Editor's note: This story has been updated to include the names of those running for Chittenden 20 House seats seat who declined to attend the forum.
COLCHESTER — Lake Champlain Access Television, as part of its 2024 election forum series, hosted the Chittenden 20 House district candidates last night at its office in Colchester.
Moderated by Sun reporter Ella Ruehsen, Doug Bishop (D-Colchester) and Gayle Pezzo (D-Colchester) joined the host and moderator to answer a number of questions, both planned and viewer-submitted.
Also invited were Republican candidates Doug Wood and Joshua Crop who declined to attend the forum. There are two seats available in this district.
The following is a transcript of questions and responses, edited very slightly for clarity.
Bishop: I'd like to say thank you to LCATV and to Colchester Sun and Ella [Ruehsen] specifically. Thank you. I believe the candidates have an obligation to foster an understanding on the issues, and I think forums just like this are a great opportunity for that. So I appreciate this chance. I'm Doug Bishop, and I'm running to be a state representative for Colchester's Chittenden 20 district, where my wife and I have lived for the past 22 years, and where we raised our son. When I graduated from [the University of Vermont], I had the honor to work in Washington, DC on the staff of Sen. [Patrick] Leahy. It was that experience where I got to see someone model what it's like to be a true public servant, and that left an impression on me, and I'm very proud to say that Leahy has endorsed my candidacy. I have a diverse set of experiences that have provided me with perspective and skills that I am confident will serve our community well in the legislature. After working on Capitol Hill, I went to law school before returning to Vermont and then I went into private practice for 12 years and worked hard to support Vermonters and help them when an injustice was done. I also built skills that have continued to help me break down complex issues, identify opportunities and move forward towards solutions, looking to connect more broadly with the community. About 15 years ago, I made a career change and started working in nonprofits. I've been part of the leadership of the Vermont American Red Cross, I've worked at the Greater Burlington YMCA for nine years, and I also helped stand up the Vermont Disaster Relief Fund in the wake of Tropical Storm Irene. I've had significant budget responsibilities in my work. I've always fostered collaboration and gained valuable insights into many of Vermont's vexing problems. And I've worked hard these past few months to connect with the people of Colchester, launching a campaign website and a Facebook page. I've attended virtually every selectboard, school board, planning commission and [development review board] meeting. Most importantly, I've knocked on over 1,000 doors to hear directly from you about the issues that are most important, and as your representative, I'll continue to stay connected and to serve you by being informed and engaged with the people of my district.
Pezzo: I'd like to take the opportunity to thank LCATV and the Colchester Sun for providing this platform to be able to connect with the voters of Colchester. I'm Gayle Pezzo. I'm running for state representative for Chittenden 20 district. The reason I'm running is to help solve some of the tough challenges facing Vermont. I'm a first time candidate working actively to become familiar with policies while canvassing and knocking on close to 1,500 doors. It's been the constituents that have been telling me their priorities and what matters to them. I feel we owe it to the people of Vermont to repair what needs to be fixed before we move on to the legislature. The ability to live comfortably and with dignity, absent of constant worry over tax increases or expenses lurking around the corner, and stressing over how they will manage to pay for and afford to remain in Vermont appears to be what's on the forefront of their minds. My background is in mental health, as a clinical director and counselor working with substance use and addiction. I owned the private practice and family counseling, and after retirement, I owned and operated a small business. Through that work, I sharpened my skills in managing finances, budgeting prudently to achieve success. I recently sat as panelist on the Vermont legislation mobile home task force, and I'm currently a member of the environmental justice advisory council. My priorities are affordable housing, sustainable education funding and healthcare that is accessible within the reach of every Vermonter, as a right and not a luxury. We need to fix what's broken now and for the future. Short-sighted measures are not acceptable, and we can and will do better.
As an avid reader, I'm always interested in what people are currently reading and what they would recommend. What's currently on your nightstand, what is next on the pile, and what has been your best read this year?
Pezzo: What's on my nightstand is [Shel Silverstein’s] ‘The Giving Tree,’ the Bible, and also ‘All I Really Need to Know, I Learned in Kindergarten,’ [by Robert Fulghum]. Gotta get through those again first.
Bishop: I love this question. I would say I've had two things on my nightstand of late. One, my mother’s self-published memoir of some of her experiences and her working life, and so I'm just doing a re-read of that. Also, at the recommendation of someone as I was considering this run, I'm reading the book by Amanda Ripley called ‘High Conflict.’ It's about how we get ourselves into conflict and how we can get ourselves out. And there can be good conflict, good conversation, but it's been very insightful. Next on the reading list is Eric Larson, who has written a number of books of history. They almost read like fiction, but they're not, and he's got one out that I haven't read yet, so I would say that's probably up next.
