COLCHESTER — Lake Champlain Access Television, as part of its 2024 election forum series, hosted the Chittenden 19 House district candidates Thursday night at its office in Colchester.
Moderated by Sun reporter Ella Ruehsen, candidates Sarita Austin (Democrat, incumbent), Wendy Critchlow (Democrat), Leland Gazo (Republican) and Spencer Sherman (Libertarian-Republican) joined the host and moderator to answer a number of questions.
There are two seats available in this district, to be selected Nov. 5 by voters.
The following is a transcript of questions and responses, edited very slightly for clarity.
Austin: I'd like to thank LCATV for this opportunity, and to thank my running mate, Critchlow, and candidate Gazo, for participating in this forum. As the only incumbent in Colchester running for reelection to the House of Representatives, I would like to explain why I am choosing to run again in a new legislature. I gained essential insight into how proposed bills were chosen to be taken up, how important it was to listen and ask questions of testimonies we were listening to, to read reports by experts on the costs and benefits of the bill we were debating, and finally, to listen to the explanations of my fellow committee members on their rationale for their vote. I do not have enough time to describe the multitude of procedures, protocols, rules, regulations and laws that make it possible for senators, representatives, lawyers, advocates and opponents, heads of agencies the governor and members of his Cabinet and the public to participate in a safe, orderly, respectful and collaborative process that hopefully results in legislation passing and laws created. We are a citizen legislature. We come from all walks of life, whose responsibility it is to bring the voices of our community to Montpelier. It is a brilliant vision by design, and one that, since its inception, continues to evolve and adapt while still staying true to the values and vision of our Constitution. I am running for another session because I believe we are at a critical crossroads. Vermont is growing older. According to a Pew study, Vermont's population [is growing] slower than 45 other states’ from 2020-2040. West Virginia, Vermont and Illinois are expected to shrink the most. I consider myself a pragmatic progressive, and I believe we need to prioritize legislation that assures a quality of life that works for all Vermonters given our evolving demographics and shifting fiscal outlook.
Critchlow: Good evening, and thanks for having us here today and giving us the opportunity to introduce myself to the voters. My name is Wendy Crichlow, and I've proudly called Colchester my home for 37 years, and I love this town, and believe it's a great place to raise a family and enjoy the beauty and the activities that make our community unique. I've always been focused on national elections, having volunteered for presidential campaigns since I was old enough to vote, but over the last 10 years, I have become increasingly aware that politics are all truly local. For that reason, I have become more involved in reconnecting with the Colchester Democratic Party and for following the town even more closely. Colchester is very lucky to have such dedicated people serving on our boards, and residents who take an interest in what they are doing. I have been a poll worker volunteer since 2016. It has been my honor to work with the town officials who are both ethical and meticulous in ensuring an accurate election outcome. I, too, see how hard they work. I have been elected justice of the peace and serve on the civil board authority, recently becoming their secretary. I serve on the planning commission, and I have come to really appreciate this role. The people who serve are dedicated residents whose sights are always focused on growth while maintaining the character and beauty of our town. I'm employed by the state of Vermont as the Medicaid auditor, and I am a proud union member and steward. I was previously employed as a nurse and an elder care case manager. I'm also a taxpayer, and I deeply feel the need to contain the rising cost of living and working here. While I see no easy answers, I believe that we need to grow our tax base by supplying good, affordable housing and rethinking zoning and reforming Act 250. I don't really think [reforms] went far enough in the first round. I'm also acutely aware that our school budgets are what increased our property taxes. It is also apparent to me that the increase to health care insurance is the major factor in this increased budget. As someone who has worked in healthcare in different capacities, I know this is unsustainable. Healthcare coverage should not break the bank for communities or for consumers.
