Editor's note: This story was updated Aug. 30 at 10:19 a.m. to correct the name of an organization mentioned.
COLCHESTER — A week ago, a woman from Westbury Mobile Home Park stepped up to the microphone at the Aug. 22 selectboard meeting to request the park be made an incorporated village of Colchester.
For her, Westbury is a desert devoid of municipal services, and she’s tired of the back and forth discussions the issue has caused.
“It's been 24 months since the discussion by residents took hold, 15 months since we came before you to ask for guidance and assistance and 12 months since you issued an opinion letter to the members of our neighborhood,” said Gayle Pezzo, Westbury resident and village project team leader. “We're here tonight to present to you a petition.”
Following Pezzo’s remarks, two other residents present at the meeting placed the petition — a thick stack of paper bound in teal ribbon — on the table between Town Manager Aaron Frank and Deputy Town Manager Renae Marshall.
Their petition to form an incorporated village had garnered signatures from a 72% majority of Westbury’s voting body, with 246 signatures out of 345 eligible voting residents.
Why form a village?
Those behind the effort say it could specifically lower the cost of the residents’ water utility. More broadly, it could aid in solving an equity issue and relieve its working class residents of financial burdens that many other Colchester residents are not responsible for to begin with.
Why the lack of support from the town?
The town is “perplexed” by the assertion that a village would be the appropriate tool to address these financial concerns, according to an Aug. 22, 2022 letter to Pezzo from selectboard chair Pam Loranger.
Pezzo’s request was made during public forum on Aug. 22 instead of during the meeting because she had only asked to be added to the agenda four days prior to the meeting.
Frank told Pezzo as well as the Sun that by the time she had asked, it was too late to add new items to the agenda, prompting Pezzo and a handful of others from Westbury to make their case during the citizen’s to be heard portion of the meeting.
The formation of a village requires a majority of signatures from residents, which the Village Project now has. Pezzo asked the selectboard to approve the incorporation of the village at its next meeting, Sept. 26.
In the meantime, residents await confirmation from the town and reflect on the work that’s been done up to this point.
In 2018, Westbury Mobile Home Park was put up for sale. Because of Vermont law — 10 VSA 6242 — the residents were allowed to compete with developers to buy the park.
The residents formed a co-op, won the bidding process and sealed the deal to purchase the park in March 2019 with the help of the Cooperative Development Institute and ROC USA, the latter of which provided Westbury with its mortgage loan as well as the business model for resident ownership.
Had an outside developer won out, residents could have been displaced or the park dissolved. Mobile homes not strong enough to be moved and mobile homeowners unable to find another place to move their home to, would have had their homes scrapped.
Residents now collectively set their own lot prices and invest those funds back into park infrastructure without concern about potential neglect, financial exploitation or poor maintenance jobs from an external private investor.
The collective purchase of the park and establishment of a co-op had to be done with the agreement of 650 families within just six and a half weeks, and the co-op had to pay three times the assessed value — roughly $8 million more than the value placed on the park by the Town — in order to keep outside developers at bay.
This took about $45,000 per family in funds raised or borrowed.
Now, the collectively-owned co-op is known as Westbury Home Owners Association, but purchasing the park left residents with very little reserves for the work ahead.
In the hustle to compete with developers, there was no time to figure out how services like roads, drinking water or wastewater would best fit into the equation.
“With a leap of faith (and no other options) the non-profit co-op we formed took responsibility for all aspects of the community,” stated the contributors to the About page of the Westbury Village Project website. “Because, unlike potential developers, our core mission was to keep our community alive.”
The co-op now manages services on behalf of Westbury, which is a community with a population of more than 500 — a larger population than that of 50 individual towns in Vermont, according to the website. Many of these services are the kind of services routinely taken on by municipalities in Vermont.
As it currently stands, Westbury continues to have unique challenges, as its residents are now expected to manage four and a half miles of road, a water distribution system with more than seven miles of pipe, wastewater for 250 homes, as well as other infrastructure.
In other neighborhoods, costs for roads and infrastructure are paid by local tax dollars.
