant costs for our education system. So there aren't a lot of easy solutions, unfortunately, but addressing some of these systematic failures that are affecting all of us, like housing, healthcare, our workforce shortage, would grow our tax base and provide some relief. Specifically on the school side, one solution that comes to mind is funding our school infrastructure from a central source. We have had instances and near instances of school buildings that were bonded and then had to close before the bond was even paid for. I mean, these decisions at the local level around our school are very emotional, and they're not always made with rationality. Centralizing those sources would allow us to look at where those schools are located and decide where the wise investments should be made. 

 

Brennan: That's a great question, and it's a really tough answer. Our education system is broken. There's no doubt about that. We all know. One reason why it hasn't been fixed is because it's extremely complicated. I'm not going to sit here and tell you that I understand it, because I believe there are only three or four people in the state of Vermont who do. I'm very confused by it. It needs to be a little bit more predictable. I've never been appointed to the Education Committee, and can't tell you I've worked hands-on on education policy, but I do know this: There are some tough choices that have to be made, some consolidations, some clawbacks of COVID-era funds, we overfunded — well, it wasn't overfunding, it was just heavy funding from COVID-related money that came into the state. And I just believe in my little world of understanding what I do, cost savings, class sizes, 38 studies come to mind that we've done on education funding in the 22 years I've been in the legislature. Number 39 this year, and I'm hoping the legislature can see their way clear to approve that study. I'm sure it's got some brilliant people on it. I'm sure they'll come to us with a proposal that hopefully works and saves or monitors money, and that's what I'm hoping for, and I'm anxious to see the study. In the meantime, we're faced with rising property taxes. They're out of control. It's not going to get a whole lot better this year, and I just wish we would have taken another look at it last session, when the governor did veto that bill, and he had a proposal that would have brought savings down to around 5% property tax rate. It was temporary, but still, it was a good plan, and we chose not to do it. The super majority overruled it, so we'll see what happens next year. 

Q: The state, and indeed the country, is in the midst of a serious drug crisis. What more or differently can be done to ease this crisis in Vermont? Do we start with doctors, drug users, social services? 

Brennan: I think we start with services. Addiction is an epidemic. It's more than a crisis. It's an epidemic. I see it locally. I see it in the Chittenden County area, especially Rutland. I have property in Rutland where I have a lot of contacts down there, it's rampant. There's a number of ways to address it. One with recovery centers. Treatment is key. I don't think we put enough money into that. We should reallocate, reallocate some of the monies that are going to other areas of government and really get a foothold on this. Another thing is, is the crime that's committed by some to allow these people to continue drug use without treatment and with them on the streets, they're not getting any help. We had a couple bills this year that I personally don't think we're going to help with anything. One, one was a safe injection site bill, age 72 that's not the answer. I think we need a facility, more facilities and to get these people the treatment that they need. 

Julow: This is a topic that I did not know much about when I was appointed to the Senate. And then we had this, this bill coming up, and I spent about three weeks doing a deep dive on it, and then they had a recovery forum at the Champlain Valley Fair a couple months back. And I attended that. And all of this was really enlightening and sad at the same time. This is just a sad thing. I think when we go to Burlington, we feel for these people. I mean, it’s just a really tough problem to solve and really deeply affecting these people's people's lives. And I learned about the fourth wave that's coming in, and we're seeing fentanyl being reduced. We're seeing more stimulants. And what I learned from that and that session is that this problem is constantly changing. So this is something the legislature is going to have to revisit constantly. We can't just come up with a solution and think that we've conquered this problem. We're going to have to stay on top of it. The drug dealers are constantly thinking of different ways to mix the different narcotics we have out there, and we need to keep pace with that. And the things you mentioned, we need all of those things. There's prevention, there's recovery, there's treatment, and there's harm reduction, and it's about finding the right balance between those, and that largely depends on the current narcotic that is out there on the street. We have a lot of drug settlement money coming. Prevention is the one that has proven to produce the most return on investment. It takes the longest to play out, but prevention is an area I would like to see us put more into. We've done some harm reduction, we have done needle exchanges, we have done the [Overdose Prevention Center] is going on in Burlington later this year, and treatment and recovery, of course, remain critical parts of that. So it's not a great answer to the question, because the problem is always changing, but those four tiers, prevention, treatment, recovery, harm reduction, we always need to be moving around that balance and finding the right one. 