Gazo: First of all, I wanted to thank public access for putting this on, [Ruehsen] for moderating and asking the questions, and obviously for my opponents, and my running mate [Sherman], for coming out tonight. For those of you that don't know, my name is Leland Gazo. As many of you know, I'm a Malletts Bay, born and raised, gentleman, I’ve been here my whole life. I aim to represent the district I was raised in. It's something that I'm passionate about. I'm a seventh generation Vermonter. My family has a long lineage of dairy farming, home building, and really hard work in our lifespan. Something that I look to bring to Montpelier is that artisan craft, that ability to work under pressure, and honestly, that ability to care for your neighbor, as my family has done for seven generations in Vermont. Currently, I'm a business owner. I own a roofing company here in Vermont with my father. It's a family-owned and operated business for 22 years. At the business, I wear many hats. Sometimes I'm on the roof. Sometimes I'm a project manager. Oftentimes I'm tasked with doing the numbers, running the budget and understanding what our clients need. When I do the budget, I look for areas where we can be more fiscally responsible, where we can save money to keep our business going for a longer time, even through tough periods. That is what I'm looking to bring to Montpelier, business acumen, common sense and peace of mind that Vermonters will know that they can stay here for not the past seven generations, but for the next seven generations. My platform is simple. I've listened to Vermonters. I've worked on the doorsteps, and I've heard the three issues that are most apparent and most impactful to every Vermonter, every Colchester resident's life right now, comes down to three things: affordability, property tax and law and order. I’m sure we'll get through some of those policy issues tonight, but I'm looking forward to the opportunity to speak more.
Sherman: Wow. Hi. I am Spencer Sherman, and I'm running for representative in Chittenden 19. Apparently, I came with less notes than everybody else. I was also late. So I will lead with this. What do Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln and Spencer Sherman have in common? They were often late. I agree with [Gazo]. When I meet people in the street, what I hear most is affordability, affordability, affordability, and the closer our border gets with Burlington, I hear concerns about public safety, and as I talk to folks, I'm really concerned that most of the folks in the legislature didn't do what I did when I first got here 29 years ago, which was I sat and watched for 10 years how Vermont politics worked. I sat and listened to Dick Maza, to moderates, and I watched this drift go farther and farther left in our political spectrum, and I don't believe that represents the vast majority of the people in Chittenden 19. So I'm here to try to turn that around. I'm here to try to bring common sense back to the legislature, where people can reach across the aisle, work together and try to come up with compromises, rather than forcing things through a veto session.
While other forums saw questions from outside viewers, and all forums were advertised to field questions from the audience, this particular forum did not garner any submissions.
Looking at Vermont’s future financial picture, what are your ideas on how to balance budgets, manage taxes and fees, maintaining or cutting services and alternative funding streams for the state? Can you identify any particular areas of the budget that you might trim down if given the opportunity?
Sherman: Thank you for that question, that’s a great question. When we talk about fiscal conservancy, I believe that's where we're going with this type of questioning. When we talk to constituents and they're all concerned about curtailing costs and limiting tax increases, once again, the question is how to do it. I personally believe our education formula is broken. I think it's too complex. I think we need to apply the KISS principle, for example. I think that there was a really good idea that came up a couple of legislative sessions ago, where there was a suggestion of removing the education burden from the property tax and applying it to a one to a one and a half percent flat tax on consumption for the state. And I thought that was a brilliant idea. I thought it was something that should be explored. And yet the supermajority didn't let it get out of committee. It stayed on the wall. It was effectively laughed at because it was an alternative that didn't include the algorithm that is so broken.
Editor’s note: “KISS” is an acronym for the design principle, “Keep It Simple, Stupid!” The concept was reportedly coined in 1960 by an engineer for the American war missile and military aircraft manufacturing company Lockheed Martin.
Gazo: I think the issue of budget maintenance and understanding where we are fiscally, does not only involve cuts. Oftentimes, I think when Colchester residents think of Republicans, they think of, ‘Oh, my Lord, Republicans are going to cut everything in sight. We're going to have no funding for our absolutely necessary services.’ For me, it's about finding waste within the budget, monitoring that waste, and making really calculated decisions to reduce that waste, to reduce bureaucracy and to make changes in those areas. In Vermont, we have so much bureaucracy that overlaps in different sectors. We need to address that overlap, address that bureaucracy, reduce the cost, and pass that savings on to Vermont taxpayers.