Despite being Colchester taxpayers, and despite having no gates or “keep out” signage, due to its technical categorization as a private community, working class Westbury residents are burdened with the responsibility of paying for all of it.
To remain what residents consider to be a critical source of working class housing in the Town of Colchester, Westbury’s Village Project backers say they need to finish what was started in 2018 when residents beat out developers, by becoming a public neighborhood.
Over the course of the last couple of years, the town ended its provision of publicly paid plowing to the private roads in Westbury Park, and later took a stance against incorporating the Westbury region as a village — the ongoing effort intended to make the roads public and eligible to qualify for wholesale, municipal pricing on water.
Since 1970, the town had paid for winter road maintenance to about a third of the private roads in Colchester. In 2016, the town received petitions from residents on private roads without public plowing who claimed unfair treatment, so the selectboard discontinued its plowing of private roads.
Westbury residents’ tax dollars continue to fund plowing to public roads.
As it currently stands, the residents of Westbury also pay high private rates for their water utility, which isn’t abnormal for private residents in general.
However, most Colchester residents live on publicly-managed roads, so when a pipe bursts or the system needs maintenance, it is the town’s job to fund the provision of repairs.
Villages exist as political subunits established at the request of the residents and are intended to assist areas with unique challenges and needs compared to the surrounding community, according to the Village Project website.
Forming a village could, in theory, allow residents to partner or contract with the town to receive services from public entities that are better equipped to handle provision of these services, as well as render residents eligible for state funding and grants to maintain infrastructure.
Pezzo does not foresee any reason why the formation of the village would come at a price to the town itself, as Westbury residents and taxpayers would remain voters and taxpayers of the town, with all obligations remaining in place except for those explicitly granted to the village.
The park residents’ stance is that if the town is unable to take on the responsibility of managing services and infrastructure they manage elsewhere in town for other residents, Westbury will need to take matters into its own hands to take on this challenge.
To that end, residents have requested support from the town as a partner in establishing an incorporated village, claiming the town has a history of working with other municipalities.
Westbury residents believe this partnership would serve the common good of Westbury residents as well as Colchester residents outside of the Westbury region, and that this path would strengthen the community inpromoting greater participation, equal voice and shared responsibility.
If the residents of Westbury create a village, the co-op can hand over certain “public services” to the village, so the village can take care of the residents of the Village of Westbury using resources that are only available to municipalities.
The first time Pezzo brought the case for an incorporated village to the Colchester selectboard, she was not met with support for this goal, nor was the town willing to consider the kind of partnership Pezzo and the Village Project had envisioned.
Rather, she was countered with a number of feasibility questions and an ultimate assessment from the selectboard that this route does not make sense for either her community in Westbury or for the broader Colchester community.
Fourteen residents and interested parties from Cooperative Development Institute, Champlain Valley Office of Economic Opportunity and law firm Tarrant, Gillies and Shems attended a Colchester selectboard meeting back in April to ask the town for support in researching a model for the village that could maximize the public good for Colchester.
In August of last year, the Town of Colchester publicly came out against the effort to incorporate a village, stating the town would not be interested in providing services under contract to a village at Westbury or any other village in the Town of Colchester.
At the time of the last correspondence about the Village Project, Loranger stated the selectboard’s reasoning against the formation of the village, and said the town was not interested in contracting with a village to provide municipal services due to increased liability.
The town’s reason for not backing the formation of a village up to this point, according to Loranger’s letter containing the selectboard’s assessment, are because the members of Colchester’s selectboard believe the following:
A single resident-owned, private, not-for-profit corporation has significant control over the property that would become a village, granting a private organization unreasonable control over a public village;
As an incorporated association that levies regular fees to its owners through lot rents, the same tool used by the prior for-profit owners, Westbury already has an efficient mechanism by which to collect funds for jointly funded services and infrastructure;
Westbury had the opportunity for the land to be owned by a government-controlled entity, the Vermont State Housing Authority, that would have provided government backed management, infrastructure planning and development, and other services as it does to Windemere Mobile Home Park in Colchester and other entities in the state, but the choice to instead establish a private co-op came with responsibilities for the residents — with the responsibility of managing a government being even greater;
The co-op cannot just push back and forth responsibilities to and from a village as it best benefits the co-op from a fiscal perspective and a village would have to have very defined responsibilities that often take years to change;
Even the simplest municipal village would include at the minimum a clerk, a treasurer, a lister, boards that handle abatement requests, assessment and tax appeals, a tax collector, a qualified government accountant, a government auditor, a grant administrator and a government general manager;
Although governments do often contract with such entities to deliver services, they do not conventionally come to be specifically to deliver a small suite of services to an individual private or non-profit entity;
If Westbury’s roads became public, its residents would need to hire engineers to study speed limits to make them enforceable under law and in traffic court, and speed limits below 25 miles per hour are difficult to approve and enforce as a municipality;
Grant funding for ongoing operations by municipalities are almost non-existent and those that exist are expensive to administer especially on a small scale.