Since none of you are incumbents, why do you believe that you have the qualifications to be a legislator?
Bishop: I think I've covered some of that in my opening remarks. I've had some diverse work experiences that I think would serve me well. I see a common thread through many of them, of being an advocate, most directly when I was practicing as an attorney, but in my roles at nonprofits, I've always seen myself as working as an advocate for those organizations and the people we serve. I've stressed in my campaign, collaboration and affordability, and collaboration is something I feel strongly about. When I first started practicing law 25 years ago, another attorney in the firm and I got some special training and started with some other folks in Chittenden County, a group called the Collaborative Law Group. That was more focused on family law, which was a small part of my own practice, but we saw a different way for people to resolve issues and to do so collaboratively, and that's kind of stuck with me in the way that I've approached problem solving within organizations I've worked with or when we need to work with folks outside that organization. So I think that collaborative approach and the sense of having a desire to advocate for others, are things that would serve me well, in addition to the work experiences I’ve had.
Pezzo: I think one of my strong suits is that I'm a good listener. I'm trained in listening. In the last couple of years, I've noticed that people feel a little bit marginalized, and the main reason that I wanted to run is because I want to be the voice of those people who feel that their voice isn't heard. I have a strong voice. I'm a good listener. I want to be able to engage them in more civic involvement. And I think just my training, as far as counseling, allows me to be able to not only listen, but to hear what people are saying.
Feelings about safe injection sites?
Editor’s note: In the interest of time, this viewer-submitted question was merged by our moderator with a host-curated question about the drug crisis generally, spoken as follows.
The state, and indeed, the country, is in the midst of a serious drug crisis. What more or differently can be done to ease the crisis in Vermont? Do we start with doctors, drug users, social services?
Pezzo: I believe that any method of harm reduction that saves one life is a valuable resource that needs to be considered. However, the model needs to encourage the addict to be interested in counseling, follow-up and aftercare. Addiction is a disease, categorized as such in the medical diagnostic manual — not a choice or a moral issue. Staving off overdose at the crisis level seems counterproductive to me, by treating the symptom and ignoring the cause. The mental health aspect can't be disregarded. Vermont's current treatment access is sparse and taxpayer money is wasted in part because the disease itself is misunderstood. Funds need to be allocated to mental health and substance use as an investment for prevention, outreach and intervention, before it reaches crisis level. Without these measures, the crisis will increase. The numbers of folks affected will grow and lost lives will become greater. The funds spent on the court system, incarceration for drug and alcohol related offenses, EMTs, police, these emergency department and hospital admissions could be better used toward prevention and identifying the cause of the behaviors, even at an early age. Those who continue to believe that providing these resources is coddling the afflicted person, need to consider that Medicaid and insurance companies would not pay those expenses if it was a simple matter of lack of willpower and poor choices. I look forward to seeing the data regarding the success or failure of this pilot program.
Bishop: Whether we call it a public health emergency or an epidemic, we have a serious drug addiction problem in this country and here in Vermont, and we can't simply will that away. We need to try a variety of approaches and be willing to open ourselves up to something that we may not at first agree with. I understand when people have a hesitation about a safe injection site. I would say, when I first heard that, I had that same impression, but I would be supportive, and am supportive, of what the legislature did this past term, because I believe we need to try new things. We need to see what's going to work and expand when we find things that do work. If this doesn't work, we don't keep funding it. It's that simple. But we need to try. I think we need, as [Pezzo] said, to be focusing on prevention and treatment. And recently, I was reading through some materials that our Rep. for Chittenden 19, [Sarita] Austin, shared with me. It was a letter to Gov. [Phil] Scott from federal judges, from state judges, those involved in human service organizations like Spectrum. And it really highlighted something important, and that's a gap in our longer term residential program, or step down programs, for those afflicted by drug addiction. We have short term programs of two to three weeks that barely address the withdrawal issue, and then people are back on the streets, back with some of the same people that they're with. They're not in a different environment, not in a different headspace, and they get back again into the problems of addiction. We need to work harder eradicating the problem. That may cost money, but our alternative is the prison system, where we spend $95,000 a year in Vermont to house a prisoner — that is not money well spent. It's not addressing the problem. I think we also need to look at more of a comprehensive and enhanced case management system, where we can help people resolve some of the other issues going on in their life, beyond addiction, help them find housing, help them find a job, help them get a driver's license, if they no longer have that. So there's more we can do for prevention and treatment that I think would be well-spent money.
What do you see as some of the state's biggest challenges in the coming years, and what resources and strengths do the Vermont citizenry, and you as a representative of that citizenry, possess to tackle those challenges?