Critchlow: I have been looking at the budget, and if you do, it's like an exorbitant amount that goes into the school budget. And from what I understand, we have passed a balanced budget every time — we're not taking money out of reserves, we're trying to pass a good budget. I think education takes a majority of it. There has to be some sort of reform that we do for funding our schools and on that. There's also the health care cost. I mean, the insurance premiums for the teachers this year went up 18%. That is crazy. I work for the state. I just know we did a raise, which has evaporated this year through health care premiums. There's got to be a better way to fund these things, and I think that's where we need to focus, is on figuring out a way to revamp our funding at the school systems.
Austin: So as you stated, the funding formula, the way we fund education in Vermont, is an extremely complex system, and it basically started with the Brigham decision. When the Brigham decision came down from the Vermont Supreme Court, it used to be that towns — I was living in Willison at the time, and the reason my husband and I chose Willison is because of the commercial development that was going on, and that commercial development and the taxes they paid kept our taxes very low. But the Brigham decision, what it said to Vermonters was, all children have to have equal access to educational opportunities. And so, what occurred as a result of that decision, and what you have seen, I think, over the years, is an attempt to absolutely ensure that all children in Vermont have equal access opportunities. But we pay, we now pay into a state fund, which is driven by local control, local school boards and then voter approved budgets. So, what happened this year was, due to health insurance, due to the schools — I feel — taking on more than their capacity in terms of their role as education and advancing learning, taking on more social services such as mental health and other issues, and also it was one other thing that I think was a driving force for increasing the cost of education, housing also was increasing the cost of education as well. I did meet with the chamber this week, and they are coming up with some very innovative and viable solutions to changing the funding system and still staying within the parameters of the Brigham decision. So I think we all want to have a quality education for our children, and I think we all want to do it in an affordable and sustainable way.
With school budgets failing and property taxes increasing around the state, how would you approach education funding reform? Is there a different way to fund Vermont’s education system?
Austin: So when we look at what's been happening over the last 20 years, school enrollment has dropped substantially, while school costs have increased exponentially, like 80%. We now have, I believe it's around 75,000-80,000 students and a large budget to educate them. What I think, and what the chamber thinks, and what other people that I've been talking to think, is that we have to look at the property tax credit. We have to look at another way of supporting people whose income is impacted substantially by the tax increase. We have to find another way to help support them, you know, to pay their taxes, we have to, I think, return to where you could take or transfer funds from the general fund to the education fund, because again, the mental health cost us $50 million this year, and I had a lot of questions about, is that the responsibility of the school? In terms of what we look at, the mission of education — is treating students with mental health issues, not that they shouldn't be treated, but whose responsibility is it to deliver that service? I also think we have to look at consolidation. I think we need a commission on consolidation. You know, I think we need to really look at the cost benefit of having two very small schools next to each other, K-8 with 120 students in it. And I know, even in Colchester, I know people love their neighborhood schools, I know they love Porter's Point and Union School, but it is expensive.
Critchlow: I’m going to piggyback off that, but I think that there has to be some sort of talk about consolidation, and no one wants to talk about that, but it's vital. And the other thing that I've been doing a lot of is reading the last few days, and we should look at other states. Other states are actually coming up with some innovative ideas on how to fund schools. We can share resources. There can be mental health and nurses that are not specific to each and every school. My understanding is that some of the schools up in the Northeast Kingdom can't even find paraeducators right now because we don't pay them well enough, but perhaps if we consolidated, we could do a better job at serving our kids.