Q: As the state sees continuous increases in the amount of people experiencing homelessness, what are your thoughts on the need for emergency shelter programs and how might they be paid for? 

Julow: This is a problem, like addiction, requires a multi-tiered solution. In Part, Part of tackling homelessness is to have a viable housing stock, and so continuing to build out our housing stock and moving the margins of people into homes is important so you have less down at the bottom part of the margins, funding our shelters, is another piece of fighting homelessness, and that's something we need to do a better job of. I think we all go down to Burlington and we see how significant this problem really is and needs more resources and treatment and counseling can go hand in hand, and then also providing services for people with disabilities. These are four strategies you can use in different balances to fight homelessness. 

Brennan: There is a definite crisis with homelessness, and it's driven a lot by the drug and opiate epidemic Vermonters face. But we have to wean ourselves, in my opinion, off the hotel, motel program. I mean, when it started, it was great. It was housing everyone. But, there are a fraction of people out there who want to remain homeless, okay? And that's their choice, and they should be able to be left to that. But when it comes to the people with small children, they can't find work, they're starving, they're cold, they're left out in the cold. They need housing. We have to figure out a program, and we have one, but it's just it's been weaning down over the years. The COVID money has kept those programs going. I don't believe we can continue at that pace. We are the number one state in the country and the most attractive state for attracting homeless people, and we treat them, I think, rather nicely. I mean, I don't know what to say to that, other than the fact that we're doing everything we can, we wish we could do more. I'm sure it would cost more money, but at this time, we've got to wean ourselves off this, the hotel-motel program in particular, because it's coming out of everyday taxpayer pockets, and it's not sustainable in the future. 

Q: Do you support increased tax rates for wealthier Vermonters? Why or why not? 

Brennan: For me, no, I don't. And the reason why is because I think every Vermonter pays their fair share. The wealthier people in Vermont can afford it, yes, but I believe they're paying a lot more than I am at this point. And you know, it's not a taxing problem. It's a spending problem. I think if we lived within our means, we wouldn't have to even be thinking or entertaining the idea about going after the wealthier people, the 1% of Vermonters, that are the wealthiest. 

Julow: Our taxing policy should be fair. That's what we believe here in Vermont, and I don't think it is fair. I would support taxing the wealthy. I'm not looking to sting people, but I think we have a system of taxing that is regressive. So I would support taxing people who make above $500,000 a year, which is not a lot of people, a little bit more. And also, when it comes to our property tax funding, taxing second homes at a different rate. Four of the five communities we represent, or I represent in the state senate, have a lower rate of tax for a second home than those who live here year round. And I think we can find ways. I think snowbirds, people who are retired, shuffling back and forth to Florida, that's one thing. But people who are purchasing second and third homes and minimally occupying them, are taking up housing stock that we're not using efficiently. They are not purchasing things and contributing to the [education] fund through sales tax or meals and rooms. And I don't think we should go crazy on that, but I do think we have a right as a state to be made whole for the missed revenue we're getting from second and third homeowners. 

Q: Hospitals and doctor’s offices are busier than ever, and many residents and businesses are struggling to keep up with the rising healthcare costs. How can Vermont make it easier to receive care and pay for it? 

Julow: I'm so glad you asked this one, because this is becoming the number one issue I find at doors. It is cost. This is something that is troubling Vermonters, they feel very insecure about the cost and accessibility of our health care system, and they're worried about it, and it's one of the first things they mention to me, it's the cost. So our silver plan has doubled since 2018, that's part of it, and that's been a problem for a long time, the increasing cost. But more and more, it's becoming accessibility that is shaking people's faith in our healthcare system. We've had mental health and specialists have always taken a long time, and we've been short on those providers for a while, but increasingly it's primary care, it's dental, it's reproductive care. Our hospitals, especially in the rural areas, are unprofitable. We've seen a disturbing trend where a lot of providers who are in short supply and have figured out the insurance system dropped, it has gone to cash, which means there's a smaller and smaller pool for the rest of us to access those providers. I don't come from an area of personal expertise on this. I don't know how to fix our healthcare system, but I think I understand and recognize the problem. I understand it is worrisome to a lot of Vermonters, and I think it's something we need to put a lot of resources and time into bringing in people who can help us solve this. And it's not hopeless. We have states right here in New England who have done a much better job of managing this than us. While our silver plan has doubled since 2018, Massachusetts’ has remained stable. So there are success stories out there. We like our Vermont solutions, but sometimes it's okay to look over the fence and borrow from other states are doing a better job at it than us. 