Bishop: So I have 20 minutes to answer this question? There is a lot going on here... I think we're going to get to some of these, probably with other questions, but I'm going to spend some time talking about what I'm hearing most on doorsteps, and that's about our property taxes. We cannot have double-digit increases, that's not sustainable and it's not fair to the taxpayers. We have an education funding system that's broken, and part of the problem is it’s simply too complicated. People in Montpelier will be the first to admit there are very few people there that fully understand that system. The more I dive into it, I hear about issues of equalized pupils, CLA, or common level of appraisal. And I'm concerned that in response to the Brigham decision, which very rightfully said, we need to provide equal opportunity for Vermont students, in those 25 years since, we've cobbled together Act 60, Act 68, Act 127, and other efforts to try to fix it. And it's become so complicated, that's where we get surprised with double digit increases. So I think we need to look, have we gotten some of these elements right, the equalized pupil and the CLA? Or have we tipped the balance so far that individual towns and their schools have become disconnected with what the property taxes are going to be for their own residents? We need to refocus that. I think we need to look at school consolidation and schools within districts and school districts themselves. That's not a popular conversation, but we have to have tough conversations, because these are serious problems. I think addressing the cost of mental health that's currently being borne by our education fund and handled in schools, there may still need to be work done in schools, related to mental health, but its funding should not come on the backs of taxpayers and property taxes, but more broadly, through our general fund. And I think we need to tackle the issue of the expensive renovations and rehabilitations of schools that are being undertaken across the street. There's a study taking place now on how we can support funding for construction costs, and I'm very interested in what those findings will be.
Pezzo: It appears there's no easy solution to this problem. There are Vermont constitutional concerns, as well as strong belief in local control of education versus possible efficiencies of statewide control. Statewide control would more likely save taxpayer money. But are we willing to give up the local control of budgets and policies? The facts are that when each school district passes its yearly budget and is provided to the legislature, the money has to come from somewhere. Many circumstances led to the double digit tax increases. Needs of our kiddos have changed, and access to mental health and emotional support needs to be addressed while they are being educated. COVID[-19] funds ended. Employee health insurance increased. Inflation, school construction and maintenance expenses were the contributors to the tax increases. That's all that I hear when I knock on doors, is the concern about taxes and the schools and funding. The current school funding system needs to be reorganized. It's not sustainable. The formula that was created in the past does not meet the needs and current demands of our students, staff and educators today. Possible solutions? Revisit the school meals, mental health and health care costs, and move them out of the Education Fund. Develop a dedicated income stream for school construction, merging schools where it is deemed practical, and revise the funding formula to meet the needs of today. Education property tax rates are currently set for two grand list categories, homestead and non-homestead. The non-homestead category is too broad. We should expand the number of categories to provide more tax flexibility and fairness. Vermonters believe every child should have access to an excellent education, no matter their ability or their zip code. Solutions to provide that excellent education without causing taxes to rise by double digits must be our goal.
What are some ways in which you'd advocate for making housing more plentiful and affordable, and what should be done, if anything, to help first time homebuyers enter the real estate market?
Pezzo: we're all aware that there’s a housing crisis in Vermont. Act 250 reform will certainly aid in helping make it more attractive for developers to build. However, there needs to be consideration, and the list is lengthy — where to build, maintaining the role of duty to that area in supporting environmental standards and conditions, public transportation, availability, infrastructure, access or development, optimum utilization of the building, space, affordability, distance between schools and employment, rents or purchase prices in line with work opportunities in that area, resources, availability — all are items that need to be considered. Resources are not always measured in dollars. As an example, applying for grants to purchase a fire truck that can access the top floor of a four story building or a town altering its current zoning regulations are valuable resources that widen the planning opportunities. All factors need to be scrutinized and perceptive. Understanding and insight need to be of great importance. Without additional affordable housing, we will not see economic growth. These are all huge issues to address, and to get it right, we need to take small steps to move forward that result in positive and permanent outcomes that are achievable to meet our goals. I believe that Act 250 reform is one of those small steps.