Gazo: Yeah, so the last question was about the budget. More broadly, with this question being about education specifically. What I would like to see is our education finance system completely redesigned. Right now, we have an education finance system designed to pull the most amount of taxpayer dollars with the least amount of accountability. What that does is it distances our students from the money. It increases bureaucracy within the education finance system, and it keeps the money from the teachers, from the students, from the pens and pencils where it really needs to be. My perspective on the education finance system is that if we tie our money tighter to the district it's coming from, we will be better off as educators, better off as students — and right now, our students, in truth, they aren't at the top of the country in their ratings for their test scores, but we are at the top of the country in our spending per pupil. Something in that situation has to change, and I think the only way we can accomplish that, looking at the education finance system, is completely reforming it. We have 54 student advisory unions in the state. States like Florida, states like Tennessee, have half to a quarter of the amount that we have. Somehow their bureaucracy is half of ours, a quarter of ours. Their test scores are better than ours, but yet, we are spending 10 times the amount of money per student that those states are spending. Reform the education finance system, reduce bureaucracy. Get back to funding our teachers. Get back to funding our students, and as I said, get back to funding the pens and pencils that get our students education that they so deserve to be contributing members of the society in the future.
Sherman: Well, first, let me say I agree with [Austin] in the fact that I think the schools are trying to take on too many responsibilities that aren't about educating our children. I agree with [Gazo] that the bureaucracy around our school funding is ridiculously bloated. Personally, I'm a fan of school choice. I think the tax dollars should follow the student, and you will see rather quickly, probably within a decade, what are the better schools and what are the worst schools? And then you could lead that to the consolidation that some in Montpelier wish to do. Again, I'm a big fan of the KISS principle on this. I think we have way too much convolution in the current algorithm for school funding. Like [Gazo], I think it should be thrown out and we should start over. I'm a big fan, as I said before, about a flat tax on consumption, and that would fund the school system and take it off the weight of the property owners, and I'll leave it there.
What are some ways in which you’d advocate for making housing more plentiful and affordable, and what should be done, if anything, to help first-time homebuyers enter the real estate market?
Critchlow: Great question. I do work on the planning commission, and there's been some changes that have been made as far as easements that we can now on a single family drawing do duplexes, and there's more that we can do there too. But I think Act 250, like I said earlier, does not go far enough. It's really hard to build a house around here, and that's what we need, is more houses. More housing brings down the cost, and right now they are so inflated. I'm just in awe of how much it costs to buy a house in Vermont right now, and I don't know how young people can do it. I do think that giving them an incentive would be the right thing to do, to get them into a house and help them sustain it, because we need people, and I think if we build more houses, it will drive down the cost.
Gazo: Yeah, absolutely so as a home builder, someone in the construction industry, I understand how challenging Act 250 is to adequately develop homes that are sensible, not only for the environment, but also for our growing economy. What I would like to see is several different things, primarily with Act 250, we need to really have a strong reform against the act. It was designed in the 1970s at a time where Vermont was growing, we were trying to reduce that growth to protect our natural environments. Now our environment is fine, and quite frankly, our development has to catch up. It's something that I think we can do. We took steps towards it this past legislative session. However, it didn't go far enough, in my opinion, on the side of first-time homebuyers. I am a homeowner, and one thing that is difficult in that buying process, is the property transfer tax. I would like to see that reduced to zero for other new homebuyers and homeowners. Right now, I think there's a program going on in the state where you can get funding to develop an accessory dwelling unit in your home, you can get up to, I believe, $50,000 to build an accessory dwelling unit on your current property. That rent that you would be funding, funding that dwelling from would be capped. I would like to see that not capped. I think that home ownership and accessory dwellings are all great. I think the more units that we can build, the better. And I think as a builder, it's something that I'm well equipped to talk about in the legislature and in Montpelier.
Sherman: Housing. We definitely do more of it. There's no question, and it's not, at the moment, affordable. There was a housing bill that went through the legislature this year, H. 687, I believe [Austin] voted for. I will refer you back to the governor's veto in his letter about it, there were some real problems with the bill, among others, the modified road rule expanded Act 250 and effectively would have made it more difficult to actually produce that housing. He wanted an extended timeline, because the legislature was kind of pushing an implementation process that he believed was too fast, and I agree with him. He wanted to extend the interim exemption, which I believe made sense. So what we have, really, is that both sides of the aisle want to solve this problem, but I believe they have different ways of doing it, and I believe the democratic supermajority keeps pushing up the costs. And I think the average Vermonter doesn't want the costs accelerated.