For example, the grant from the State Agency of Transportation is about $1,600 per mile, or about $4,800 per year for Westbury’s roadways and comes with complex paperwork, reporting and financial auditing requirements that could cost more than $4,800 to comply with.
Westbury’s Village Project believes the Town would contract with the village to plow for around $4,800, the value of the possible state grant, which seems to be based on a misunderstanding related to the Town’s budget reduction following its discontinuance of plowing some of the private roads.
The town reduced the budget by $19,300 after that discontinuance, but that did not represent the cost of plowing 15 of the 44 miles of plowing private roads, but rather solely the external and overtime costs of doing so — the town applied the fixed capital and non-overtime labor costs to better maintain the public roads, but that figure is not representative of the total cost to plow and maintain public roads by mile.
The Westbury residents involved in the Village Project disagree with the reasons listed in the letter and continue to forge ahead in hopes that by the time of its next meeting on Sept. 26, the selectboard will reconsider its stance on the subject.
Pezzo said she believes the town made several errors in the calculations included in its letter, and feels that the formation of a village would still be worthwhile — in spite of the known added responsibilities for Westbury residents in organizing and managing a village.
She believes there is an important distinction between the co-op and the village, both of which would function to serve residents — as both co-ops and governments intend to do, regardless of whether the village is a conventional choice for Westbury’s unique community.
The co-op is a non-profit entity that homeowners buy into, as there are 251 homes in the proposed village, which means there are no more than 251 co-op voters.
“If the Town is suggesting that the co-op exists so there is no reason to form a village, I would propose that it would be similar to someone suggesting only homeowners should be able to vote in Colchester elections,” Pezzo stated in an Aug. 23 email.
The co-op does not wish to become a municipal entity, but rather, is interested in finding a way for certain services it currently provides and some infrastructure that it currently manages to be offered publically to Colchester residents who live in Westbury.
“This is not about financial benefit for the co-op or any private entity,” Pezzo stated in a letter to Frank and the selectboard last April. “This is specifically about providing public services for residents of Colchester that the Town does not or cannot provide to the Colchester residents that live in Westbury.”
Those involved in the Village Project have spent two years researching other small municipalities and villages nationwide and say the formation of a small village for the sake of receipt of a reduced, wholesale rate on a water utility has been done before, just not in Vermont.
A similar thing has been done in Crossroads Cooperative in Great Falls, Montana, Pezzo said.
Westbury residents expect and are prepared for the hard work ahead of them, she said.
Pezzo also believes the selectboard was mistaken about whether the VSHA had offered to buy the land, but that the Housing Foundation Inc., had offered to do so. The HFI was unfortunately unable to come up with the money in time to beat out developers who were standing in line, leaving the formation of a co-op as its only option at the time of its formation.
Right now, by Pezzo’s calculations, the cost of drinking water for a home in Westbury is $798 per year as compared to $460 per year for a family living 200 feet outside of the Westbury neighborhood — with the Westbury number calculated based on retail rate plus operations, maintenance and asset management modeling.
The comparison was made using 168 gallons per day which is an average use for homes on the Westbury Park water system, compared to the rate model for the water system that brings water to the area, Colchester Fire District #3.
