Federal shutdown hits the Green Mountain State, Vermont’s senators push back

Posted

CHITTENDEN COUNTY — As the shutdown comes — no matter who gets blamed for it — the impacts are simple.

Your taxes will go up. When things break down, there’s always a cost.

Tuesday night, Congress voted itself into deadlock as senators look to weigh voter sentiment against each other’s government funding plans. Each party blames the other, although Republicans are solidly in charge of the government.

“We can get rid of a lot of things that we didn’t want and they’d be Democrat things,” President Donald Trump told reporters Tuesday as the threat of the shutdown loomed. “They just don’t learn. So we have no choice. I have to do that for the country.”

The political debate

“Here’s the bottom line. In a few hours, tonight at midnight. It’s very likely the United States government is going to shut down,” Bernie Sanders, the independent senator from Vermont, said late Tuesday afternoon, speaking during a livestream.

He was flanked by his Congressional colleagues. Many of them — like Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Massachusetts) — have been pushing back against wealth concentration for years, but this time around, they argue health care will become even more of a luxury if Republicans are able to pass their funding bill and pull roughly a trillion dollars out of the U.S. health care system via Medicare cuts.

“People who have been watching can see we’re in a fighting mood. And I’ll tell you why: it is a rip-off, what is going on — this transfer of wealth with the billionaire tax cut, and then cutting health care to pay for it,” Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vermont) said. “On the cost … a Vermont family making $82,000 — a family of four — their premiums can go up $20,000 a year.”

Meanwhile, Republican politicians are looking to pin the blame on Democratic politicians, as if the results of the 2024 presidential election has removed all the legal standards and norms provided by the separation of powers.

So what does that mean for American taxpayers?

If 2018-2019’s shutdown is any indication, it will likely mean delayed services, higher costs and lower GDP. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that $3 billion in economic activity dried up in Trump’s first term due to the federal government shutting down for five weeks.

And this time around, all signs point to this one being a doozy, as both sides don’t have much reason to capitulate.

Republican politicians sit in the positions leading all three branches of the federal government, and while public support for Trump’s agenda has waned — the majority of people now disapprove of his administration, according to The Economist — top federal officials have been largely playing the blame game to get Democrats to agree to Medicare cuts.

Meanwhile, top Congressional Democrats argue the president’s lawlessness has warped any predilection for fair play.

“Past shutdowns have been avoided and solved by a negotiation between Republicans and Democrats, but this time is different,” Welch said. “President Trump has made it clear he has no interest in working with us, telling Congressional Republicans, ‘Don’t even bother dealing with them.’”

Trump has threatened extensive cuts to other government services under executive purview if Democrats don’t vote for his bill, although that hasn’t been particularly effective at the negotiating table. There’s no evidence Trump needs a shutdown — nor any legal mechanism — to make the cuts.

On day one in office, Trump put tech billionaire Elon Musk in charge of a federal agency that dismantled multiple government offices, including the U.S. Agency for International Development. Since that time, a federal judge ruled the administration’s shuttering of the agency was likely illegal.

Republicans in Congress, meanwhile, have largely shrugged at the overreach, as warehouses full of medical supplies paid for by U.S. taxpayers rot overseas.

Disruptions incoming

According to Vermont’s labor statistics, Chittenden County has just over 2,500 federal employees, categorized as working in either public administration or transportation.

Knowing how each job is affected by the shutdown, however, likely comes down to what each agency does, as “essential services” remain open.

For example, people can expect the U.S. Postal Service to continue without disruption. The federal service agency released a statement to that effect last week as the talk of a widescale shutdown began.

"Because we are an independent entity that is generally funded through the sale of our products and services, and not by tax dollars, our services will not be impacted by a government shutdown," the statement read.

Most Department of Homeland Security employees will also remain at their posts, although about one in 10 are furloughed by the shutdown.

This includes U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents. Out of the roughly 68,000 employed by the federal agency, over 63,000 are expected to continue to go to work.

Instead, the most impacted by the government shutdown are those deemed to be nonessential by federal officials. This includes wide swathes of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife’s refuge system.

The government agency is being ordered to close refuge units until the assistant secretary of the department can determine that activities resumed will not cause additional funds to be obligated. A call placed to the Missisquoi Wildlife Refuge in Swanton went unanswered early Wednesday afternoon.

As for government support systems like social security, these services are expected to continue to operate, with social security and Medicare payments still coming down the line.

With that said, it’s hard to say exactly what cracks might show in the system if the shutdown continues without a solution. In 2019, the delivery of SNAP benefits slowed down at the tail-end of the shutdown, as well as caused disruptions in air travel thanks to no-show employees at the Transportation Security Administration.

The Vermont Chamber of Commerce is also warning about potential business impacts, such as delays in federal payments, agency approvals, federal grant programs and some nutrition, housing and healthcare systems.

When the shutdown will end, however, is anybody’s guess. To fund the federal government, Congressional leaders will need to gather 60 votes to move forward, and the political pressures will be immense in today’s day and age.

Vermont’s senators though agree the fight is worth it for their constituents in the Green Mountain State. With the cuts proposed by Senate Republicans, Vermont’s politicians are making the case the state’s health care system will face even more stress thanks to the cuts at a time when rural hospitals are already stretched.

“This trillion dollars in cuts in Medicaid — you know, a $150 billion out of the hospitals — it’s not just a $150 billion out of the hospitals, because all those folks who used to have Medicaid are going to still get sick and show up at our community hospitals and get treated,” Welch said. “And our hospitals will provide that care as long as they can, but there’ll come a point where they’re bankrupt. I mean, that’s literally what we’re talking about.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here