Austin: Well, I just want to say that I do disagree with [Sherman] and [Gazo]. H. 687 has been the only bill for me that I was not hesitant to vote yes for because this bill was worked on for I think over two years if not more, with builders, contractors, environmentalists, advocates, home advocates, municipality advocates and everybody came to a compromise on this bill, and when that happens, what it means to me is when this bill is being implemented — and it's being implemented now — we're not going to have legal battles that are going to cost hold up the development of housing and cost the state a lot of money in legal pangling. So what H. 687 did was it spent $80 million on building houses. We need housing. We can't have people move here. I think all of us have heard business owners and employers talk about how they had found people, had found employees to come here, but there wasn't housing, let alone Vermonters, who live in a starter home and want to move now up to a middle level home. So the property transfer tax is the mechanism for the funding, and that has raised $13 million to contribute to this. The Vermont housing improvement program that we've spent $6 million out of the general fund to build houses with that healthy homes. We've also looked at the Housing Finance Agency.
Hospitals and doctors offices are busier than ever, and many residents and businesses are struggling to keep up with rising healthcare costs. How can Vermont make it easier to receive care and to pay for it?
Gazo: So in Vermont, with our healthcare system, there are multiple different reasons why our healthcare costs are rising. I think number one, we have a housing housing shortage for our nurses, for our doctors that are qualified, that want to move here, that want to work here, but as soon as they get that contract, they start looking for homes, realizing how expensive it is to live here, which is why we need to reform Act 250. On the insurance side of the healthcare industry, we essentially have a duopoly. We have MVP and Blue Cross, Blue Shield. We do not have a competitive market space in the insurance provider industry for healthcare to adequately serve Vermonters, we need to make it more acceptable and provide the capacity for insurance providers to come and compete in Vermont in the marketplace to drive down our insurance premiums. There was another piece of legislation passed this year, Act 111. At face value, I think it's a good piece of legislation. It allows doctors to avoid negotiation with insurance providers before providing you with the next step in your service. On the other side of that, because insurance providers are no longer able to negotiate with the doctors on the care provided for their patients, they have to increase their rates this year up to 20% to cover the cost that they lost in the negotiation process, something that I would have been a little bit more careful in passing, not saying that I would like to seen a study on it, but something I really would have taken a long look before voting for. On another note, one in three Vermonters are above the age of 65. Our healthcare is going to become expensive to fund in the state of Vermont over the next few years. We have to really pay attention to this.
Sherman: Healthcare. All right, for those of you who don't know, I'm a chiropractor. I've been a practicing chiropractor here in the area for 27 years. I do take insurance. I have taken a number of different insurances, and I can tell you, the insurance industry does not promote health. I think the best way to move forward with this is to promote the idea that we can grow out of chronic care, because chronic care is one of the most expensive burdens to our healthcare system there is, and I didn't see anybody giving out vitamin D when it came to COVID[-19]. So I have concerns that the direction of healthcare, as focused as it is on the crisis care, which we need in the hospitals, it is not focused on wellness care, and I believe that's the direction that the legislature should focus to improve what I'm going to call the root causes of the cost of healthcare.
Austin: As we know, the health care this year, that was a negotiated settlement, increased 18% and when beehive came into the education committee to talk about why that had increased so much, it was because of very complex and very sick patients who whose procedures were expensive and their pharmaceuticals were very expensive. So I think one thing hopefully at the federal level, I know we've done it a little bit here, is to deal with the extreme cost of pharmaceuticals. Those have to come down. I think the legislature did play out their role by establishing the Green Mountain Care Board, and just we saw how the Green Mountain Care Board denied the [University of Vermont] Medical Center, you know, they lowered the increase for the appropriation, and as a result — and again, I don't know enough to make an informed decision on this, so I'm not, I'm not coming down on either side — but it then UVM said, ‘Well, we can't build our surgical center, because Green Mountain Care has cut the revenues for us.’ Well, we have a surgical center in Colchester, and when they were trying to get established in Colchester, they met a lot of pushback from other medical organizations, especially in Chittenden County, and I feel that what we need is more specialized places like the surgical center, like Copley for knee and hip replacement, to kind of specialize and to have UVM take on more of the general care of the population.
