In last Tuesday’s general election, Vermont was the first state to be called for either of the presidential candidates, and, as expected, we went heavily for Hillary Clinton. Of all “blue” states, Vermont is the bluest.
But when the nation goes through an election as divisive and as epochal as the one we’ve just experienced, it’s useful to examine the entrails to see why what happened happened, and to ask if the dissatisfaction that propelled Donald Trump to victory is here as well.
Of all Vermont’s 14 counties, only Essex went for Trump, by a decisive 58-38 spread. Hillary Clinton won narrowly in Orleans, 47.2 percent to 46.9 percent. And she slipped past Trump in Franklin County by 3 percentage points and in Rutland County by 4 points.
That’s not terribly surprising, as these four counties are regarded as the state’s most conservative areas, and the northeast Kingdom is the state’s most sparsely populated.
If there is a common-denominator element between Mr. Trump’s win and our election results, it’s the urban/rural split, and it’s the so-called hollowing out of the middle class that is happening in Vermont as it is elsewhere.
It’s a trend that continues with the anticipation Vermont’s population will continue to lag that of the nation. It’s also projected that today’s youth will continue their migration to the city. We will be left with a population that continues to age at a faster rate than other states and one that is more expensive to service.
If this continues in Vermont, then we can expect Chittenden and surrounding counties to attract what little growth there is, with the rest of Vermont treading water or declining.
From a political perspective, that decline invites reassessment. As the economy continues its technological march toward increased mechanization, the most dramatic effect will be in our rural areas.
That’s most of Vermont.
We keep being told that technology will be our savior, that it will create more jobs than it destroys, but that’s not happening, and it’s becoming clear that the boom in technology has disproportionately benefited those at the top and not those in the middle or at the bottom.
The top five U.S. based technology companies – Apple, Google, Microsoft, Facebook and Oracle – have a combined stock value of almost $2 trillion, which is about 80 percent more than the five top tech companies in 2000. And they employ almost 25 percent fewer people now than they did then.
That’s just the beginning. Experts in the subject suggest we’re just at the forefront of a wave of technological improvements that will target professions long thought to be safe from technology. Programmers, engineers, architects and lawyers are all at risk as computers become more adept in figuring out our cognitive processes.
Amazon, as we know, uses 45,000 robots to deal with its order processing needs. The company expects to expand that number significantly and, in so doing, will employ fewer people. It’s called efficiency.
Robots are being used as night watchmen in malls. They are cheap. And effective. And they don’t take lunch breaks or spend time on their cell phones.
This technological march is ongoing, and it creates winners and losers. To date, the winners are in concentrated markets and are most commonly found on both coasts and in the cities (with obvious exceptions.) The losers are in the nation’s rural areas. The losers are those less educated and the ones less able to access the opportunities that come with scale.
That disparity is one of the characteristics of Donald Trump’s victory. He won where the opportunities are fewest.
Figuring out how to address these growing imbalances is central to his mission, and it will be overwhelming.
Vermont should not think it is immune from these same challenges. It isn’t. Our susceptibility is nothing Mr. Trump has exposed, and what most find objectionable about him still remains. But there is a reason Republican Phil Scott won by the margin he did, and there is a reason a noticeable percentage of the state’s vote went Mr. Trump’s way.
There is a great deal of economic uncertainty as we look forward, and addressing it is the state’s first responsibility.
Emerson Lynn is co-publisher of The Colchester Sun.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here