“We have worked hard and come a long way since staving off eviction in 2018 from speculative developers but we are often reminded by things like the difference in cost of water for a family in our neighborhood vs. other neighborhoods that there are still inequalities,” Pezzo stated in her email to the Sun. “Until we are able to have discussions in a municipal forum we will not have achieved equality in the community or across the town.”
Pezzo hopes the town will acknowledge the democratic collection of signatures from the majority of Westbury residents and support the formation of a village, and that it will work with the village as a partner to find ways to collaborate on providing for citizens moving forward.
At this point, residents are focused on the formation of a village to ensure that all residents of voting age can have an equal voice in decisions surrounding how to bring safe, affordable drinking water to these homes.
Residents have discussed how, conceptually, the village could contract with the town to receive other municipal services. However, Pezzo believes this to be an unlikely outcome.
“The Town of Colchester made it clear in their opinion letter last August that they do not want to partner with a village,” she stated in her email. “Based on that, it is the end of the story for a discussion of how partnership on roads or sewer might help the Colchester residents and help the Town fulfill its mission statement.”
This is despite the fact that other private communities, another mobile home co-op known as Breezy Acres in particular, benefit from Colchester’s municipal sewer, Pezzo said.
However, the town isn’t the only entity Westbury residents require better cooperation from. There are other roadblocks beyond that in achieving the financial goals of the village.
The Champlain Water District’s board of commissioners at this time does not support giving Westbury the wholesale water rate that it gives to many municipalities if it were to become a village, according to a Feb. 6 letter from Joseph Duncan, CWD general manager, the contractor that provides water to Colchester and other towns and is hooked up to the pipes at Westbury.
If CWD does not change its stance, the purpose of establishing a village to obtain wholesale water rates would be rendered null.
The reason for CWD’s position is it considers Westbury to be a customer of CFD #3, and CWD functions on a model by which it sells water at a wholesale rate to city and town-owned water systems.
The idea of adding another separate municipal entity — which happens to be encompassed by a single property owner, the co-op at Westbury within the Town of Colchester — runs counter to what CWD’s Board of Commissioners has been trying to achieve by providing wholesale water to large municipal areas through town-wide, locally-owned distribution systems.
The board of directors at CWD feels strongly that allowing homeowners associations to become municipal villages is not in the best interest of the communities it serves, because in Vermont, and historically in Colchester, the capacity to maintain the necessary leadership and structure to operate small fragmented systems owned and operated by small villages or fire districts breaks down over time and puts the systems and their users at risk, according to Duncan’s letter.
The Champlain Water District controls four of the six local water supply systems in Colchester and is working to consolidate them to turn ownership over to the Town, which Loranger stated in a Town report has simplified billing and repair, as well as upgrades and capital planning.
The reason why CWD currently owns four water systems in Colchester is because the leadership that ran those systems for years could not find the next generation of leaders to step up, according to Duncan’s letter.
Officials at CWD worry that a municipal village has the potential to fracture town structures that CWD believes to be critical for the long-term operation of a water system.
However, Pezzo sees no harm in providing lower prices on water to a uniquely structured working class neighborhood, and feels that regardless of system ownership, it is not in anyone’s best interest for CWD to deny the hypothetical Village of Westbury access to wholesale rates on water that other small municipalities — such as the Village of Jericho — are granted.
“Through all the complexity of how we have come to where we are right now, what we have here is a pretty simple story,” Pezzo stated in her Aug. 23 email to the Sun. “We are residents within a Town that has specific needs for municipal services the Town has said they cannot or will not assist with. Vermont has specific laws to address this kind of situation by the formation of a municipal village.”
Pezzo hopes to continue negotiations following the incorporation of a village at Westbury. Based on the statute 24 VSA 1304, it is the residents’ understanding that upon receipt of a petition from a majority of the voters living within the area described in the petition, the selectboard shall create the village.
Pezzo also believes respect and cooperation is important in any process.
“We accept that the Town does not want to assist our efforts,” Pezzo stated. “What we are asking the town for is support of our right to advocate for ourselves.”
Should an official village be created at the Sept. 26 selectboard meeting, the proposed date, time and place for the first meeting of the village is 1p.m. on Nov. 11, 2023 at 289 Coventry Road in Colchester.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here