Critchlow: As somebody who is in the healthcare industry, and I actually started with the state of Vermont in 2013 at the onset of the Affordable Care Act being implemented, and I can tell you, it was a very difficult time. But as far as getting other insurance companies to come into Vermont, they never will. And the reason is because the competition, even between Blue Cross, Blue Shield and MVP, is so [extreme] nobody else is going to come in. There's just not enough people in the state to bring in other insurance companies, so it is a difficult time if you're looking to get some kind of competition there. UVM just started with MVP to do the Part C, Medicare, and from what I understand, we have United Healthcare leaving. We have a lot of others that do long term care that are leaving the state of Vermont because you can't, you can't compete. It's just, there's not enough people to make it worthy, worthy of them to do that. So we've got to find some other way to do it, and I agree that there has to be alternatives to just going to UVM Medical Center to have all your procedures done and fighting with insurance companies. I think the cost of medication is crazy, and we just have to look at those kinds of costs.
Do you support increased taxes for wealthier Vermonters? Why or why not?
Sherman: I think we do a good job here in Vermont stratifying our tax base. I don't think we need to change a whole lot. If you look at the amount that wealthy Vermonters pay, it is the bulk of the taxes. And although I don't have those numbers off the top of my head, I can tell you that wealthy Vermonters pay more than you think. And if you're making under $100,000 a year, you're paying less than most. And I think that's a good way to stratify our tax system. But if you look at the bill, for example, H. 887 which sort of tried to balance out the homestead and non-homestead taxes this year, that came in the wake of last year's 8% property tax increase — 8% was huge, last year. This year was 20%. I mean, these are unsustainable, and you can't just pretend, ‘Oh, we'll make the rich pay more and the problem will go away.’ That's not how you get problems to go away. I mean, when you look at the cost of inflation, which is what is actually fueling the middle and lower income folks' income problems, because if you look at what inflation does to the average household, it is a tax on the middle and lower class. And when you compare that to just saying, ‘Oh, we'll tax the rich more,’ I don't think that's the solution. I mean, I see fees going up. I see taxes going up. I see an extra new payroll tax. I see the fuel costs increasing, if, God forbid this clean heat standard passes, and I just don't think it's fair to say, ‘Let the rich pay for it.’
Austin: I look at Vermont, the tax system. I look at the five different columns of taxpayers in Vermont. I mean, there's a standard five columns of taxpayers in terms of when they look at income, like $25,000, $50,000 not exactly sure about the numbers, but I feel that Vermont and the legislature work very hard to make to create fair taxing policies, so that the wealthy do pay more taxes, and the and people who are income-challenged pay less taxes, percent-wise. So it's like 20, 40, 60, 80, you know, those are the columns. But then it breaks down into like five, five and 10 for the last 20% in terms of wealth. And so it was Vermont. Like the last one was maybe, I don't know if 5% of Vermont taxpayers earned over $550,000 a year. And then the next column down was maybe $300,000 to $500,000 and then the next column over in this kind of one column, that would be 20%, it had three different columns for kind of the most wealthy Vermonters, and what they pay. And what those columns showed was that the two top earners in those columns could be paying a bit more, to make it fair across the five columns, that they could — and still be a fair tax system. So I would be in favor of that, and that was done by Public Assets. So I really look at their studies and their reports a lot, they do a lot of reporting on wealth and cost savings.
Critchlow: I’ll need to study up on the columns, I wasn’t quite sure how that worked. I don't know that there's therapy with taxing. I know I pay a lot of taxes, and I'm sure everybody here does too. I think that's an easy answer for our fiscal problems is to say, to tax the rich, because I think they're already pretty much taxed. I don't know, I'm not one of them, but I would have to look at that. But I just don't — I think that just sounds like too easy of an answer for what we're going through right now.