Bishop: Well, a lack of housing is crippling for individual Vermonters, and it's damaging our economy. That's clear, and we need to — and I am personally committed to helping us — turn the corner on that. As I knock on doors and I listen to business leaders, this is the first or second issue I'm hearing. I was at a Chamber of Commerce breakfast in the spring, where state legislators and the governor spoke. But before the morning got started, we heard from the co-founder of OnLogic [Industrial Computers], the host of that event in their new building. The number one issue, she said, that keeps her up at night, is not her competition, and it was not the supply chain. It was a lack of adequate housing for her workforce. And we're also woefully under building for what we need, and we need to make changes to do that. It was recently recommended by the Vermont Housing Finance Agency that we build out in the neighborhood 5,000-7,000 homes a year over the next five years, but we're currently building only about 2,200 2,300 homes. So this past legislative session, I think the legislature made strong and important first steps in reform of Act 250. The Governor vetoed that because it didn't go far enough. I don't think each piece of legislation has to be the end all and be all. It can be a beginning. We can watch how this unfolds. We can continue to modify and make changes to Act 250, modernizing it, because it's in need of that. It was created 50 years ago, and it's time for some modernization. First steps have been taken. We need to do more. I think also, for first time home buyers, is there an opportunity to kill two birds with one stone? We're having workforce problems, such as in the areas of healthcare. Can we incentivize bringing in nurses and other healthcare workers or other fields that we identify are a priority, and give those folks the support as first time homebuyers? Young nursing students from our own program at UVM, keeping them in the area, perhaps with some incentives for first time buyers. I like the creativity of our treasurer, Mike Pieciak, using some of the 10% in Vermont funds with the Vermont Housing Finance Agency. Those are funds that, because we're on a strong financial footing and we have cash on hand, we could invest in building out more housing. We need more creative solutions, such as that one.
Bishop: I'd like to thank LCATV and the Colchester Sun for offering this forum. Colchester voters have had an opportunity to gain information and insights that will help them make an informed decision in this November's election. Some of you are already voting. Simply put, I'm passionate about Vermont. I've seen that for far too many fellow Vermonters, their life is more challenging than it has to be, and harder than it needs to be. I think working together through collaboration with an eye on affordability, we can work across the political divide within the legislature. We can work across any divides that exist between the legislature and the executive branch and move towards solutions that are practical and affordable. I think we all recognize these problems are complex, and there are no easy answers, or I would have shared them long ago with the legislature if I had those golden answers. But throughout my professional career, I've worked in environments that have presented unique and challenging problems, and each time, I bring past experiences to bear and try to work towards solutions, and I'll do the same in Montpelier. I hope you see that the work that both [Pezzo] and I have done to date is preparing us already for a role in the legislature. There's no time to waste. So as we're running for office, I think we're both also hoping that we're preparing for the job that's ahead of us. I think far too many people run with the idea that ‘no’ is a platform, ‘no’ is not a solution. And I'm open to new ideas. I'll bring fresh perspectives, and I think we can have ‘yes’ as an answer towards our problems. So whether it was supporting the work of Sen. Leahy, representing individual Vermonters as an attorney, or helping to lead some of our cornerstone nonprofit institutions, I'm drawn to public service and building stronger communities. I see a role in the state legislature as an extension of that past work, and I hope that the people in the Chittenden 20 district will give me their support and [Pezzo’s] support and vote us both in to this upcoming legislative session.
Pezzo: As a Vermonter, affected by every decision that is made at state level, it's important to further mention the topic of affordable housing. After one year of moving to Colchester to the Westbury Park neighborhood, the mobile home park was put up for sale. Due to the forward thinking of Vermont legislation, a law was in place that provided the current homeowners the first opportunity to purchase the mobile home park, which staved off developers. The residents created an owner-occupied, affordable housing community, where 250 families were saved from eviction. I became involved with the residents’ ROC advisors and lenders to transfer ownership of the park to a nonprofit, resident-owned cooperative. I continued to work with the nonprofit cooperative, initially as a treasurer and currently as the board president. There were still some gaps that needed to be filled to provide municipal opportunities for those families, so I formed a coalition and organized a team of Colchester residents, both living in Westbury and in other parts of town. We built a network of legal, municipal and business advisors from around the state, who generously volunteered their time and expertise in September of 2023. Meeting all requirements of another piece of legislation, the residents of Westbury created the first village to be incorporated in Vermont in 90 years. What is amazing to me is what can be accomplished when people with many perspectives collaborate, cooperate and come together to solve a common problem. I believe this is what our representatives are responsible for doing, and I'm up for the task. I'm Gayle Pezzo. I'm running for state representative for Chittenden 20 district. I'm a mother, grandmother, former business owner, healthcare professional and a proud resident of Colchester, Vt. It's an honor to be on the ballot. I'd appreciate your vote on or before Nov. 5.
A transcript will be made available on the Sun site on Monday, for the Chittenden 19 House district candidate forum, also hosted the night of Oct. 10 by the Sun and LCATV.
Recordings of all forums are or will soon become available on the LCATV website.
Read our Grand Isle Senate candidate forum transcript here.
Additional coverage and conversations with all state legislative candidates representing Colchester voters directly, and some statewide seats, can be found on our elections page.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here