Fort Ethan Allen property owner wants business-friendly zoning

Posted

Essex’s main property owner in Fort Ethan Allen is requesting a zoning change that he believes would allow him to fill his now-vacant buildings. The town, however, says he can already do what he’s asking for under current rules.

For over 20 years, William Parkinson has owned a dozen buildings between the University of Vermont properties and the water tower in the small portion of the fort located in Essex.

Historically, the industrial zoning that governed his properties made sense, he said, but over the years, his century-old buildings no longer fit the needs of today’s users. They want their buildings with high ceilings and concrete slabs suitable for forklifts, not four-foot foundations below post-and-beam construction.

Parkinson is now suggesting the town of Essex change zoning to a mix that includes business, which he says would allow greater opportunity for new tenants while still maintaining options for industrial use. Some examples he listed include an art studio, antique store or coffee-sandwich shop.

Bordering the fort zone is a larger business district that begins with Lowe’s and heads down Susie Wilson Road to Kellogg Road, making a business/industrial district a logical transition, Parkinson said.

A zoning shift would better align Essex’s regulations with Colchester’s. Sarah Hadd, Colchester director of planning and zoning, said the Colchester Town Plan envisions a village mixed-use district with a range of commercial, light industry and multi-family dwelling development in the fort.

For Parkinson, it’s a good time for change. His buildings on Laurette Drive will soon be vacant — an area prime for retail given its proximity to Route 15 —  and he suspects UVM is pushing to sell off its properties. He’d like to purchase those, too, but only if he has more versatility.

Essex planning commissioners have seemed amenable to Parkinson’s suggestions, he said, though nothing has come of his previous calls for rezoning. When he approached the selectboard several years ago, members asked to hear from the economic development commission.

Parkinson is now asking EDC members, whom he views as the most logical supporters of business-friendly changes, to recommend a reexamination of the fort zoning.

EDC members tabled an advisory memo on the matter last month, citing concerns about spot zoning — Parkinson says he wants the entire zone to change, not just his properties — and an uncertainty over whether his plans are already allowed under current zoning.

Town staff maintain it is. They cite an industrial zoning provision called the “neighborhood shopping center,” which allows for various types of retail and personal service facilities if they serve primarily the residential development surrounding it (think Healthy Living vs. University Mall in South Burlington).

“We’ve told him it can be done, and he doesn’t seem to have responded well to that,” town planner Darren Schibler said.

He notes uses like art galleries and breweries would be allowed under the neighborhood shopping designation if there’s both a production and sales area, though the latter couldn’t actually serve alcohol on site because restaurants aren’t allowed.

Yet Parkinson believes calling his properties a neighborhood shopping center would be disingenuous given their location. He also believes it would continue to limit his options.

“If an art studio was in there, clearly the vast majority of customers are not going to be in the adjacent neighborhood,” he said.

And a retail-manufacturing set up isn’t practical, Parkinson said. Even if a coffee shop mostly served the neighborhood, he’s not allowed to put one in unless it’s attached to another business, like a supermarket or a convenience store.

Parkinson said he isn’t looking for any high-traffic stores and understands certain kinds of retail won’t fit. But if he continues as-is, his buildings will remain vacant. One has already sat empty for six years.

“I am not being a good steward by letting them sit vacant – they should be occupied,” he said.

Schibler said the community development department hopes to reexamine allowed uses in the entire town in the next few years. For now, however, planners are focused on the Essex Town Center, which is currently undergoing its own rezoning process.

“We’ll get to it,” Schibler said.

Parkinson’s patience, meanwhile, appears to be dwindling.

“Not only is it a total waste, but at some point I’m going to get mad enough to stop maintaining them,” he said. “And that is the entrance to Essex.”

Asked if he’s shared that sentiment with the town, he said he’s “joked about it” to some people.

“But I think everybody knows I love the fort too much,” he said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here