Gazo: I think my answer is pretty easy for this. It's no. As I've gone door to door in Colchester, I've spoken with wealthy Vermonters, and what they have told me at least three or four times is that they have already purchased a second home in Florida. If the wealth tax is passed, they will move their primary residence to Florida. They will stay there six months and a day, and then they will come back to their home in Vermont. We will lose a massive amount of our tax base if we impose a higher tax percentage on our wealthiest individuals in Vermont. It's not something that makes sense for the state. It's not something that helps us, especially when Montpelier has the rampant spending habits that they do. Vermonters by and large, we’re sick of getting taxed. Whether you're wealthy, whether you're middle class, whether you're just downright poor, we're tired of the taxing. We're tired of spending in Montpelier, and the wealth tax will not solve the issues that we've created for ourselves in Montpelier with the progressive supermajority.
The last two years have seen devastating flooding in Vermont, especially in the state’s central region. What should be done to prepare for future flooding events?
Austin: That's a really good question. I was looking again at those numbers. I think Vermont has spent close to $1 billion in either anticipated spending or in the current day and the past three flooding seasons that we've had. I am on the flood caucus. So it's a group mainly in rural Vermont, mainly Barre, Montpelier, St. Johnsburry, who are getting together to answer that question of what can they do? They're definitely working with the Federal Emergency Management Agency. I don't think any viable solutions have come of it. I mean, there's a lot of ideas being thrown out there about what’s to be done? I think it's Brandon, where during the last flood about three years ago, they installed much bigger culverts under their bridges, and that action prevented flooding in their towns this season. I mean, there's a recommendation from someone on flooding caucus to try to upgrade roads… so that they can get the benefit of having their roads maintained, and culverts added, crushed stone added. I mean, those are some of the simpler solutions. I think people are working on it. I think there are some solutions. I was reading the other day, in New York City, they're putting in roads that are permeable, you know, so water goes down through them.
Critchlow: After the last couple of weeks, if we don't think that climate change is real, then we're sadly mistaken. I think there's a lot of things that we can do to try to help mitigate it. We should not be having these floods in Vermont the way we are. It's devastating. It seems to happen in the same towns over and over again. I agree that we need to have some sort of infrastructure there. We need to have people who know, engineers that know, how to fix this problem, because just rebuilding and starting all over again and watching it happen the next year — Barre got hit so bad this year, and it was the same roads that it was just hitting over and over again. They cleaned it up and then it comes again. That's not sustainable. We need to start thinking about how to fix this.
Gazo: I think the solution is challenging. What I would say the solution is not, is another tax to prevent some type of carbon emission from going into the stratosphere. I don't think that's a direct solution for the issues we're seeing with the floods and the result of global climate change, not just the climate change in Vermont. I don't have the solution to improve or repair our watersheds, to improve or repair our lakes at the moment, but what I would like to see is, instead of spending money on taking carbon emissions out of the environment, spend that money in repairing the culverts, repairing the systems, repairing the infrastructure around those flood zones, around those floodplains so that people in those areas can live in peace and some happiness. I'd also like to mention, I had a conversation last night with a gentleman on the Urban Search and Rescue Task Force in Vermont. It's basically a flood search and rescue team. They were down in North Carolina for the past 20 days. They saved hundreds, if not thousands, of lives, and their funding is quite low. If we're going to continue to see flooding in Vermont and at large in the rest of the region, I would really like to see commitment to some dollars going their way for training. They were down there for almost 20 days, and they train on a very tight budget, but they saved hundreds of lives. And I think that those are the things we really need to focus on. I'm not sure that there's an exact solution we can provide to stop flooding at this moment.
