Gov. Scott’s $9 billion budget proposal draws anger and approval from legislators and interest groups

Posted

MONTPELIER – Gov. Phil Scott unveiled his administration’s $9 billion fiscal year 2026 budget proposal to legislators earlier this week.

Scott addressed the General Assembly in the House Chamber Jan. 28, almost immediately diving into the issues of affordability, demographics and education in the state.

“Taxpayers also made it clear they want us to fix broken systems, not just fund them,” he said. “This session won’t be easy because we’re expected to solve big problems. But if we stay focused and you put your community and the wellbeing of the entire state first, we will deliver the brighter future Vermonters asked for and deserve.”

Republicans throughout the state, including the governor, campaigned heavily this past election cycle on the affordability of Vermont. That messaging helped Republicans tear through the Democrat controlled supermajority in the legislature.

The budget proposed by the governor’s administration would increase state spending around 5% over last year.

Education pushback

One of the biggest challenges the state faces is the way it funds its education system. Last year, budgets in Franklin County and across the state failed multiple times at re-votes.

In his budget address, Scott said of the proposal, $5.9 billion dollars comes from Vermont’s taxpayers, yet the education fund totals $2.4 billion – eating up a significant portion of the state’s money.

“Our kids are not getting what they deserve from the $2.4 billion we spend. Neither are teachers or taxpayers,” Scott said. “The reason is an approach to financing that drives up costs and fuels inequality, along with a structure that’s far too big for a declining number of students.”

But, Scott said there is good news from this election. With the Democratic supermajority toppled, the state assembly can work bi-partisanly to solve issues in education funding and academic standards.

Scott’s administration has already laid out a plan with changes including the consolidation of the state’s many schools and districts into just five. Franklin County schools would be included in the Champlain Valley district, grouped with Grand Isle and Chittenden counties.

“The bottom line is, we are committed to seeing this through with the least amount of disruption for kids, teachers, schools and taxpayers,” he said. “If we fail to make meaningful changes, we will be right back where we started with higher and higher costs every year.”

Sarah Lyons, director of operations, at the Public Assets Institute – a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization promoting economic policies in the state – said it is clear, Vermonters want good schools and fair taxes, however, the governor's plans aren’t clear.

“Gov. Phil Scott said again today he would reform education by doing more with less,” she said in a statement. “While we don’t know all the details yet, we’ve heard this promise before and don’t have a lot to show for it.”

While the legislature works to “fix” the education system, Scott said his budget will use $77 million in the general fund to eliminate this year’s property tax increase. However, in order to fully buy down the increase, administration officials said the budget proposes ending the universal school meals program in Vermont.

Vermont was the sixth state in the country to enact a permanent universal school meals program in 2023 – without a signature from the governor.

However, Hunger Free Vermont, a statewide advocacy nonprofit, said the program costs 40% less than originally projected and accounts for less than 1% of total education fund spending.

Almost immediately, the advocacy group asked for Scott to repeal his proposal to end the program. In a statement, the organization said the universal school meals program has proven value already with students less stressed and nurse visits and behavioral issues decreased.

The nonprofit added the Listen and Learn Tour, headed by Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders, highlighted statements on the positive impact of the program.

“This cruel proposal will not save money, but it will increase stress on families, teachers and school administration,” Hunger Free Vermont’s executive director Anore Horton stated. “It will take food out of the mouths of students, many of whom have never known what a school day looks like without universal school meals.”

Climate issues

Another policy which has seen the ire of both voters and the governor has to do with climate. Scott has no issue supporting climate resiliency, however, he said the state cannot afford to do the work and would rather pass it on to federal resources.

“Reducing emissions is a goal we share,” he said. “Where we differed is how to get there, because when people can’t afford it, we can’t achieve it.”

In order to change the high price of climate change, Scott took aim at the Global Warming Solutions Act. Scott said the state should follow the U.S. Climate Alliance when tracking goals for net emissions and not gross.

Gross emissions are the total amount from a source, while net emissions are the total minus anything removed through carbon offsets and renewable energy.

Scott also took issue with the “arbitrary” deadlines set in the act and said instead he will direct the Agency of Natural Resources to develop a plan to reach 2050 climate goals.

“This is what we did for clean water, and just like our clean water plan, we can do it without costing Vermonters more,” he said.

In his budget speech, Scott said he wanted to change some of Vermont’s climate policies. Specifically, he pointed to last year’s Renewable Energy Standard, and the climate superfund bill – which allows the state to recover financial damages from fossil fuel companies.

Although Scott said his interest is in taxpayers and not making “national headlines,” environmental and business groups took issue with his standing.

“Budgets are a reflection of values and priorities and it is clear that on climate, Gov. Scott’s budget aligns more with President Trump and the Republican party than with the needs of working families,” Ben Edgerly Walsh, climate and energy program director at Vermont Public Interest Research Group, stated. “Anyone who believes Vermonters want their lawmakers to take their cues from Trump’s MAGA agenda is seriously misreading the situation.”

Others like Montpelier city councilor and executive director of the Vermont Natural Resources Council, Lauren Hirel said as someone from a flood-devistated community with a budget shortfall, the cost of climate change is being lifted by those residents.

Hirel also questioned why the state should cancel efforts to hold oil companies accountable for the damage their products have caused.

Scott’s approval

Not everyone who listened to the governor’s speech was left questioning some of the budget proposal, however.

The National Federation of Independent Businesses said it applauds the administration's approach to property tax reform and budgeting.

“Gov. Scott recognizes that Vermont’s small businesses cannot endure additional cost increases or tax hikes,” director John Reynolds said in a statement. “Vermont small business owners look to the legislature to follow the governor’s lead and not consider any tax increases, additional burdens that would in no way make the Green Mountain State more affordable.”

Republicans in the House and Senate in a joint statement said the governor’s proposal noted the importance of not just funding existing problems but in fixing them with new legislation and repealing other programs.

The joint statement said the governor and Republicans in the General Assembly continue to be focused on four main goals: education funding, housing, public safety and energy affordability.

“With Gov. Scott’s lead, House and Senate Republicans are prepared to address all of these issues this session to deliver better education that is cost-effective, more affordable housing, safer streets and a cleaner climate without raising taxes or fees,” the statement reads.

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here