COLCHESTER — Over the next eight years, Colchester will roll out an emerald ash borer management plan that includes removing and replacing town ash trees.
Developed and proposed by town engineer Amanda Clayton and assistant town engineer Lea Sanguinetti, the plan was approved by the Colchester selectboard Dec. 12.
The emerald ash borer is a small, metallic green beetle about half an inch long which targets and kills ash trees. The wood-boring insect originally came from Asia and has since become an invasive species in North America.
It was likely first introduced in the 1900s in ash wood used for shipping pallets and packing materials from Asia. By May of 2021, the emerald ash borer was confirmed to be in Colchester — its presence first discovered by a volunteer Forest Pest First Detector. Emerald ash borer infestations have been detected in 36 states as well as in the District of Columbia and five Canadian provinces.
This insect is the primary cause of the extensive decline of the ash tree in the U.S. and beyond, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
Since its discovery, the emerald ash borer has killed tens of millions of ash trees and has cost municipalities, property owners, nursery operators and forest product industries tens of millions of dollars, according to the USDA.
Since the insect’s arrival in North America, communities across the continent have been unable to successfully eradicate its presence after detection.
After any given ash tree has been infested, the tree’s probability of dying is higher than 99%. Symptoms of infestation are challenging to assess in the early phases of infestation, which makes initial infestations difficult to determine.
By the time a tree is symptomatic, it is estimated that it was already infected for three to five years and in danger of a rapid decline, and likely death in the course of the next two to three.
In later phases of deterioration, these trees become a property, infrastructure and general public hazard, as the structural integrity of infested trees breaks down and they become brittle.
Colchester is 36.3 square miles and the majority of the community is forested, so it is estimated there are thousands of ash trees within the community.
Although private land mitigation options such as ordinances requiring protective or preventative measures were considered, the regulation, monitoring and enforcement of such a program would be extremely expensive and ineffective.
Most forested areas in Colchester are on private property and are therefore outside of the town’s direct purview or control, so mitigation options are limited — which in conjunction with the species’ rapid reproduction rate and ability to travel half a mile to several miles per year, is largely why communities have been unable to eradicate the bug.
Colchester’s Department of Public Works completed an inventory with the Vermont Urban and Community Forestry Program and student volunteers from the University of Vermont, identifying 446 ash trees within the town’s right-of-way and other town-owned property frequented by the public — areas deemed most crucial and viable to focus on, such as transportation corridors and parks.
This inventory accounted for about 860 acres of high-trafficked areas, though the town’s forested land makes up approximately 1,100 acres in total. The town subsequently hired Greenleaf Forestry to inventory the remaining areas in May and June of 2023.
Both phases utilized an ArcGIS Map tool called the Vermont Municipal Tree Inventory. A majority of all the ash trees accounted for in the inventory were found to be in good condition and are relatively young, within a range of six to twelve inches in diameter at breast height.
The mitigation strategies evaluated and considered following this inventory included:
Do nothing
Education and outreach
Treatment
Tree removal
Or replanting
Of the strategies listed, only the treatment and removal options were found to effectively address the threat to public safety and town-owned property frequented by the public.
However, given that chemical control treatments are needed every one to three years for the remaining life of any given tree, the trees can only be treated four to five times before removal becomes a more cost-effective option to eliminate the threat, as significant recurring costs of treating all these trees – at about $155 per tree – render the treatment option fiscally impractical, with the exception of trees deemed to have heritage, historic, memorial or otherwise significant value.
At this time, no such significant trees have been identified.
Without cost-effective treatment measures, the most effective and expedient means of eliminating public safety risks is to simply remove all ash trees as quickly as possible.
Though the removal must be done both quickly and comprehensively, replanting new trees can happen over a longer period of time and should be done selectively, Clayton and Sanguinetti state in their plan.
Of the 446 trees slated for removal, 116, or 26%, will be replaced as part of this plan. Replacing all 446 of them would cost about $535,200 in current dollars.
The trees to be replaced will be on the four residential roads with the most significant ash tree presence — Edgewood Drive, Wall Street, Abigail Drive and Winchester Place — as well as in Airport Park, and replanting efforts will be consistent with the town’s Street Tree Master Plan, which aims to increase the biodiversity of tree species throughout the town for improved future resilience. Specifically, the goal is to avoid any one genus having higher than 10% and any one species having higher than 5% of the total inventory of street trees in town.
The Colchester Department of Public Works intends to apply for $300,000 in grants for this project, to also be matched through $195,000 in local dollars. The grants would come from the Vermont Urban and Community Forestry Program and other sources.
Total completion of these stages of the plan is estimated to take about eight years.
The primary source of local funding will be through an annual request for year end fund balances from the town’s general fund. In the absence of those year end general fund balances, local funds would be requested through the annual general fund budget process.
On private property, identifying ash trees for treatment or removal by an arborist can reduce property-owners’ risk of incurring damage to their own property as well as protect their safety in the event of dropping branches — and further, reduce the continued spread of these invasives.
Other risks include aesthetic impacts of the loss of all nearby ash trees following the infection of one in a given area, as well as ecosystem service impacts such as a reduction in the overall tree canopy’s abilities to regulate surface temperatures, improve air and water quality and store carbon, not to mention the economic impact on property values.
Ash trees can be identified by their compound leaves and opposite branching pattern, in which twigs and buds grow directly across from each other rather than with staggered or alternate branching. The bark on a mature ash tree has a distinct diamond-shaped ridge pattern, though the bark of younger trees is relatively smooth.
While ash trees may have eastern ash borers present for a few years prior to the appearance of symptoms, increased woodpecker foraging may be an early sign of infestation.
Typically the first more noticeable and surefire signs of infestation are delayed leaf-out in spring, thinning canopy or crown, bark splits and epicormic shoots, although these symptoms only show up after infestation has become moderate to high.
Additional signs include S-shaped galleries and D-shaped exit holes. Emerald ash borers begin to emerge from ash trees in late May and will continue to emerge, mate and lay eggs through late summer, between August and September.
A more comprehensive outreach and education plan from the town is tentatively slated to come in the future, to be directed at private landowners by way of the town newsletter and on the town website, with the outreach strategy to direct property owners to existing resources from subject matter experts, including Emerald Ash Borer Network, Vermont Invasives and the Vermont Urban and Community Forestry Program’s emerald ash borer management webpage.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here