Sherman: I think we need to look a little farther back in history to understand why we're having this problem. When Vermont was founded, before it was Vermont, when New York and New Hampshire were arguing over who had the property rights, the settlers originally settled near the tops of most of the small hills, and they did so in order to mitigate any problems with flooding. This didn't work out so well, because their encampments and the lights showed the Native Americans where they were, and there were a lot of raiding parties. Now we don't have a problem with the Indians raiding our villages anymore, thank God. But we do have the remnants of these settlements in the valleys near waterways. It was beneficial when we used water for power and we had water wheels running our stuff, but it is no longer beneficial. So one of the things I think we could do is focus our attention on flooded properties and offer the people from those flooded properties a place to rebuild out of the floodplain, because rebuilding in a floodplain and waiting for the next flood, I don't really see as a sensible answer. We have plenty of land in Vermont. We have plenty of forested land in Vermont. We have plenty of places where people could build safe houses out of these flood zones. And I think that is the direction we should move, moving forward.
Critchlow: I just want to thank you again for having us tonight and allowing us to introduce ourselves to the voters. I think we all have a vested interest in the success of our brave little state, even if it gets flooded. I certainly don't profess to know it all. I don't know all the answers, but as a lifelong Vermonter, I am well aware of the problems. I am a thoughtful and civil-minded person who can easily work across the aisle, negotiate and see the greater good, and I have been known to change my mind. I've done that a lot. I appreciate listening to experts who bring in passion to their area of expertise. I'm very much a data-driven person who believes in trying something and then measuring the results. I will do my absolute best to make decisions that best serve Colchester and broadly Vermont. I'm asking for your vote, and pledge that any vote I cast in Montpelier will be for the greater good of Colchester.
Gazo: As I mentioned before, I'm born and raised in this state, here in this town. [Sherman] and myself, are two individuals that are committed to creating a more affordable state, to creating lower taxes and to creating a safer state. We are committed to supporting Phil Scott and his initiatives and working across the aisle to make those initiatives work for everybody. I will say I've spoken with many of you on the campaign trail, on your doorsteps, and I understand your frustration. As someone that's lived here my whole life, it’s something that I will put my effort towards in Montpelier, my hard work, my ethic and my experience. My family has generations in Vermont. We know what it's like to be a Vermonter. We know what it's like to go through tough times, and we know what it's like to come up with creative solutions, to adapt and address those problems in an effective and fiscally responsible manner.
Sherman: Wow. I don't create prepared remarks. I speak from my heart. I've been in this state close to 30 years, and like I said, I listened before I was willing to speak, I have watched the state drift farther and farther left, to the point where people are no longer reaching across the aisle for solutions. And I think that's a broken system. I think the governor is right. We need to put people in office to get rid of the Democratic supermajority, so people are forced to reach across the aisle and compromise more. I'm willing to be that guy. I've been studying my constituents. I've been talking to them, and the vast majority want a more affordable state, and they're concerned that all these heartfelt ideas that seem to be jacking up the costs of living here, are making it unaffordable, and it's not a sustainable path moving forward. So I would ask for your vote to send me to Montpelier, and I, like [Gazo], will work with the governor. I'll work with the Democrats, but I don't feel that having a supermajority that can force an agenda on the state is the proper path moving forward.
Austin: In my opening statement, I described my initiation into our Vermont legislature. To say I was in the weeds my first year as a new member is an understatement. If reelected, this will be my fourth session representing Colchester in Montpelier. I want to expand on why I'm running for reelection. I want to use the skills, knowledge and lessons learned and understandings I have acquired over the past six years to continue to make a certain vision of Vermont a reality. This is a vision where children, where child care is affordable and accessible, where access to affordable housing and rentals is available and costs are reasonable. Where our economy is growing, our workforce is evolving, and our business owners are thriving, a vision that works for all of us. Where when one of our family members or a member of our community is sick, we're able to access healthcare without worrying whether we have to choose between paying for our auto insurance or seeking the care we need. Where Vermonters and visitors can enjoy the wonder of our natural resources, clean water, pristine forest, snow covered mountains, while also intentionally balancing the expansion of housing in and around town and village centers, where also balancing the expansion of housing with the cost of providing equal access to educational opportunities is sustainable and affordable, and our 21st century schools are safe, secure, accessible to all and operational.
Those interested in learning more in advance of the Nov. 5 election can hear from their Chittenden 20 House candidates here and Grand Isle Senate candidates here.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here