Lawyer: Bay homeowners lost $4.5M

Posted

Less than a month after a mass eviction on Malletts Bay, dozens of former homeowners say they lost nearly $4.5 million combined and are seeking a payout from their insurance company using an unusual legal tactic.

Late last year, members of the Malletts Bay Homeowners Association filed a lawsuit against themselves in Vermont Superior Court, saying their own governing body’s “numerous and separate acts of negligence” caused the termination of their land lease.

Court documents show their provider, Hanover Insurance Company, agreed to defend MBHA against the current suit but retained an independent attorney, Tom Higgins, to act on behalf of the association – not the insurance company – in a limited appearance.

Last Wednesday, Higgins asked the court to appoint a receiver, saying he needed a client representative to effectively act on behalf of the association.

Yet all of the people who would naturally become defendants are currently acting as plaintiffs.

“There’s records, there’s information, there are facts about what happened here that I [am not] privy to,” Higgins said outside the courtroom. “There’s going to come a point when somebody is going to ask a question of the association that I don’t have the ability to answer.

“I don’t have that kind of relationship with the association,” Higgins continued. “I’m just their lawyer.”

After a back-and-forth in court about who exactly would pay for those services and whether the court had the authority to appoint a receiver at all, the MBHA’s lawyer, Pietro Lynn, urged Judge Robert A. Mello to rule quickly. He said many of his clients are struggling with extreme fiscal burdens.

“They have mortgages to pay, and they’re in a very, very difficult spot financially,” Lynn said. He said he’s representing all but “a few” homeowners from the association.

It’s been nearly a year since the Vermont Supreme Court ruled Mongeon Bay Properties LLC could void a land lease set to expire in 2036 and evict the owners of 28 summer and year-round homes from their lakefront properties.

The residents, all part of the MBHA, each held the deed to at least one structure in the eclectic neighborhood but had no legal ownership of the ground beneath them.

The Mongeon family has owned that seven-acre plot – which stretches along both sides of East Lakeshore Drive, Lone Birch Street and up Williams Road – since the 1920s.

The MBHA began carrying an insurance policy when it signed the lease 20 years ago, former homeowner Michael Carroll said in an interview last month.

When Tropical Storm Irene swept the region in 2011, the banks of four camps on the lakeside suffered. Mongeon Bay, led by Bruce Mongeon, eventually took the association to court, claiming their repairs did not satisfy the terms of the lease. He demanded they leave.

On appeal, Vermont Supreme Court justices sided with Mongeon. The homeowners were ordered out by April 30.

The newest complaint offers a total reversal of facts presented in that suit with Mongeon Bay, admitting fault in matters many of the homeowners continued to adamantly contest verbally as recently as last month.

The plaintiffs’ brief says the bank erosion “was the result of the MBHA’s failure to comply with its duties.” The suit also says the association “should have understood” their repairs “were not sufficient.”

The homeowners are seeking compensatory damages, attorney fees and costs, prejudgment interests and any other court-granted relief.

The land lease required association members to completely remove their homes from the land at its conclusion. Many watched as half a dozen homes were leveled by powerful construction equipment days before the eviction deadline.

Any structures that weren’t demolished were considered abandoned and repossessed by the landlord. Several homeowners said they took Mongeon up on his buyout offer, selling their houses for between $4,500 and $5,000.

Lynn said the $4.5 million assessment, determined by an appraiser, includes the value of every home, no matter the course of action owners chose to take at the end of the lease.

Even so, Lynn said their policy does not contain $4.5 million of insurance coverage, but a series of $1 million policies. How many of those policies may be triggered by the facts of this case remains to be seen, Lynn said.

“The company accepted that money gladly,” he said. “They have a responsibility to pay that out to the members that have suffered badly.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here