Brennan: We may actually agree on this topic. We do have a health crisis. We have an affordability crisis in health care. Insurance costs are the driving factor. Primary care physicians, if you lose one, you're not going to find another one for a while, or are lucky to find one in the future. But we also have doctors and nurses leaving the state. My wife's a nurse, and I hear on a daily basis that Dr. So-and-so says he can't afford it here, he's leaving, the restrictions, the regulations are too much, and they're heading to Boston to work. So it's like with students. We have to develop a plan to keep those doctors here. I think we're a little bit over regulated. We have to loosen up the bootstraps a little bit when it comes to regulations for healthcare professionals, and try to keep the ones that are here, in the state. And again, it's a complicated area, not my area of expertise either. I have a go-to guy in education and I have a go-to guy in healthcare. Those two issues are tough issues, so there are people out there who know a lot more than [Julow] and I about that, and we have to rely on them sometimes. 

Closing comments 

Brennan: Thank you. It's clear we need new solutions to our state’s increasing problems. Our legislature is failing the needs of Vermonters. Currently, I'm running to continue serving in Montpelier. As I said earlier, I've served for 22 years, and I'd like to move up to the Senate and try to fill Senator Mazza’s shoes. Tough order. As a legislator and a grandfather, I have a huge concern for Vermont's future. It's my responsibility to pass on a healthy and livable state to the next generation. As a former small business owner, I understand the pressures you face, from owners to workers, going door to door. Vermonters want honest leadership, and what I'm hearing as a number one issue is affordability. People are amazed and just beside themselves when I go door to door,  about property taxes. They want honest leadership and someone who they can trust in the Vermont House, Senate, excuse me, statehouse. I’ve got 22 years in the House, and I'm still talking about it. For years, I've been elected alongside a Democrat in a two seat district, because voters know they can count on me. I hope you know I've got your back too. I'm proud to have the support, once again, of Gov. Phil Scott, Mike Mazza, Dick's son, and Chris Conant and many others, a whole slew of people, and I really appreciate their support, and I hope I can earn your vote, and I'd like you to vote now right up until Nov. 5. 

Julow: So thank you again, LCATV, Colchester Sun, Milton Independent, for hosting this. It's been a pleasure to be here tonight. When you run for office, one of the unpleasant things you have to do is you have to ask for money. You make a lot of calls, and you ask a lot of people for funds, and you put out this link online for people to donate, and if somebody donates more than $100 it goes to the Secretary of State's report. If they donate less than $100 it's anonymous, and only I get to see who made that donation. And it's been really touching to see the donations that have come in that are, I guess, classified as small, because I know these people. They are members of my community. I know the struggles they face, and I know how precious those dollars are they have have donated to me and my campaign, and to think they're taking that and they have faith in me to come up with solutions to the problems they face is something I will carry with me every single time I walk up the steps to the State House. So I'm Andy Julow, I'm a Vermonter, I'm a husband, I'm a father, I'm an economic developer, I was a school board member, and it has been my great honor to serve as your State Senator for Colchester and Grand Isle over these last five months, and I hope that you will support me on or before November 5. Thank you. 

Where to learn more 

Stay tuned on the LCATV website or channel tonight to hear from the candidates running for Vermont House seats on behalf of districts directly representing Colchester residents. More information about schedules and streaming options can be found in our previous reporting. 

Additional coverage and conversations with all state legislative candidates representing Colchester voters directly, and some statewide seats, can be found on our elections page.

#csnltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here